Book Reviews

Phaedrus by Plato: An Honest Review

Last Updated: November 2026. Expanded the treatment of the palinode and the unity question.

Quick Answer

Plato's most beautiful dialogue, and the one in which he takes back what the Phaedo said about the body. Socrates leaves the city for once, sits under a plane tree with a young man who loves speeches, and gives a speech of his own that turns love from a disease into a god's gift: the soul is a winged chariot that once saw the truth, fell, and grows its wings again at the sight of beauty in a face. Then the dialogue turns and asks what a good speech is, and ends by warning that writing, including this, cannot teach and can only remind. The two halves have puzzled readers for two millennia. They fit, and finding how is the reason to read it twice.

Key Takeaways

  • Love as divine madness: the best of four kinds the gods send.
  • The chariot: two horses, a driver, and wings that fell and can regrow.
  • Beauty: the one Form that shines through its earthly image.
  • True rhetoric: knowing the truth, knowing the soul, and leading it.
  • Writing's limits: a reminder that cannot answer back.

17 min read

What This Dialogue Is

The Phaedrus is a dialogue in two speakers, Socrates and Phaedrus, probably written in the 360s BCE, after the Republic and the Symposium, and it is around seventy pages in translation. It has two parts that do not obviously belong together. The first is three speeches on love, of which the third, Socrates's palinode, is the most famous passage of Plato outside the cave. The second is a discussion of rhetoric, what makes speech good, ending with a myth about the invention of writing and a judgment on what written words can and cannot do.

It is a dialogue of unusual warmth and beauty, set outdoors in summer, and it is also the place where Plato most fully states the doctrine of the tripartite soul, the theory of recollection, the nature of beauty and the method of dialectic. Readers who come for the myth stay for the argument, and readers who come for the argument find that the myth was making it.

A recantation. The Phaedo had said the body was a prison and the passions a hindrance. The Phaedrus says that the passion of love, in its right form, is the soul's way back to the truth, and that the philosopher's madness and the lover's are the same. Plato is not contradicting himself so much as completing a thought, and the dialogue's own structure, in which Socrates retracts a speech against love and gives one for it, is the retraction of the harsher view.

The Plane Tree

The scene, which is part of the argument.

Socrates meets Phaedrus, who has spent the morning hearing Lysias speak and has the text under his cloak, and they walk out of the city along the Ilissus to find a place to read it. They come to a tall plane tree with a chaste-tree in flower beside it, a spring of cold water, an altar of the nymphs and of Achelous, a gentle slope for the head, and the sound of cicadas in the midday heat. Socrates praises the spot at length and Phaedrus laughs at him: he speaks like a stranger being shown around, and indeed never leaves the city. Socrates answers that the country and the trees have nothing to teach him, only people in the city do, but that Phaedrus has found the drug to draw him out: a speech in a book.

It is the only dialogue set outside the walls, the only one in which Socrates is alone with a single companion, and the only one in which the setting is described with such care. The nymphs, Socrates later says, may have possessed him; the place is one where speech can become inspired, and the dialogue's turn from Lysias's clever text to the palinode's divine madness happens because of where they are sitting.

Who Phaedrus Is

Phaedrus of Myrrhinus is a young Athenian who loves speeches: he appears in the Symposium as the one who proposed the topic of love and gave the first speech, and in the Protagoras among the admirers of the sophists. He is enthusiastic, a little vain about his taste, devoted to Lysias's prose, and ready to be led. Socrates handles him with affection and some teasing, and the dialogue is in part the education of a lover of words into a lover of truth. Phaedrus is not a philosopher, and the dialogue does not make him one; he is the soul that the palinode and the rhetoric are meant to lead.

Lysias's Speech

The first speech, read from the text.

Lysias, the orator, has written a paradox: a speech in which a man who does not love a boy argues that the boy should give himself to him rather than to a lover. The lover is mad, jealous, changeable, ashamed afterward, and a burden; the non-lover is calm, discreet, reliable and useful, and will treat the boy as a friend rather than as a possession. The speech is clever, cold and formally weak, its points arranged as they came to the writer, and Socrates says so.

The speech's function is to state the case against passion in its most sophistical form, and to represent the kind of writing, technically skilled and empty, that the second half will analyse.

Socrates's First Speech

The second speech, which Socrates gives with his head covered for shame.

Phaedrus challenges Socrates to do better on the same theme, and he does, after invoking the Muses and covering his face. He defines love as desire for beauty that has overpowered judgment, and argues that the lover, being in the grip of such desire, will want the beloved weak, ignorant, poor, friendless and dependent, will be a jealous and tiresome companion, and will abandon him when the madness passes. The speech is far better made than Lysias's, with a definition, a division and an argument, and it is the more damning for it.

He stops before praising the non-lover, saying he has said enough, and is about to cross the river back to the city.

The Sign and the Recantation

The turn.

As he prepares to leave, Socrates's divine sign comes, the daimonion that always holds him back from something he is about to do wrong, and he hears a voice forbidding him to go until he has purified himself. He has blasphemed. Love is a god, or something divine, and both speeches have called him evil. He will offer a palinode, a recantation, as the poet Stesichorus did when he lost his sight for slandering Helen and regained it by taking the slander back. And this time he speaks with his head uncovered.

The moment is the dialogue's pivot and one of the few in Plato where the daimonion acts on the page. Socrates is turned from cleverness to inspiration by something he does not control, and what follows is presented as given rather than made.

The Four Madnesses

The palinode's opening argument.

The earlier speeches assumed that madness is bad and sanity good. But the greatest goods come to us through madness, when it is sent by the gods. There is the madness of prophecy, by which the priestess at Delphi and the Sibyl have done Greece more good in their madness than in their right minds. There is the madness of ritual, which finds purification for families under inherited curses. There is the madness of the Muses, which seizes a gentle soul and rouses it to poetry, and without which the merely skilful poet is nothing. And there is a fourth, the madness of love, which the palinode will show is the best of all.

The passage is the source of the Western doctrine of poetic inspiration and of the idea, which runs from the Neoplatonists to the Romantics, that the highest states of the soul are ones it does not command. It also reverses the Phaedo: the passions are not merely the body's noise; some of them are the gods speaking.

The Proof of the Soul's Immortality

A short, dense argument before the myth.

To show what love does, Socrates must say what the soul is, and he begins with a proof that it is immortal, different from any in the Phaedo. What moves itself is the source of motion for everything else; what is moved by another can cease, but what moves itself cannot cease without all motion ceasing; and a self-mover cannot come to be or perish, since it would need a source outside itself. The soul is what moves itself, the source of life and motion in the body. So the soul is ungenerated and immortal.

The argument is a page long and Socrates does not dwell on it. Its interest is that it defines the soul by motion rather than by knowledge, which is why the myth that follows can be one of movement, flight and fall.

The Chariot

The image, which has never been bettered.

What the soul is in itself would take a god to say; what it is like can be said more briefly. It is like the combined power of a winged chariot and its driver. The gods' horses and drivers are all good; ours are mixed. The driver is reason. One horse is noble, white, upright, a lover of honour, driven by command alone. The other is crooked, dark, thick-necked, snub-nosed, deaf, driven only with whip and goad. Driving such a pair is hard, and the soul's story is the story of that difficulty.

The three parts of the soul, reason, spirit and appetite, are those of the Republic, but here they are horses and a driver, and the drama of the myth, the struggle at the sight of the beloved, is their struggle. The image entered Christian and Islamic thought, Freud's ego and id, and every later account of the divided self.

The Procession of the Gods

Where the soul was before it fell.

The soul, when it has its wings, travels the heavens with the gods. Zeus leads a procession of eleven gods, each with a following of souls, and they ascend to the rim of heaven, where the gods stand on the outer surface and are carried round, and see what is beyond: the colourless, shapeless, intangible being that truly is, justice itself, temperance itself, knowledge itself, which nourish the soul's wings. The gods see this fully and are fed. Other souls follow, some barely raising the driver's head above the rim, some glimpsing and losing sight as the horses struggle, some trampled and lamed in the crush and going away without the vision. And a soul that never sees is weighed down by forgetfulness and evil, loses its wings, and falls to earth.

The passage is Plato's most sustained description of what the Forms are like to see, and it is written as vision rather than argument. The Phaedo said the soul knew the Forms before birth; the Phaedrus shows the seeing.

The Fall and the Wings

What happens next, and the doctrine of rebirth.

The fallen soul is sown into a mortal body, and the law is that a soul which saw most becomes a philosopher or a lover of beauty or of the Muses; the next a lawful king; and so on down through nine kinds to the tyrant, who saw least. A soul returns to its wings after ten thousand years, unless it is a philosopher's, which grows them in three thousand if it has chosen the philosophic life three times running. Between lives the souls are judged and sent to punishment under the earth or to reward in a region of heaven, and in the thousandth year choose their next life, and a human soul may enter a beast and a beast that was once human may return, but only a soul that has seen the truth can enter a human, since a human must understand by Forms, gathering many perceptions into one by reasoning, and that understanding is recollection of what the soul saw in its procession.

The cosmology is mythic and Plato does not ask belief for its numbers. What he asks is assent to its shape: that we have seen, that we have forgotten, and that the forgetting can be undone.

Beauty and Recollection

The doctrine that makes love the way back.

Justice and temperance and the other Forms have no brightness in their earthly images; we see their likenesses dimly and few recognise them. But beauty was seen shining among the Forms in the procession, and here on earth it comes to us through sight, the sharpest of the senses, and its earthly image, a beautiful face or body, shines too. So the soul that sees beauty on earth is reminded, as it is by nothing else, of what it saw before, and the reminder is felt bodily: a shudder, a sweat, a heat, and then, at the roots of the wings, which have been dried and sealed, a swelling and an ache as the feathers begin to push through. The soul in love is a soul growing wings, and the pain and joy of it, the throbbing, the longing, the relief at the beloved's presence and the anguish at his absence, are what the growth feels like.

This is the philosophical core of the palinode: that the experience everyone has had, of being undone by a face, is the soul's recollection of the truth and its first movement home. Beauty is the one Form we can see, and it was placed where we could see it so that we would remember.

The palinode's achievement is to have made the ordinary experience of falling in love into evidence for the soul's origin. The shiver at the sight of the beloved, the heat, the ache, the inability to think of anything else: these are not, on Plato's account, a chemistry to be explained away or a weakness to be mastered. They are the wings coming back. The soul saw beauty once among the gods, lost it, and forgot; the beautiful face is the reminder, and the madness that follows is the soul remembering what it is. No philosopher before or since has taken the experience so seriously or given it so much, and the passage is why the dialogue is read by people who care nothing for the theory of Forms.

The Lovers

The palinode's account of what love does when it is rightly lived.

The lover, reminded of the god he followed, seeks a beloved of that god's kind and tries to make him more like the god, so that the beloved becomes an image of the divine for the lover and the lover's devotion is a kind of worship. The beloved, seeing himself loved, comes to love in return, receiving the stream of beauty that flows back to him from the lover's eyes, and his wings begin to grow too. Then the horses fight. The dark horse lunges toward the body; the driver and the white horse pull back, remembering the vision; the driver hauls on the reins until the dark horse's mouth bleeds, and again, until it is humbled and follows. If the lovers live this way, in the philosophic life, mastering the dark horse, they win the first of the three Olympic victories and at death rise winged. If they slip, and yield to the body in some unguarded hour, they are still friends, and go without wings but on the way to them, and will not be sent to darkness.

The account is of love between an older man and a youth, as Athenian custom framed it, and Plato's transformation of that custom into a philosophy has been argued over since. What the passage says, whatever its frame, is that love at its best is two souls helping each other remember, and that the body's demand, once mastered, survives and pulls the flight.

The Cicadas

A myth in the interval.

The speeches over, at noon, with the cicadas singing, Socrates says they must not fall asleep like slaves in the heat but keep talking, and tells why. The cicadas were once men, before the Muses were born, who when song appeared were so enraptured that they sang without eating or drinking until they died, and the Muses gave them the gift of singing from birth to death without food and then reporting to the Muses who among mortals honours them. The cicadas are listening. The passage is a small joke and a serious warning: the dialogue is about to turn from inspired speech to the analysis of speech, and the singers overhead will tell the Muses whether the analysis honours them.

True and False Rhetoric

The second half.

Is it shameful to write speeches? No, only to write them badly. What then is a good speech? Socrates argues that rhetoric as the sophists teach it, a set of techniques for persuasion, is not an art, because it does not know the truth about its subject and does not know the soul it addresses. The true rhetorician must know what is just, beautiful and good, so that he can make likenesses that lead toward them; must know the kinds of soul and the kinds of speech that move each; and must be able to see, in the man in front of him, which kind he is and what will move him. Rhetoric, so understood, is a leading of souls, psychagogia, and it is the same as philosophy applied to persuasion.

The section reads Lysias's speech and Socrates's own against these standards and finds Lysias wanting: no definition, no organisation, points thrown down as they came. Socrates's speeches, by contrast, began by defining love and divided it into kinds, which is the method the dialogue now names.

Collection and Division

The method, stated here for the first time.

There are two procedures. Collection: to see together the scattered particulars and bring them under one Form, so that a definition is possible, as the speeches brought the many kinds of love under one idea of it. Division: to cut the Form again at its natural joints, as a good butcher does, not hacking through any part, as the speeches divided madness into the human and the divine and the divine into four. The dialectician, Socrates says, is one who can do this, and he is a lover of these divisions and collections and follows anyone who can make them as if he were a god.

The method is that of the late dialogues, the Sophist and Statesman, and the Phaedrus is where it is announced. Its presence explains the dialogue's date, and its connection to the palinode is that the palinode was an example of it.

Theuth and Thamus

The myth, and the judgment.

Socrates tells an Egyptian story. Theuth, the god of invention, brought his arts to King Thamus at Thebes: number, calculation, geometry, astronomy, draughts, dice, and letters. Of letters he said: this will make the Egyptians wiser and improve their memories, for it is a drug for memory and wisdom. Thamus answered that the inventor of an art is not the best judge of it, and that letters would produce forgetfulness, since people would trust the marks and cease to exercise memory; that they were a drug not for memory but for reminding; and that they would give the appearance of wisdom without the reality, so that people would have heard much and learned nothing and be hard to get on with, being wise in their own conceit.

Socrates draws the lesson. Written words are like paintings: they look alive, but ask them a question and they keep a solemn silence. They cannot choose their readers, going to those who understand and those who do not alike. They cannot defend themselves when misused. They are, at best, reminders for those who already know. The living, breathing word, written with knowledge in the soul of the learner, which can defend itself and knows when to speak and when to be silent, is the true writing, and the written text is its image, a garden of letters sown for amusement, to store up reminders for oneself in old age and for those who follow the same track. The serious business is dialectic: the planting of words in souls.

The passage has troubled every writer since. Plato wrote it down. He wrote everything down, and much of what we know of his thought is these written words that cannot answer. Readers have taken this as irony, as a warning about how to read him, and as the reason the dialogues are dialogues: written words pretending to be living ones, so that the reader will be led to do the questioning the text cannot. The critique of writing is the dialogue's last and most self-implicating turn.

How the Halves Fit

The question, and the best answer.

Since antiquity readers have asked what a myth of the winged soul has to do with a critique of the sophists. Hermias, the Neoplatonic commentator, said the subject was beauty in all its forms. Modern readers have proposed love, the soul, rhetoric, or the relation between inspiration and method. The reading that has come to prevail is that the second half explains the first: the palinode was a speech that knew the truth about love and the soul, that was fitted to Phaedrus's soul and led it, that proceeded by collection and division, and that came to Socrates by a divine madness the Muses of the plane tree sent. The rhetoric section describes what a good speech is; the palinode had already been one. And the critique of writing tells the reader what the whole dialogue is: a written reminder of a conversation, which can only lead a reader who already has the wings to be led.

On this reading the dialogue's unity is that of demonstration and explanation, and the reader who goes back to the palinode after the second half finds it doing everything the second half prescribes.

The Afterlife of the Dialogue

Enormous. The chariot became the standard image of the soul in Neoplatonism, in Christian ascetic writing and in Islamic philosophy. The four madnesses gave the Renaissance its theory of the poet's furor and the Romantics their inspiration. The doctrine of beauty as the visible Form fed Ficino's Platonic love and the whole tradition of the beloved as the image of the divine. The critique of writing was taken up by Derrida in Plato's Pharmacy, which made the dialogue central to twentieth-century theory, and by every writer who has wondered what a page can do. The cicadas and the plane tree are the most quoted scene in Greek prose. It is a dialogue that has been useful to mystics, lovers, poets, rhetoricians and philosophers of language, and none of them has exhausted it.

The Translations

Christopher Rowe's Penguin, 2005, is accurate and readable, with notes that explain the setting and the argument. Alexander Nehamas and Paul Woodruff's Hackett, 1995, is the standard in universities and has a fine introduction. R. Hackforth's Cambridge, 1952, gives the translation with a running commentary and is the one for serious study. Robin Waterfield's Oxford is fluent. Walter Hamilton's older Penguin, in the volume with the Seventh Letter, is still pleasant. The Penguin edition reviewed here is Rowe's, and any of these will serve.

Who Should Read It

Read it if you want Plato's account of love and the soul in its most beautiful form, since the palinode is that.

Read it after the Symposium, whose ladder of love it completes with wings, and after the Phaedo, whose harshness it takes back.

Read it if you write, and want to be told by the founder of written philosophy what writing cannot do.

Read the palinode if you read nothing else, and then read the myth of Theuth, and ask what the one has to do with the other. That question is the dialogue.

The dialogue's teaching is that the way back to the truth passes through a face. Plato had said elsewhere that the body was a hindrance and the senses deceived; here he says that beauty, alone of the Forms, was placed where the eyes could find it, so that the soul, which had forgotten everything else, would be reminded by the one thing it could not miss. The lover's madness is where philosophy begins, and the philosopher is the one who, having been undone by beauty, follows the undoing upward instead of down. It is the most generous thing Plato ever wrote about ordinary human experience, and it is why the dialogue has been read by people in love for twenty-four centuries and found to be about them.

The winged chariot, the four divine madnesses, beauty as the soul's reminder, and the myth of writing: Plato under the plane tree.

Phaedrus on Amazon

Affiliate disclosure: Thalira earns a small commission on purchases made through the link above, at no additional cost to you. Our account of the dialogue's structural difficulty and the debate over its unity is given above and was not softened for the link.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Phaedrus about?

Love, the soul, rhetoric and writing. Socrates and the young Phaedrus walk outside Athens, sit under a plane tree by the Ilissus, and exchange three speeches on whether a boy should favour a lover or a non-lover. Socrates's second speech becomes a myth of the soul as a winged chariot and of love as the recovery of its wings. The second half turns to what makes speech good and ends with a critique of writing itself.

When was it written?

Probably in the 360s BCE, after the Republic and the Symposium and before the late dialogues. Its theory of the soul as tripartite and its method of collection and division place it at the turn from Plato's middle to his late period.

What are the three speeches?

Lysias's speech, read by Phaedrus, arguing that a boy should give himself to a non-lover, who is calm and useful, rather than a lover, who is mad. Socrates's first speech, delivered with his head covered, making the same case more elegantly. And Socrates's recantation, the palinode, arguing that the lover's madness is a divine gift and the greatest good.

What are the four madnesses?

Prophetic madness, from Apollo, as at Delphi; ritual or purifying madness, from Dionysus, which heals inherited guilt; poetic madness, from the Muses, without which technique produces nothing; and erotic madness, from Aphrodite and Eros, which the palinode defends as the best of the four.

What is the chariot myth?

The soul is like a charioteer with two winged horses, one noble and one unruly. Before birth the soul followed the gods to the rim of heaven and saw the Forms; the wings failed, the soul fell into a body, and it now recollects what it saw. Beauty, alone among the Forms, shines through its earthly images, and the sight of a beautiful beloved makes the wings begin to grow again.

What does it say about beauty?

That beauty is the one Form we can see with the eyes, and that its earthly likeness therefore has a power the likenesses of justice and wisdom lack: it reminds the soul of what it saw before birth, and the reminder is felt as the shiver and heat and ache of falling in love. Beauty is the soul's way back.

What is the second half about?

Rhetoric: what makes a speech good, and whether the rhetoric taught by the sophists is an art at all. Socrates argues that true rhetoric requires knowledge of the truth, of the soul and its kinds, and of the method of collection and division, and that it is a way of leading souls rather than a set of tricks.

What is the critique of writing?

Socrates tells the myth of Theuth, the Egyptian god who invented letters, and King Thamus, who said they would produce forgetfulness and the appearance of wisdom. Writing cannot answer questions, cannot choose its readers, and cannot defend itself; it is a reminder, not a teaching. The living word, planted in a soul that understands, is the only real writing.

How do the two halves fit?

The question the dialogue has posed since antiquity. The best answer is that the palinode is an example of the rhetoric the second half describes: a speech that knows the truth about the soul, is fitted to its hearer, and leads him. The dialogue shows the art and then explains it.

What is the setting?

Outside the city walls, by the Ilissus, under a tall plane tree, with a spring, cicadas and an altar of the nymphs, at midday in summer. Socrates never leaves Athens and says so; the dialogue's unusual setting is part of its meaning, and the cicadas get their own myth.

Which translation should I read?

Christopher Rowe's Penguin is accurate and readable with good notes; Alexander Nehamas and Paul Woodruff's Hackett is the standard in teaching; R. Hackforth's Cambridge has a running commentary; Robin Waterfield's Oxford is fluent. Walter Hamilton's older Penguin is still pleasant.

Who should read it?

Anyone who wants Plato's account of love and the soul in its most beautiful form, writers who want to be troubled about what writing is, readers of the Symposium who want its companion, and anyone who has fallen in love and wondered whether the madness was a symptom or a sign.

Notice the wings

The palinode's practical claim is that the feeling of being undone by beauty, a face, a piece of music, a line of a poem, a view at a certain hour, is the soul remembering, and that the ache is the wings growing. The next time it happens, do not explain it and do not act on it immediately. Stay in it, as Socrates stays under the plane tree, and ask what it is reminding you of. Plato's answer is that it is reminding you of something you saw before you were born and have spent your life forgetting. You do not have to accept the cosmology to test the instruction. The ache is real; what it points to is the experiment.

Sources & References

  • Plato. Phaedrus, trans. Christopher Rowe, Penguin Classics, 2005.
  • Plato. Phaedrus, trans. Alexander Nehamas and Paul Woodruff, Hackett, 1995.
  • Hackforth, R. Plato's Phaedrus, Cambridge, 1952, with commentary.
  • Ferrari, G. R. F. Listening to the Cicadas: A Study of Plato's Phaedrus, Cambridge, 1987.
  • Nussbaum, Martha. The Fragility of Goodness, ch. 7, "This story isn't true," on the recantation.
  • Derrida, Jacques. "Plato's Pharmacy," in Dissemination, 1972, for the writing myth.
Back to all book reviews

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.