Clarissa Pinkola Estés: Women Who Run With the Wolves and the Wild Woman

🕑 14 min read

Who Is Clarissa Pinkola Estés?

Clarissa Pinkola Estés was born in 1945 in Indiana to parents of Mexican heritage and was adopted and raised in a Hungarian-American family in the Great Lakes region. She grew up immersed in two story traditions: the Hungarian folk tradition of her adoptive family and the Mexican curandera tradition of her biological heritage. Both would become central to her life's work.

She trained in Jungian psychology and holds a PhD in ethno-clinical psychology from the Union Institute. She has worked as a psychoanalyst for over four decades, specialising in trauma and creative life. But her primary identity is as a cantadora, a keeper of old stories, a role she inherited from the oral tradition of her Mexican-American family.

Women Who Run With the Wolves was published in 1992 by Ballantine Books. It spent over 145 weeks on the New York Times bestseller list and was translated into 36 languages. It became one of the most widely read books in the feminist spirituality and depth psychology fields of the 1990s and remains in print and widely read today.

The Wild Woman Archetype

The central concept of Estés's work is the Wild Woman archetype, which she also calls the Wild Woman Nature or the Life/Death/Life force of the feminine. This is not a description of a personality type or a behavioural style. It is an archetypal principle in the Jungian sense: a universal pattern that structures psychological experience.

Estés describes the Wild Woman as "the natural Life/Death/Life force of the feminine." She governs the instinctual life: the capacity to perceive accurately (to know what is predatory and what is nourishing), to create freely (to follow creative impulse without excessive self-censorship), to grieve fully (to let things die when they must die), and to renew deeply (to wait in the fallow time without forcing premature growth).

The Wild Woman, in Jungian terms, corresponds to the deepest layer of the feminine archetype, what is sometimes called the Great Mother or the Feminine Self. She precedes the personal; she is the instinctual layer beneath the personal complexes and beneath the cultural conditioning. Estés's contribution is to describe her specifically through the stories that have always carried her: fairy tales, myths, and folk narratives from across the world's traditions.

Bluebeard: The Internal Predator

The Bluebeard story, which Estés analyses in the chapter "Stalking the Intruder: The Beginning Initiation," is one of the most psychologically precise in the book. The story: a wealthy man with a blue beard (marking him as uncanny and dangerous) courts and wins a young woman. He gives her the keys to all the rooms of his castle but forbids her to enter one particular room. She enters it and finds the bodies of his previous wives. The key bleeds and cannot be cleaned; Bluebeard discovers her disobedience and threatens to kill her. Her brothers arrive just in time to save her.

Estés's reading goes straight past the surface. Bluebeard is not primarily a story about dangerous men (though it is that). It is a story about the predator within the psyche.

The forbidden room contains the remains of what Bluebeard has already killed: previous women, previous attempts at authentic life. The key that bleeds is the key of self-knowledge: once a woman knows something about her own nature and the nature of what is threatening it, that knowledge cannot be cleaned away. It marks her. And that marking is not a wound; it is a gift. It is the beginning of genuine knowledge rather than comfortable ignorance.

La Llorona: The Cost of Abandoning the Wild

La Llorona, the Weeping Woman, is one of the most powerful and complex figures in Mexican and Chicano folk tradition. The story varies across versions but the core is consistent: a woman drowns her children after being abandoned or betrayed and now wanders weeping near water, seeking them and sometimes threatening the children of others.

In most tellings, La Llorona is a cautionary figure: a reminder of the destructive potential of grief and rage. In Estés's reading, she is also a figure of profound psychological truth about what happens when a woman abandons her own nature to please or keep someone else.

This reading is not intended as a critique of real mothers who face impossible circumstances. It is a psychological reading of the story's symbolic content. The point is that the self cannot be sacrificed without enormous cost, and that the cost is not borne only by the person who sacrifices it: the grief becomes destructive toward whatever remains.

The Ugly Duckling: Finding Your Own Kind

Estés's analysis of the Ugly Duckling departs from the usual reading in a significant way. The usual reading emphasises transformation: the ugly duckling becomes a beautiful swan. But Estés points out that the duckling does not transform. It was always a swan. What changes is not the duckling's nature but its context.

The story, she argues, is about the particular trauma of being born into or raised in a family or culture that does not recognise one's actual nature. The duckling is not defective; it is simply the wrong kind of bird for the nest it landed in. The constant attempts to make it conform, the constant experience of rejection and contempt, are not evidence of anything wrong with the duckling. They are evidence that it is in the wrong community.

Skeleton Woman: Love and the Life/Death/Life Cycle

The Skeleton Woman is an Inuit story that Estés uses to explore intimacy and the Life/Death/Life cycle. A woman was thrown into the sea by her father long ago. A fisherman accidentally hooks her skeleton while fishing and flees in terror, dragging her behind him. Back in his hut, exhausted, he falls asleep. She slowly reassembles herself using his heartbeat as a drum. She drinks a single tear from his sleeping face. In the morning, a living woman lies beside him.

Estés reads this as the archetypal story of genuine intimacy: "the vital task of any developing relationship." True love, she argues, requires the willingness to face (and even tenderly care for) the death and loss that is always present in any deep relationship. The man flees from the skeleton, the death aspect of the feminine. But he cannot escape her; she is attached to his line. Eventually, in his exhausted sleep, he allows his heartbeat to animate her.

The Life/Death/Life Cycle

Running through all of Estés's stories is the concept of the Life/Death/Life cycle: the understanding that creative and relational life moves not in a simple ascending line from worse to better, but in cycles that include growth, fullness, decline, death, and renewal.

Contemporary culture, Estés argues, is deeply uncomfortable with the death and fallow phases of this cycle. The dominant narrative demands continuous growth, continuous productivity, continuous positivity. When a creative project stalls, when a relationship enters a fallow period, when energy simply withdraws, the dominant cultural response is to pathologise this as failure or depression and to demand a return to productivity.

The Wild Woman governs the entire cycle. She is equally at home in the growth phases and the death phases. She knows that the fallow time is not empty but full, that the thing that appears to die is being composted into the material for the next growth. The loss of contact with the Wild Woman means the loss of this knowledge, and the result is exactly what Estés describes: a terror of natural endings, a compulsive clinging to what needs to die, and a consequent stunting of what needs to be born.

The Curandera Tradition

Estés's work draws on both her Jungian training and her inheritance from the curandera tradition of rural Mexico. This dual background is what distinguishes her approach from purely academic depth psychology.

The curandera is a traditional healer who works at the intersection of body, soul, and community. She uses plants, prayer, story, and ritual. She treats conditions that conventional medicine often does not recognise as illness: susto (soul fright), mal de ojo (the evil eye), and various forms of spiritual exhaustion and disorientation. Estés trained in this tradition alongside her academic training, and both are present in her work.

This is why her writing style matters as much as her content. She writes in the voice of an oral tradition: repetitive, rhythmic, personal, and direct. She addresses the reader as "you" and addresses her readers as a community. This is not rhetorical technique; it is the tradition in which she was trained, in which the teller's voice is part of the medicine.

Jungian Roots and Feminist Spirituality

Estés is working squarely within the Jungian tradition, particularly as interpreted by Marie-Louise von Franz: the tradition in which fairy tales are read as documents of the collective unconscious and amplification is used to reveal their archetypal depth. But she departs from that tradition in several ways that matter.

First, she centres the feminine explicitly, in a way that Jung himself (writing in the early-to-mid 20th century) and von Franz (writing within the Jungian institutional framework) did not always do. The Wild Woman is not a secondary figure, the anima seen from the outside; she is the central subject, the inner feminine seen from the inside.

Second, she brings a political dimension that is largely absent from classical Jungian analysis. The suppression of the Wild Woman is not only a personal or family phenomenon; it is a cultural and historical one. Patriarchal structures, colonial erasures of indigenous knowledge, consumer capitalism's reduction of instinct to consumption: all of these are, in Estés's account, forces that suppress the Wild Woman at a collective level.

This connects to the work of James Hillman on the Anima Mundi: the soul is not only inside the individual but in the world, and the damage to the world-soul is also damage to the individual soul. Both Hillman and Estés insist that psychology cannot be only an indoor, individual project.

Wild Woman and the Hermetic Feminine

The Wild Woman archetype, as Estés describes it, has deep connections to the Hermetic tradition's understanding of the feminine principle. In Hermetic cosmology, the feminine is not passive or receptive in a simple sense; it is the creative, generative, and meaningful force immanent in matter. The Hermetic Sophia, Divine Wisdom, is both the highest emanation of the divine and the deepest principle of material creation.

This is structurally identical to what Estés calls the Wild Woman: a principle that is simultaneously instinctual (in the body, in nature, in the cycles of the earth) and spiritual (the source of genuine creativity, perception, and wisdom). The Hermetic tradition's Anima Mundi, which Hillman drew on for his own archetypal psychology, and Estés's Wild Woman are expressions of the same fundamental understanding: that the feminine is not the opposite of the spiritual but the ground in which it grows.

The figure of Hermes Trismegistus in the Hermetic tradition represents precisely this kind of deep synthesis, and the Hermetic Synthesis Course explores these connections between the ancient traditions and modern depth psychology.

Related reading: Jung's Shadow, Anima and Animus, Marie-Louise von Franz, the Individuation Process, Complexes in Jungian Psychology.

Frequently Asked Questions