Steiner's principle that good teaching keeps the child's ego from incarnating too deeply, which breeds earthbound natures, or too loosely, which breeds dreamers.
Balance in Teaching in Anthroposophy is Rudolf Steiner's pedagogical principle, set out in the 1920 lecture course later published as Meditatively Acquired Knowledge of Man (GA 302a), that the art of education consists in regulating how deeply the child's ego, the eternal I, incorporates into the physical, etheric, and astral bodies. An ego drawn in too firmly, Steiner taught, produces an earthbound, brain-bound nature he linked to brutality and criminality; an ego held too loosely produces a dreamer lost in fantasy. The teacher restores equilibrium through the curriculum itself. Arithmetic, geometry, and musical rhythm press the ego inward, while form-drawing, geography, and history lift it back out. Steiner gave this course at the Stuttgart Waldorf School in September 1920, and Waldorf remedial educators still apply its weighing-of-the-scales image when a child incarnates too deeply or too loosely.
Balance in teaching is Rudolf Steiner's principle that the educator's central task is to regulate how deeply the child's ego, or I, incorporates into the body. Set in GA 302a, the principle treats school subjects as counterweights: arithmetic, geometry, and musical rhythm draw the ego inward, while drawing, geography, and history lift it back out, so the growing human being settles neither too earthbound nor too dreamily loose.
In Steiner's Own Words
Through our education we must try to avoid everything that would lead to the ego becoming too strongly absorbed by the bodily organisation, becoming too dependent on it. You will understand the utter seriousness of this matter when I tell you that the cause of the criminality and brutality of some men lies in the fact that their ego was allowed to be absorbed too strongly during their years of growing up. The characteristics of degeneracy, found by anthropologists and known to you, which manifest fully only in later years, reveal themselves often as an ego which has been too strongly absorbed by the rest of the bodily organisation.
What it Means Today
Steiner delivered this course at the original Stuttgart Waldorf School in September 1920, and the weighing-of-the-scales image he used there still governs Waldorf remedial work a century later. The clearest modern carrier is The Extra Lesson by the English Waldorf teacher Audrey McAllen, published in North America by Rudolf Steiner College Press and now stewarded through the Waldorf Learning Support association. McAllen built a graded sequence of movement, form-drawing, and painting exercises that does exactly what Steiner described: it presses a too-dreamy ego more firmly into the body, or eases a too-earthbound ego back toward freedom. A child who reverses letters, who cannot hold rhythm, or who lives in fantasy is read not as a deficit to be drilled but as an ego out of balance with its organism, and the remedy is artistic rather than corrective. Thalira synthesis: where contemporary special education sorts children by measured deficit, Steiner's balance in teaching reframes the same children as souls whose incarnation runs early or late, so the curriculum becomes a set of counterweights on a scale rather than a ladder of remediation. The teacher does not push the child up; the teacher restores the equilibrium between an eternal I and the body it is learning to inhabit.
Where to Read More