Steiner's contrast between John's water baptism, which loosened the etheric body, and Christ's baptism with fire and Spirit, which works on the strengthened spirit itself.
The Baptism with Water and with Fire in Anthroposophy is Rudolf Steiner's contrast between two distinct initiatic acts, set out in GA 112, The Gospel of St. John in Relation to the Other Three Gospels (lecture of 30 June 1909, Kassel). John's baptism with water submerged the disciple in the Jordan, loosening the etheric body from the physical body so a survey of the whole life, the life-tableau, arose, together with the impulse of repentance. Christ's baptism with fire and with the Holy Spirit, John foretold of the One who came after him, involved no physical substance at all. It worked directly on a spirit made strong, letting the experiences of the astral body flow into the etheric body so that clairvoyance could arise within ordinary waking consciousness. The bearer is the human fourfold being; the cosmic-historical anchor is the Mystery of Golgotha, which made initiation possible without the older trance.
The Baptism with Water and with Fire names the two baptisms Steiner distinguishes in the Gospel of St. John. John baptized with water, drawing the etheric body partly out of the physical body so the candidate beheld his own life and felt called to repentance. Christ baptized with fire and with the Holy Spirit, an inner working on the spirit itself, needing no submersion and leaving everyday consciousness intact.
In Steiner's Own Words
Through the spirit that streams forth as the Christ impulse something flows into the body, something that can otherwise be induced only by way of psycho-physiological development through fire: an inner fire expressing itself in the circulation of the blood. John still baptized by submersion, with the result that the etheric body withdrew and the spiritual world was revealed. But if a man opens his soul to the Christ impulse, this impulse acts in such a way that the experiences of the astral body flow over into the etheric body, and clairvoyance results. There you have the explanation of the phrase, "to baptize with the spirit and with fire", and those are the facts concerning the difference between the John baptism and the Christ baptism.
What it Means Today
The clearest living continuation of this two-baptism reading is the sacrament of Baptism in The Christian Community (Die Christengemeinschaft), the movement for religious renewal founded in 1922 by a circle of theologians who had turned to Steiner for a renewed liturgy. Its first leader, the former Lutheran preacher Friedrich Rittelmeyer, served as the community's senior priest, the Erzoberlenker, until his death in 1938. The community kept baptism as one of its seven sacraments, and it kept water at the centre of the rite, while re-reading the act in the polarity Steiner set out in Kassel: the water that addresses the body and the inherited line of descent, and the fire and Spirit that address the child's own spirit, the part that comes from beyond heredity. Where the older Mysteries had to lay the candidate in a deathlike trance for three and a half days to loosen the etheric body, this renewed rite assumes the change Steiner located at the Mystery of Golgotha, that the spirit can now be reached without the body being put to sleep.
Thalira synthesis: read this way, John's water baptism and Christ's fire baptism are not two competing rituals but two ends of a single human axis, the etheric loosening that shows you your past and the spiritual ignition that strengthens your future, so that "with water and with fire" describes the whole arc from remembering what one has been to becoming master of what one is.
Where to Read More