A Strange Story by Bulwer-Lytton: Complete Guide to the Victorian Occult Novel

Overview

A Strange Story was serialised in Charles Dickens's magazine All the Year Round from August 1861 to March 1862, and published as a novel in 1862. It appeared at a remarkable moment in Victorian intellectual history: the decade following Darwin's Origin of Species (1859), when the conflict between scientific materialism and religious/spiritual worldviews was at its most intense.

Bulwer-Lytton positioned the novel deliberately within this conflict. Its protagonist, Dr. Allen Fenwick, is a physician and committed materialist who has publicly argued that consciousness is nothing more than a product of brain chemistry and that claims of supernatural phenomena are the products of credulity, fraud, or mental illness. The novel then systematically confronts Fenwick with experiences that his materialist framework cannot accommodate, forcing him to expand his understanding of reality or be destroyed by his own rigidity.

The novel's antagonist, Margrave, is one of the most original villains in Victorian fiction: beautiful, charming, and possessed of genuine occult powers, yet utterly amoral and driven by a single, obsessive goal. He represents the danger that occult knowledge poses when separated from moral development, a theme that runs through all of Bulwer-Lytton's esoteric fiction and that reflects concerns within the Western esoteric tradition itself about the misuse of spiritual power.

The novel is less well known than Bulwer-Lytton's other works (The Last Days of Pompeii, The Coming Race, Zanoni), but within the esoteric tradition, it is regarded as one of his most significant achievements: a sustained fictional exploration of the relationship between scientific knowledge, occult experience, and moral responsibility.

Bulwer-Lytton: Novelist and Occultist

Edward George Earle Lytton Bulwer-Lytton, 1st Baron Lytton (1803-1873), was one of the most successful and versatile writers of the Victorian era. He produced novels, plays, poetry, and essays across four decades, and his works were bestsellers in Britain, America, and on the Continent. He also served as a Member of Parliament and as Secretary of State for the Colonies (1858-1859), during which time he played a role in the establishment of British Columbia.

But Bulwer-Lytton's public career as novelist and politician was only half the story. He was also a serious student and practitioner of the Western esoteric tradition:

Rosicrucian membership: Bulwer-Lytton was initiated into a Rosicrucian lodge (possibly the Societas Rosicruciana in Anglia, founded 1866, or an earlier, less formal group). The Rosicrucian tradition, with its emphasis on spiritual alchemy, the unity of science and mysticism, and the existence of a hidden brotherhood of initiates, shaped his novels profoundly.

Study with Eliphas Levi: The French ceremonial magician Alphonse Louis Constant (pen name Eliphas Levi), author of Dogme et Rituel de la Haute Magie (1854-1856), visited Bulwer-Lytton in England and maintained a correspondence with him. Levi's synthesis of Kabbalah, Tarot, and ceremonial magic influenced Bulwer-Lytton's understanding of occult power, and echoes of Levi's teachings appear throughout A Strange Story.

Mesmerism: Bulwer-Lytton was a practitioner of mesmerism (animal magnetism) at a time when it was considered disreputable by mainstream science but was attracting serious interest from some physicians, philosophers, and spiritual seekers. He attended mesmeric demonstrations, experimented with mesmeric techniques, and treated mesmerism in his fiction as a genuine faculty rather than a fraud.

The "occult novel" genre: Bulwer-Lytton effectively invented the occult novel as a literary form: fiction that uses narrative to encode genuine esoteric teachings for an audience that would never open a philosophical or magical treatise. His three major occult novels, Zanoni (1842), A Strange Story (1862), and The Coming Race (1871), form a connected exploration of occult power, spiritual development, and the relationship between the seen and unseen worlds.

Plot Summary

Dr. Allen Fenwick, a successful physician in the fictional English town of L, has built his reputation on materialist principles: he has publicly argued that all supernatural claims are either fraud or delusion and that consciousness is entirely a product of the brain. His certainties begin to crumble when he encounters two figures who challenge his worldview from opposite directions.

Sir Philip Douvall: An elderly physician and scientist who, unlike Fenwick, has not dismissed the supernatural. Sir Philip possesses knowledge that bridges science and the occult, and he warns Fenwick that rigid materialism leaves the mind vulnerable to forces it refuses to acknowledge. Sir Philip dies under mysterious circumstances early in the novel, and his death sets the plot in motion.

Margrave: A young man of extraordinary beauty and charm who arrives in L with no known past. Margrave possesses genuine occult powers: he can influence people's thoughts and actions through mesmeric force, project his consciousness across distances, and perform feats that defy Fenwick's materialist explanations. He is also, Fenwick gradually realises, amoral and dangerous: he manipulates everyone around him in pursuit of a single goal.

Margrave's goal is the elixir of life: an alchemical preparation that can restore youth and grant physical immortality. He possesses the knowledge to prepare it but lacks certain elements, and his search for these elements drives the novel's plot through L, across Europe, and eventually to Australia (where the climactic scenes take place).

Fenwick's fiancee, Lilian Ashleigh, becomes a target of Margrave's mesmeric manipulation. She falls into a trance-like state that Fenwick's medical knowledge cannot explain or cure, forcing him to seek help from sources he had previously dismissed. This personal crisis, combined with his own encounters with genuinely inexplicable phenomena, gradually erodes his materialist certainties and opens him to a broader understanding of reality.

The novel climaxes in the Australian wilderness, where Margrave attempts to prepare the elixir in a ceremony that draws on his remaining occult power. The attempt fails: the forces Margrave invokes prove beyond his control, and his body, no longer sustained by the youth he has artificially maintained, collapses into the aged and withered form it would naturally possess. Fenwick, having been forced to acknowledge the reality of occult forces, returns to England with Lilian (whose trance is eventually broken) and a worldview that now integrates the scientific and the spiritual.

Dr. Fenwick: The Rationalist

Dr. Allen Fenwick is one of the most interesting rationalist characters in Victorian fiction because Bulwer-Lytton portrays him with genuine sympathy. Fenwick is not a fool or a villain; he is an intelligent, compassionate physician whose materialist worldview is a product of rigorous education and honest observation. His mistake is not that he values science but that he has allowed science to become a closed system that excludes any evidence it cannot accommodate.

Bulwer-Lytton uses Fenwick to make a subtle philosophical argument: the problem with scientific materialism is not that it is wrong (within its domain, it is remarkably effective) but that it is incomplete. It can explain the physical dimensions of reality but cannot account for consciousness, will, purpose, or the experiences that mystics, seers, and sensitives have reported across all cultures and historical periods. By treating these experiences as mere aberrations, Fenwick's materialism leaves him unprepared for a genuine encounter with the non-physical.

Fenwick's journey through the novel is a journey from certainty through crisis to a more expansive understanding. He does not abandon science; he expands it. By the novel's end, he has not become a mystic or an occultist but a scientist who acknowledges that reality is larger than the materialist paradigm allows. This is precisely the position Bulwer-Lytton himself occupied: not anti-science but trans-science, arguing that genuine knowledge must integrate the findings of empirical investigation with the insights of esoteric experience.

Margrave: The Occult Villain

Margrave is one of Victorian literature's most original and disturbing antagonists. Unlike conventional villains motivated by greed, revenge, or ambition, Margrave is driven by a single, all-consuming desire: to preserve his youth and beauty forever. He has genuine occult powers, remarkable intelligence, and extraordinary physical beauty, but he lacks the one quality that would make these gifts constructive rather than destructive: moral conscience.

Bulwer-Lytton constructs Margrave as a case study in the esoteric principle that power without morality leads to destruction. In the Western esoteric tradition, the development of occult faculties (clairvoyance, mesmerism, astral projection) is understood to be dangerous without a corresponding development of moral character. A person who gains power over the invisible forces of nature without developing the wisdom and compassion to use that power responsibly becomes a danger to themselves and others, a "black magician" in the tradition's terminology.

Margrave's tragedy is that he has acquired the ability to work with occult forces but not the wisdom to understand their purpose. He seeks immortality for the same reason a child seeks candy: because it is pleasant and available, without considering the consequences. His understanding of the elixir of life is purely technical: he knows the recipe but not the meaning. The elixir, in the alchemical tradition, is not a physical substance but a symbol of spiritual transformation, the opus magnum (Great Work) that transmutes the practitioner's consciousness. Margrave's literalism, his attempt to use the elixir as a physical youth-restoring potion rather than as a catalyst for spiritual development, ensures his failure.

Some scholars have identified Margrave as a precursor to Oscar Wilde's Dorian Gray (1890), who similarly trades his soul for eternal youth and beauty. Both characters embody the Victorian anxiety about beauty without morality, and both meet destructive ends when the artificial preservation of youth can no longer be sustained.

The Elixir of Life

The elixir of life (elixir vitae) is one of the central concepts of the Western alchemical tradition. In its exoteric (outer, literal) meaning, it is a physical substance that grants immortality or restores youth. In its esoteric (inner, symbolic) meaning, it represents the culmination of the alchemical Great Work: the spiritual transformation in which the practitioner's consciousness is "transmuted" from the "base metal" of ordinary awareness into the "gold" of enlightened perception.

Bulwer-Lytton, as a student of alchemy, understood both levels of meaning. In A Strange Story, the elixir operates on both levels simultaneously. On the plot level, Margrave is seeking a physical substance that will restore his youth. On the symbolic level, the novel demonstrates that the genuine elixir, true spiritual transformation, cannot be obtained through technical knowledge alone but requires moral and spiritual development that Margrave conspicuously lacks.

The elixir's preparation in the novel involves a ceremony conducted in the Australian wilderness, in which Margrave invokes occult forces through a ritual combining alchemical procedures with mesmeric concentration. The ceremony draws on genuine alchemical lore (the importance of timing, the role of natural forces, the necessity of specific ingredients), but its failure demonstrates the esoteric teaching that the outer form of the ritual is useless without the inner transformation of the practitioner. The elixir is not a recipe; it is a relationship between the seeker and the forces of transformation, and that relationship requires integrity, humility, and moral depth that Margrave does not possess.

Mesmerism in the Novel

Mesmerism (animal magnetism), the system of healing and consciousness exploration developed by Franz Anton Mesmer in the late 18th century, plays a central role in A Strange Story. Bulwer-Lytton treated mesmerism seriously as a genuine phenomenon that mainstream Victorian science was wrong to dismiss.

The mesmeric tradition proposed that a universal fluid or force (the "animal magnetic" fluid) pervaded all living things and could be directed by the will of a trained practitioner to produce healing, anaesthesia, clairvoyance, and other effects. By the mid-19th century, mainstream science had rejected mesmerism as quackery, but a significant minority of physicians, philosophers, and spiritual seekers continued to investigate it, finding in it evidence for the existence of forces and faculties that materialist science could not explain.

Margrave's powers in the novel are primarily mesmeric. He can:

• Influence people's thoughts and actions at a distance through force of will
• Induce trance states in susceptible individuals (particularly Lilian)
• Project his consciousness beyond his physical body
• Perceive hidden or distant events through clairvoyance
• Manipulate the "vital force" to sustain his unnatural youth

Bulwer-Lytton presents these abilities as genuine, not as tricks or delusions. Fenwick, the rationalist, initially dismisses them but is eventually forced to acknowledge their reality when his own materialist explanations prove inadequate. The novel's argument is not that mesmerism replaces science but that it supplements it: the mesmeric phenomena are real, and a complete understanding of reality must account for them.

The mesmeric tradition, while scientifically discredited in its original form, anticipated several developments in modern psychology and neuroscience: the concept of the unconscious mind (developed by Pierre Janet and Sigmund Freud, both influenced by the mesmeric/hypnotic tradition), the therapeutic use of trance states (modern hypnotherapy), and the investigation of anomalous perceptual experiences (parapsychology). Bulwer-Lytton's fictional treatment of mesmerism, while embedded in a 19th-century framework, addresses questions about consciousness and the limits of materialist explanation that remain open.

Science vs. the Occult

The central intellectual conflict of A Strange Story is the conflict between scientific materialism and occult knowledge, and Bulwer-Lytton navigates it with unusual sophistication.

He does not simply dismiss science in favour of the occult (which would be romanticism) or dismiss the occult in favour of science (which would be reductive materialism). Instead, he argues for a synthesis in which both are necessary and neither is sufficient alone. Science provides rigorous methods for investigating the physical world; the occult provides access to dimensions of reality that physical methods cannot reach. The complete picture requires both.

This position places Bulwer-Lytton within the broader tradition of Western esotericism, which has consistently sought to integrate science and spirituality rather than to oppose them. The Hermetic axiom "as above, so below" implies that the same principles govern both the physical and the metaphysical worlds, and that a genuine science would investigate both with equal rigour. The Rosicrucian tradition, to which Bulwer-Lytton belonged, was founded on the ideal of uniting scientific knowledge with spiritual wisdom.

The novel's relevance to contemporary debates is notable. The "hard problem of consciousness" (David Chalmers' term for the question of why subjective experience exists at all) remains unsolved by materialist neuroscience. The question Bulwer-Lytton posed in 1862, whether consciousness can be fully explained by physical processes or whether it requires reference to non-physical dimensions, is the same question that contemporary consciousness researchers are still asking. Fenwick's journey from rigid materialism to a more expansive worldview mirrors the intellectual trajectory that some contemporary scientists (including Eben Alexander, Pim van Lommel, and Federico Faggin) have reported after encounters with phenomena that their materialist training could not explain.

Lilian: The Spiritual Feminine

Lilian Ashleigh, Fenwick's fiancee and later wife, serves as the novel's representative of the spiritual dimension of existence. Where Fenwick embodies intellect and Margrave embodies will, Lilian embodies soul: the receptive, intuitive, spiritual faculty that is vulnerable to occult influence precisely because it is open to dimensions of reality that the intellect (Fenwick) refuses to acknowledge.

Lilian's susceptibility to Margrave's mesmeric manipulation is both a plot device and a philosophical statement. Her openness to the spiritual makes her vulnerable to exploitation by those who possess occult power without moral scruple. The novel suggests that the spiritual faculty (the soul) requires the protection of both the intellect (reason, discrimination) and moral will (conscience, integrity). Lilian's trance can be broken only when Fenwick integrates his scientific reason with spiritual awareness, combining the strengths of both to counteract Margrave's amoral occult force.

In the esoteric reading, Lilian represents the anima (in Jungian terms) or the spiritual soul (in Kabbalistic terms) that the practitioner must protect, develop, and integrate. Her endangerment by Margrave represents the danger that the unpurified will poses to the soul; her rescue by Fenwick represents the integration of reason and spirit that is the goal of the esoteric path.

The Dweller on the Threshold

The concept of the "Dweller on the Threshold" was introduced by Bulwer-Lytton in his earlier novel Zanoni (1842) and became a standard term in Western esotericism, adopted by Blavatsky, Steiner, Alice Bailey, and numerous other esoteric teachers.

The Dweller is the terrifying entity or experience that confronts the spiritual seeker at the boundary between ordinary consciousness and higher perception. It represents everything in the seeker that is unresolved, unconfronted, and unintegrated: fears, desires, self-deceptions, and the accumulated weight of the ego's resistance to transformation. Before the seeker can cross the threshold into genuine spiritual knowledge, the Dweller must be faced and overcome.

In A Strange Story, the Dweller concept appears in the form of the supernatural terrors that Fenwick encounters as his materialist worldview collapses. The phenomena he witnesses are not merely strange; they are terrifying, because they threaten the very foundation of his identity as a rational, scientific man. To accept the reality of occult forces is, for Fenwick, a kind of death: the death of the self-image that has defined him. The Dweller, in this reading, is the terror of ego-dissolution that stands between the seeker and genuine knowledge.

Rudolf Steiner later developed the Dweller concept extensively in his Anthroposophical teachings, describing it as the "lesser guardian of the threshold" (the confrontation with one's own shadow) and the "greater guardian of the threshold" (the confrontation with the cosmic forces that govern existence). Both concepts derive, directly or indirectly, from Bulwer-Lytton's literary invention.

Connection to The Coming Race

A Strange Story (1862) and The Coming Race (1871) are companion works that explore the same themes through different narrative frameworks:

Together with Zanoni (1842), these three novels form a trilogy of occult fiction that represents Bulwer-Lytton's sustained exploration of the themes that defined his esoteric life: the reality of non-physical forces, the relationship between knowledge and morality, and the possibility of human transformation through the development of latent faculties.

Esoteric Reading

Readers within the Western esoteric tradition have consistently read A Strange Story as a coded transmission of genuine occult teaching. The novel operates on multiple levels simultaneously:

The literal level: A supernatural thriller about a physician confronting genuine occult phenomena.

The moral level: A cautionary tale about the dangers of power without morality (Margrave) and the limitations of reason without spiritual awareness (Fenwick).

The allegorical level: A depiction of the spiritual path, in which the seeker (Fenwick) must confront the Dweller on the Threshold (the terror of ego-dissolution), overcome the temptation of power without wisdom (Margrave), and integrate reason with spiritual awareness to achieve a complete understanding of reality.

The esoteric level: A transmission of specific occult teachings about mesmerism, the vital force, the elixir of life, and the relationship between the physical and non-physical dimensions, encoded in fictional form for readers with the knowledge to decode them.

Helena Blavatsky referenced A Strange Story in Isis Unveiled (1877), treating Margrave as a fictional representation of a genuine type: the sorcerer who possesses occult knowledge without moral development. Members of the Hermetic Order of the Golden Dawn studied Bulwer-Lytton's novels as part of their curriculum. And the Theosophical Society's adoption of the Dweller on the Threshold concept ensured that Bulwer-Lytton's literary creation became a permanent part of the Western esoteric vocabulary.

Reception and Influence

A Strange Story was serialised in Charles Dickens's magazine All the Year Round, giving it a readership that extended far beyond the esoteric community. Dickens himself, who was interested in mesmerism and the supernatural, was a sympathetic editor, and the novel's serial publication alongside his own fiction ensured a wide audience.

Critical reception was mixed. The novel was commercially successful (Bulwer-Lytton was one of the bestselling authors of his era), but some critics found its supernatural elements implausible and its occult themes disturbing. The Saturday Review called it "a strange story indeed," and not entirely as a compliment. Within the esoteric community, however, it was received as a serious work of occult fiction, and its influence extended through Theosophy, the Golden Dawn, and subsequent esoteric movements.

The novel's literary influence includes:

• Oscar Wilde's The Picture of Dorian Gray (1890): Margrave's preservation of youth at the cost of moral degradation anticipates Dorian's portrait
• Bram Stoker's Dracula (1897): The mesmeric villain who preys on vulnerable women and must be confronted by a combination of scientific knowledge and spiritual courage
• H.P. Lovecraft: The materialist protagonist forced to confront supernatural realities that shatter his worldview is a recurring Lovecraftian pattern
• Dennis Wheatley: The occult thriller genre that Wheatley popularised in the 20th century descends directly from Bulwer-Lytton's occult novels

Modern Relevance

A Strange Story addresses questions that remain relevant in the 21st century:

The limits of materialism: Is consciousness entirely a product of the brain, or does it have non-physical dimensions? Fenwick's crisis anticipates the contemporary "hard problem of consciousness" that neuroscience has not yet solved.

Technology without ethics: Margrave's possession of power without moral development parallels modern concerns about artificial intelligence, genetic engineering, and other technologies that advance faster than the ethical frameworks needed to govern them.

The integration of science and spirituality: Bulwer-Lytton's argument that genuine knowledge requires both scientific rigour and spiritual awareness anticipates the contemporary movement toward "integral" approaches that seek to bridge the science-spirituality divide (Ken Wilber, Iain McGilchrist, Federico Faggin).

The occult novel as a genre: The tradition Bulwer-Lytton established, using fiction to encode esoteric teachings, continues in contemporary literature from Umberto Eco's Foucault's Pendulum to Dan Brown's The Da Vinci Code, though few subsequent authors have matched Bulwer-Lytton's combination of genuine esoteric knowledge and literary skill.

Get the Book

Get A Strange Story on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate, Thalira earns from qualifying purchases.