Steiner's teaching that musicality is the karmic fruit of a soul that, in its previous earth-life, lived with open, mobile sympathy toward the world.
The Musical and the Unmusical Soul is Rudolf Steiner's answer to a question psychology leaves open: why is one person musical and another not? In Berlin on 18 July 1916, he traced the difference to the previous incarnation. The musical soul once lived in vivid, flexible sympathy with the world. The unmusical soul belonged to someone dulled to outer impressions, who may yet have done great deeds in other fields.
The Musical and the Unmusical Soul in Anthroposophy is Rudolf Steiner's account of why some people are musical and others are not, given in Toward Imagination (GA 169, lecture of 18 July 1916, Berlin). Steiner treats musicality as a karmic fruit. The musical soul is one that, in its previous earthly life, lived with open, mobile sympathy, moving easily between joy and sorrow and feeling all that went on around it. That inner flexibility was internalized between death and rebirth and reappears as the rhythmical suppleness of the musical temperament. The unmusical soul belonged to someone dulled to outer impressions in the preceding incarnation, who may still have been a great reformer or world-historical figure. Music thus becomes a window onto repeated earth-lives, read not by crude concept but by living picture, and never used to label any one person's former existence.
In Steiner's Own Words
Now, the spiritual scientist, trying to understand the world from his point of view, comes to the conclusion that those people are musical in this life who empathized with everything and moved easily from joy to sorrow and from sorrow to joy in their previous life. This was internalized, and that is how the rhythmical flexibility of the musical soul developed. On the other hand, people who were dulled in their sensitivity to outer events in the preceding incarnation do not become musical. Nevertheless, they may have other excellent qualities, may even have been great world reformers and have influenced world history.
What it Means Today
Steiner's claim sounds remote until it reaches the place where it was meant to act: the classroom. In Waldorf music teaching, the karmic reading of musicality becomes a working assumption that every child carries a musical nature waiting to be drawn out, not a fixed talent some lack. The clearest expression is the mood of the fifth, the Quintenstimmung, the pentatonic, fifth-centered tonal world Steiner indicated for young children. Julius Knierim, a music teacher at the Engelberg Free Waldorf School, gathered this work into Quintenlieder (Songs in the Mood of the Fifth), first published in 1970, with melodies that float around the central tone A without resolving to a major or minor home. Children meet music as open, breathing movement before it hardens into the adult key system, the same mobile sympathy Steiner described as the seed of the musical soul.
The practical turn is what makes this Steinerian rather than merely poetic. If musicality is the internalized memory of a soul that once lived with feeling, then the unmusical child is not a lost cause but a soul whose sympathy is sleeping, and the teacher's task is to reawaken movement, not to test pitch. Thalira synthesis: in this light the mood of the fifth is less a teaching method than a karmic courtesy, an offer of the very flexibility a future incarnation will need to become musical, extended now to the child who arrives without it.
Where to Read More