The Secret by Rhonda Byrne: What the Law of Attraction Gets Right and Wrong

Who Is Rhonda Byrne?

Rhonda Byrne was born in Australia and built a career as a television producer, working on various Australian TV programmes. She was not a philosopher, spiritual teacher, or scientist. This matters because the authority of The Secret does not rest on expertise, lineage, or scholarship. It rests on commercial success and celebrity endorsement.

In 2004, Byrne was experiencing what she describes as a period of intense personal and professional crisis. Her father had died, and her business relationships were deteriorating. During this period, her daughter gave her a copy of Wallace Wattles's The Science of Getting Rich, a New Thought text originally published in 1910. Byrne has described reading Wattles as a revelation: the idea that thought creates reality, presented in the language of "science," struck her as a universal principle that had been suppressed or forgotten.

She produced a documentary film, also titled The Secret, in 2006, featuring a series of motivational speakers, self-help authors, and New Thought practitioners presenting various aspects of the law of attraction. The film went viral online. The book followed the same year and sold over 30 million copies, helped enormously by Oprah Winfrey's enthusiastic endorsement. Byrne subsequently published The Power (2010), The Magic (2012), Hero (2013), and The Greatest Secret (2020).

What The Secret Claims

The core claim is simple: your thoughts emit a frequency, and that frequency attracts experiences that match it. Think about wealth, and wealth comes. Think about poverty, and poverty comes. Think about health, and health follows. This is presented as a universal law comparable to gravity: it operates whether you believe in it or not, whether you are aware of it or not, and without exception.

The three-step process Byrne describes is: Ask (clarify what you want), Believe (feel as though you have already received it), Receive (be open to receiving what the universe delivers). This is presented as both ancient wisdom and cutting-edge science, validated (Byrne claims) by both spiritual traditions and quantum physics.

The book quotes a series of historical figures, including Plato, Shakespeare, Beethoven, Lincoln, Edison, and Einstein, claiming that each knew "the secret" and used it to achieve greatness. No primary sources are provided for most of these attributions, and several are demonstrably misquoted or fabricated. Einstein, for instance, never said most of the quotes attributed to him in the book.

The Real History: New Thought and Its Hermetic Roots

The law of attraction is not ancient in its current formulation. It is a product of the New Thought movement, an American metaphysical movement that emerged in the 1880s and reached its peak influence in the early 20th century.

The lineage begins with Phineas Parkhurst Quimby (1802-1866), a clockmaker from Maine who developed a healing practice based on the idea that disease is caused by erroneous beliefs and can be cured by correcting those beliefs. One of Quimby's patients was Mary Baker Eddy, who went on to found Christian Science, which teaches that matter and disease are illusions and that spiritual understanding alone is the reality.

The New Thought movement proper emerged from this milieu, developing a broader philosophy: that mind is the primary reality, that thought creates experience, and that aligning one's mental state with desired outcomes produces those outcomes. Key figures include Ralph Waldo Trine (In Tune with the Infinite, 1897), Charles Haanel (The Master Key System, 1912), and Wallace Wattles (The Science of Getting Rich, 1910), the book that directly inspired Byrne.

What most popular accounts of the law of attraction omit is the Hermetic influence on the New Thought movement. The Kybalion, published in 1908 by "Three Initiates" (almost certainly including William Walker Atkinson), presented seven Hermetic principles drawn from the tradition of Hermes Trismegistus. The first principle, Mentalism ("All is Mind; the Universe is Mental"), provided the metaphysical foundation for the law of attraction. The third principle, Vibration ("Nothing rests; everything moves; everything vibrates"), provided the mechanism: if everything vibrates, and if like attracts like, then thoughts of a particular vibration should attract experiences of a matching vibration.

William Walker Atkinson: The Source Behind the Source

William Walker Atkinson (1862-1932) is the most important figure in the law of attraction's intellectual history, and he is almost entirely unknown to readers of The Secret. Atkinson was a Chicago attorney who suffered a mental and physical breakdown in the 1890s, discovered New Thought, and devoted the rest of his life to writing about the relationship between mind and reality. He published over 100 books under his own name and numerous pseudonyms, including Theron Q. Dumont and Yogi Ramacharaka.

Atkinson's 1906 book Thought Vibration, or the Law of Attraction in the Thought World is the earliest systematic presentation of the law of attraction concept. But Atkinson's treatment is significantly more nuanced than Byrne's. He emphasizes that the law of attraction operates through action, not just thought. He insists on the role of will and concentration: unfocused wishful thinking does not produce results. He acknowledges that negative circumstances are not always the product of negative thinking and warns against the simplistic application of the principle to complex human suffering.

Atkinson was also likely the primary author of The Kybalion, which connects the law of attraction explicitly to the Hermetic tradition. This connection matters because it reveals what Byrne's version strips away: the Hermetic understanding that working with consciousness requires discipline, ethical alignment, and a sophisticated understanding of the relationship between the individual mind and the universal Mind. The alchemical tradition teaches that transformation requires both solve (dissolution of false beliefs) and coagula (reconstruction of consciousness through disciplined practice). Byrne offers only half of the first step: dissolving negative beliefs through positive ones. The rest of the work is omitted.

What The Secret Gets Right

Dismissing The Secret entirely would be as intellectually lazy as accepting it uncritically. The book does contain valid principles, even if they are embedded in a framework of magical thinking.

1. Attention Shapes Perception

What psychologists call the Reticular Activating System (RAS) filters the enormous volume of sensory data your brain receives, highlighting information that matches your current focus. If you are thinking about buying a red car, you suddenly notice red cars everywhere. They were always there; your attention has changed, not reality. This is a genuine psychological phenomenon, and it explains much of what people attribute to the law of attraction. When you clarify what you want, you begin noticing opportunities, connections, and resources that were always present but invisible to your unfocused attention.

2. Expectations Influence Behaviour

The expectancy effect is well documented in psychology. People who expect to succeed tend to persist longer, take more risks, and recover more quickly from setbacks than people who expect to fail. This is not because the universe responds to their thoughts. It is because their expectations influence their behaviour, and their behaviour influences their outcomes. The self-fulfilling prophecy is real, but it operates through psychology, not cosmic mechanics.

3. Gratitude Practices Improve Mental Health

The Secret's emphasis on gratitude has genuine scientific support. Positive psychology research by Robert Emmons and others has demonstrated that regular gratitude practices (listing things you are grateful for, writing gratitude letters, cultivating appreciation) measurably improve mood, reduce anxiety, and enhance relationships. This is one of the book's valid prescriptions, independent of its metaphysical claims.

4. Clarity of Intention Organizes Action

Knowing what you want is genuinely useful. When you clarify a goal, your brain begins organizing resources, attention, and energy toward it. This is not mystical. It is how executive function works. The Secret's instruction to visualize desired outcomes and maintain focus on them is consistent with sports psychology research on mental rehearsal and goal-setting theory.

What The Secret Gets Dangerously Wrong

1. Victim Blaming

If thoughts attract experiences, then victims of poverty, abuse, disease, and natural disaster must have attracted their suffering through negative thinking. This is the most ethically objectionable implication of the law of attraction as Byrne presents it. The book does not shy away from this implication. It states that "the only reason any person does not have enough money is because they are blocking money from coming to them with their thoughts."

Applied to its logical conclusion, this means that children born into poverty chose it at a vibrational level. That cancer patients attracted their disease. That victims of genocide thought their way into mass murder. This is not merely wrong. It is morally repugnant. It transforms a genuine psychological insight (that mental states influence behaviour) into a justification for ignoring structural inequality, systemic injustice, and the role of power in determining who suffers and who thrives.

2. Magical Thinking Replaces Action

The Secret consistently implies that thought alone is sufficient. "The only thing you need to do is feel good now," Byrne writes. This is not what Atkinson taught. It is not what Wattles taught. It is not what any serious New Thought practitioner has ever taught. Even within the New Thought tradition, aligned action is always part of the formula. Wattles explicitly states in The Science of Getting Rich that one must "act in a certain way" and that thought without action produces nothing. Byrne strips this qualification away, leaving readers with the impression that visualization and emotional vibration are sufficient without effort, strategy, or work.

3. Misrepresentation of Science

The Secret claims that quantum physics supports the law of attraction. It does not. Quantum mechanics describes the behaviour of subatomic particles under specific experimental conditions. It does not support the claim that human thoughts influence macroscopic reality through vibrational frequencies. Harvard physicist Lisa Randall has specifically addressed and rejected the book's quantum physics claims. The conflation of quantum mechanics with metaphysical claims about consciousness is a pattern found throughout New Age literature, and scientists have consistently objected to it.

4. Health Dangers

The book implies that thought can cure disease. This is dangerous. People with serious medical conditions who delay or refuse treatment because they believe positive thinking will heal them are at genuine risk. The medical community has been vocal about the harm caused by such claims. Positive mental states can support healing (psychoneuroimmunology has demonstrated real connections between mental state and immune function), but they cannot substitute for medical treatment of serious disease.

The Quantum Physics Problem

The Secret's misuse of quantum physics deserves its own section because it is representative of a broader problem in popular spirituality.

The book claims that quantum physics has proven that the observer affects the observed, and that this proves thoughts affect reality. The first claim has a grain of truth: in quantum mechanics, the act of measurement does affect quantum states. The second claim is a wild extrapolation. The observer effect in quantum mechanics operates at the subatomic level under controlled experimental conditions. It does not mean that a person thinking about a new car causes a new car to appear. The scale, mechanism, and context are entirely different.

Physicists Christopher Chabris and Daniel Simons, writing in the New York Times, and Lisa Randall at Harvard have each addressed and rejected The Secret's quantum physics claims. The consensus among physicists is clear: quantum mechanics does not support the law of attraction, and claiming it does misrepresents one of the most rigorously tested theories in science.

Scholarly Reception and Criticism

The scholarly response to The Secret has been almost uniformly negative.

Barbara Ehrenreich's Bright-Sided: How the Relentless Promotion of Positive Thinking Has Undermined America (2009) provides the most comprehensive cultural critique. Ehrenreich argues that the cult of positive thinking, of which The Secret is the most extreme expression, promotes political complacency (if your circumstances are the product of your thoughts, there is no need to organize for structural change), economic naivety (the 2008 financial crisis was partly caused by ungrounded optimism about perpetual growth), and personal cruelty (telling struggling people that their suffering is their own fault).

Mark Manson, in his critique, calls the book "a playbook for entitlement and self-absorption" that encourages people to focus on getting what they want rather than on developing the character, skills, and relationships that produce genuine fulfilment.

Mary Carmichael and Ben Radford, writing for the Center for Inquiry, characterize The Secret as "a time-worn trick of mixing banal truisms with magical thinking and presenting it as some sort of hidden knowledge: basically, it's the new New Thought." This assessment is precise: the book's valid insights (gratitude is good, clarity of intention is helpful) are banal, and its distinctive claims (thought alone attracts reality) are magical thinking.

A Hermetic Perspective on the Law of Attraction

The Hermetic tradition is the ultimate source of the ideas that, through a long chain of simplification, produced The Secret. Examining what the tradition actually teaches reveals how much has been lost.

The Hermetic principle of Mentalism does teach that "All is Mind; the Universe is Mental." This is the foundation of the law of attraction. But the Hermetic tradition qualifies this principle in ways that The Secret does not:

First: the Mind referred to is not the individual human mind but the Universal Mind in which all individual minds participate. The individual does not create reality by thinking about it. The individual participates in a reality that is already mental in nature. This is a important distinction. In the Hermetic view, working with consciousness requires aligning the individual mind with the Universal Mind, not projecting personal desires onto the cosmos.

Second: the Hermetic tradition includes the principle of Polarity ("Everything has its pair of opposites"), which means that attraction and repulsion are both aspects of a single principle. You cannot have attraction without the possibility of repulsion. The desire for wealth, if it arises from fear of poverty, vibrates at the frequency of poverty, not wealth. This is a far more subtle teaching than "think positive thoughts."

Third: the Hermetic tradition teaches that working with consciousness requires ethical purification, disciplined practice, and the guidance of an experienced teacher. The alchemical tradition makes this explicit: before you can transmute lead into gold, you must first purify the vessel (yourself). An impure vessel, one filled with egotism, greed, or the desire for power over others, will produce only more impurity. The Secret skips the purification entirely and goes straight to the gold.

The Hermetic Synthesis Course provides the structured approach to consciousness and reality that The Secret promises but does not deliver: the actual practices, ethical framework, and progressive stages of development that the Hermetic tradition has refined over two millennia.

Who Should Read This Book

If you have never encountered the idea that your mental state influences your experience, The Secret provides an accessible (if oversimplified) introduction. Read it with critical eyes. Take the practices of gratitude, visualization, and intention-setting. Leave the magical thinking, the quantum physics misrepresentations, and the victim-blaming.

Better yet, skip The Secret and go directly to its sources. Wallace Wattles's The Science of Getting Rich is shorter, more honest, and includes the role of action that Byrne omits. William Walker Atkinson's Thought Vibration provides the intellectual substance behind the law of attraction concept. Neville Goddard's The Power of Awareness offers a more sophisticated treatment of the relationship between imagination and reality. And the Kybalion provides the Hermetic framework that makes sense of why consciousness and reality are related, without pretending that this relationship is simpler than it is.

For anyone who has connected with the law of attraction and wants to understand its actual roots, explore the Hermetic tradition directly. What you will find is richer, more honest, and more demanding than anything in The Secret, and precisely because of that demand, more likely to produce the transformation the book promises but cannot deliver.

Get the Book

If you want to read The Secret for yourself and form your own assessment, you can find it on Amazon.

Frequently Asked Questions