Rudolf Steiner's Dornach lecture cycle of 1916 and 1917 (GA 173 and 174), which argued that untruth in public life works on as a force with karmic consequences.
The Karma of Untruthfulness in Anthroposophy is the title of Rudolf Steiner's lecture cycle of December 1916 and January 1917, given at Dornach in neutral Switzerland and published as GA 173 and GA 174 (German: Zeitgeschichtliche Betrachtungen. Das Karma der Unwahrhaftigkeit). Speaking while wartime propaganda filled the European press, Steiner argued that untruth spoken in public life is never inert: it works on as a real force in history, and its consequences return upon nations and institutions as a kind of karma. Lecture by lecture he read newspaper judgments aloud to his audience, set them beside parliamentary records and published documents, and asked his listeners to verify claims before repeating them. The cycle stands under the motto his movement had taken from Goethe, that wisdom lies solely in truth, and historians of esotericism now read it as a primary source on the propaganda of the First World War.
Between 4 December 1916 and the end of January 1917, with the war at its height beyond the Swiss border, Rudolf Steiner gave his Dornach members the lectures collected as The Karma of Untruthfulness. His audience came from nations on both sides of the front. Rather than offering consolation, he set out to train their judgment, testing the day's public claims against documents and asking what untruth does once it enters the world.
In Steiner's Own Words
A number of years ago we chose as our motto these words by Goethe: ‘Wisdom lies solely in truth’. Our choice was not dictated by the superficial whims that often govern such decisions these days. We chose this motto bearing in mind that the human being needs to be prepared in his entire soul, in his whole nature, if he intends to absorb spiritual science into his soul in the right way, making it the real driving force of his life. The wide preparation he needs if he wants to penetrate in the proper way into spiritual science today is encapsulated in this motto: ‘Wisdom lies solely in truth’. Of course the word ‘truth’ must be seen as something serious and dignified in every connection.
What it Means Today
The cycle occupies an unusual place in Steiner's work: it is his reading of history applied in real time, under wartime conditions, to material his listeners could check the next morning. Steiner did not ask the Dornach audience to adopt his conclusions. He read out a Swiss editorial, a speech from the English Parliament, a Times leader from 1870, and then asked whether the judgment each carried survived comparison with the record. Untruth that goes unexamined, he held, does not simply evaporate; it becomes part of the karma a people must later live through. That is the claim sealed into the cycle's title.
Read today, the lectures work as a documented exercise in source criticism conducted decades before anyone spoke of media literacy. Johanna Collis translated both volumes for Rudolf Steiner Press (1988 and 1992), and the 2005 reissue, subtitled Secret Societies, the Media and Preparations for the Great War, names the cycle's most debated material: Steiner's assertions about occult brotherhoods influencing public opinion, which scholars treat strictly as his claims rather than established history. What endures is the discipline he modelled at Dornach. Where a judgment arrives ready-made, trace it to its source; where a phrase carries no experience behind it, decline to repeat it. His wager, restated through the Goethe motto of the opening lecture, was that a spiritual movement which tolerates comfortable untruth undermines its own foundations, and that the same law holds for nations.
Where to Read More