The two soul-moods music gained with the third: major as the soul turning outward in elation, minor as the soul turning inward toward sorrow.
Major and Minor in Anthroposophy are the two soul-moods that music gained when the interval of the third entered human hearing during the fourth post-Atlantean epoch. In The Inner Nature of Music (GA 283, 1920), Rudolf Steiner traces how the older age of the fifth knew no major or minor at all, because the listener still felt carried out of the body into the cosmos. Only when the third drew the tone-experience inward, into the player's own physical and etheric organisation, could feeling colour the music. Major then became the soul's outward turn toward devotion and elation; minor its inward turn toward introspection and sorrow. The two are not fixed scales but the soul swinging between meeting the world and withdrawing into itself, the throat-gesture of inwardly shaped sound.
In Steiner's Own Words
Major and minor, this peculiar connection between human subjectivity, the actual inner life of feeling, insofar as this life of feeling is bound to earthly physicality, only begins in the course of the fourth post-Atlantean epoch and is linked to the experience of the third. This is where the difference between major and minor becomes apparent. This is when the connection between the subjective soul and music occurs. And human beings can color music; only now do they acquire color. They are sometimes within themselves, sometimes outside themselves; the soul swings back and forth between devotion and introspection.
What it Means Today
Steiner's claim is musicological as much as spiritual: major and minor are not eternal givens but a historical acquisition, the soul's two ways of meeting the world through the tones of music. A player in the old age of the fifth felt lifted out of the body; the third pulled that experience back inward, and only then could a piece sound joyful or grieving at all. Modern music therapy works exactly this seam. At the Music Therapy Department of the Filderklinik near Stuttgart, anthroposophic therapists trained in the lyre tradition of Edmund Pracht and Lothar Gärtner choose deliberately between the major turn outward and the minor turn inward when meeting a patient whose feeling-life has contracted or overflowed, rather than treating the modes as mere happy and sad labels. The same reading shapes Waldorf classrooms. Following the indication that a child up to roughly the ninth year still lives in the open mood of the fifth and only then begins to ask after the major and minor third, teachers since the 1925 founding of the Stuttgart music curriculum hold back full major-minor harmony until that inner question appears. Where a conservatory treats the modes as fixed scales, the anthroposophic reading hears in each chord a gesture of the soul, swinging between devotion that gives itself to the world and the introspection that draws back into itself, a throat-region act of giving outward-streaming feeling an inwardly shaped form.
Where to Read More