The Study of Man by Rudolf Steiner: An Honest Review

Last Updated: October 2026. Expanded the assessment of the physiology and added the section on outcomes evidence.

Quick Answer

Steiner had two weeks to prepare a dozen people to open a school, and these fourteen lectures are what he told them. Not a curriculum and not a method: an account of what a human being is, from which the method was supposed to follow. The physiology is wrong, the developmental observations are frequently sharp, and the book assumes a metaphysics it never pauses to defend. It is the source document for a global school movement and it was never written for you.

Key Takeaways

  • Fourteen lectures, two weeks before opening. Read it as spoken, urgent and unedited.
  • Thinking, feeling, willing mapped onto three bodily systems.
  • The physiology does not hold. The pedagogy is a separate question.
  • Seven-year stages determine what Waldorf teaches when.
  • Get the newer translation. Foundations of Human Experience is the better text.

🕑 17 min read

What This Book Is

Fourteen lectures delivered in Stuttgart between 21 August and 5 September 1919, transcribed by a stenographer and published from those notes.

They form one of three parallel courses Steiner gave simultaneously that fortnight. This one covers the theory of the human being; a second covers method; a third consists of practical seminar discussions.

This is the foundational volume of the three and the one the movement treats as primary. Waldorf teacher training still works through it, usually over a full year, at roughly the pace of one lecture a fortnight.

The book contains almost nothing a reader would recognise as educational advice. It is an anthropology, in the older sense of an account of what the human being is, and the pedagogy is left to be derived.

Not a starting point. If you have not read Steiner before, this is among the worst places to begin. It presumes his epistemology, his account of the spiritual bodies, and reincarnation, and it explains none of them. Start elsewhere and come back.

The Two Weeks

The circumstances explain almost everything about how the book reads.

Germany in August 1919 was nine months out of a lost war, in economic collapse, with the political order destroyed and the new republic barely standing.

Emil Molt, who ran the Waldorf-Astoria cigarette factory in Stuttgart, proposed a school for his workers' children and asked Steiner to shape it. Steiner agreed, and the school was to open in September.

That left a fortnight to prepare a teaching body, most of whom had never taught. Steiner lectured to them three times a day for two weeks.

What comes through the transcript is urgency. There is no polish, no allowance for a reader outside the room, and a recurring insistence that these people are about to be responsible for actual children and that the stakes are civilisational.

Steiner also connects the school explicitly to his political proposals for a threefold social order, which he was promoting that same year. The school was intended as a demonstration that cultural life could be free of state and economic control, and that framing is present throughout.

The Two Titles

A practical matter that confuses buyers.

The German is Allgemeine Menschenkunde als Grundlage der Pädagogik, roughly a general knowledge of the human being as the basis of pedagogy.

The older English translation, published as The Study of Man, is serviceable and dated, and its language reflects mid-century translation conventions.

The newer translation, Foundations of Human Experience, is more accurate and considerably easier, and includes apparatus explaining the terminology.

They are the same fourteen lectures. Anyone buying should prefer the newer version, and should be aware that most secondary literature cites the older one by lecture number, which both editions preserve.

Thinking, Feeling, Willing

The organising division, and the most useful thing in the book.

Steiner divides human inner activity into three: thinking, feeling and willing. The division is not original to him and goes back through German idealism to the ancients.

What he does with it is the contribution. He argues that education has concentrated almost entirely on thinking, that feeling and willing are treated as background conditions rather than as capacities to be developed, and that a child educated only in the first is deformed.

Willing, in his usage, is not motivation or determination. It is the capacity for purposeful action, expressed in movement, and it develops through doing rather than through instruction.

Feeling is not emotion in the sense of moods. It is the capacity for relation, for being affected by what is met, and it develops through art and through the quality of what is presented.

The practical consequence is the Waldorf emphasis on craft, movement and art as central subjects rather than as enrichment.

The Three Bodily Systems

Where the framework becomes physiological, and where the trouble starts.

Steiner associates each capacity with a bodily system. Thinking with the nerve and sense system, centred in the head. Feeling with the rhythmic system, the heart and lungs and everything that pulses. Willing with the metabolic and limb system.

He then makes specific claims. That the nervous system is essentially a system of dying processes, that consciousness depends on a continual breaking down of matter, and that the metabolic system is a system of upbuilding which is correspondingly unconscious.

His conclusion is that we are awake in our thinking, dreaming in our feeling, and asleep in our willing, and that this graded consciousness is the reason we can observe our thoughts and cannot observe how we raise an arm.

The last observation is worth separating from the physiology attached to it. You genuinely cannot introspect the process by which an intention becomes a movement; the intention is available and the execution is not, and something similar holds for the middle region of feeling, which is neither transparent nor entirely dark. That is a real feature of experience and Steiner describes it accurately. Whether it is because the limbs run on upbuilding metabolic processes is another matter entirely.

Where the Physiology Fails

Stated plainly, because the movement's literature tends not to.

The nervous system does not work by destruction of substance in the way Steiner describes. Nerve conduction is electrochemical, well characterised, and does not involve the breaking down he requires.

The localisation of feeling in the heart and lungs has no support. The heart is a pump, and the emotional systems of the brain were unmapped in 1919 and are now reasonably well described.

Steiner's claim about the heart not being a pump, made elsewhere and implied here, is simply incorrect.

What should be said in fairness is that he did not present these as findings from laboratory research. He presented them as results of spiritual investigation, a method he claimed to have developed and which cannot be checked by ordinary means.

That framing removes the charge of bad science and replaces it with a harder problem: a set of claims about the body that conflict with what can be measured, offered on an authority that admits no external test.

The Seven-Year Periods

The developmental scheme, and the part with the most practical consequence.

Steiner divides childhood into three periods of roughly seven years, each marked by a bodily change and each requiring a different approach.

Birth to around seven, ending with the change of teeth. The child learns by imitation, absorbs the moral quality of the surrounding adults directly, and should not be taught abstractly. Formal reading instruction is deferred.

Seven to around fourteen, ending at puberty. The child learns through feeling and through relation to a loved authority. Material should arrive as image and story before it arrives as concept.

Fourteen to twenty-one. Independent judgement becomes possible, and the young person can now be given the reasoning behind what they learned earlier as picture.

The scheme is stated with more precision than any evidence supports, and its broad shape is not absurd: a shift around six or seven and another at puberty are recognised in every developmental psychology, though the mechanisms proposed are entirely different.

Imitation, Authority, Judgement

The three modes, and their pedagogical consequences.

The imitation claim is the strongest. Steiner holds that a young child does not learn from what adults say but from what they are, absorbing gesture, mood and inner attitude directly.

The practical instruction is uncomfortable for teachers: what you actually feel about the material matters more than how you present it, because the children are taking in the first regardless.

The authority phase is the most criticised. Steiner argues that a child of this age needs a beloved authority whose judgement they accept, and that this is a developmental need rather than a limitation to be corrected.

Contemporary education generally treats fostering independent judgement as an aim at every age, and this is a real philosophical disagreement rather than a misunderstanding.

Steiner's defence is that judgement exercised before the capacity has developed produces opinions borrowed from elsewhere while feeling like one's own, which is worth considering even by people who reject the rest.

What He Says About Memory

A theme running through several lectures and among his better observations.

Steiner argues against early memorisation of material the child does not understand, holding that it produces a specific kind of later rigidity.

His alternative is that material should be met first in image and activity, allowed to live for a period, and defined only afterwards. A concept given too early, in his account, fixes and stops growing.

He uses an image of concepts as living things that should be able to change shape as the child does, and warns that a sharply defined concept given at eight is still the same shape at forty.

Whatever the mechanism, the pedagogical instruction has independent support. Delaying formal definition while building rich experience is close to what a good deal of later research recommends for conceptual learning.

The Temperaments

The classical scheme Steiner revived, and it is applied throughout Waldorf practice.

The four temperaments, choleric, sanguine, melancholic and phlegmatic, come from Greek medicine by way of a long European afterlife.

Steiner treats them as real constitutional types, associates each with one of the spiritual bodies, and instructs teachers to identify each child's temperament and to seat and handle them accordingly.

The recommended approach is homeopathic rather than corrective. A choleric child is met with material that gives their intensity somewhere to go, and grouping children of the same temperament together lets them encounter their own tendency in others.

As psychology this has no standing; the humoral types do not survive contact with any modern account of personality. As a practical heuristic for a teacher noticing that children differ in tempo and reactivity, it functions better than its theoretical basis deserves.

Sympathy and Antipathy

The most abstract material in the book, and the hardest going.

Steiner proposes that two opposed forces run through all mental life. Antipathy, which separates, defines, fixes and produces concepts and memory. Sympathy, which unites, dissolves boundaries, and belongs to will and to life.

Thinking is on this account a process of pushing away: to have a clear concept of something is to have separated from it.

He connects antipathy to the nerve pole and to death processes, sympathy to the metabolic pole and to life, and argues that consciousness arises in the tension between them.

The lectures dealing with this are the ones readers most often abandon. They are stated compactly, they use the terms in specialised ways, and no summary makes them straightforward.

The Structures It Produced

Worth setting out, because these lectures generated institutional arrangements that outlasted the reasoning behind them.

The class teacher stays with the same group for eight years, teaching the main academic lesson each morning across every subject. This follows from the authority phase: if a child of that age learns through relation to a trusted adult, then rotating teachers annually breaks the mechanism the method depends on.

The main lesson runs for roughly two hours at the start of each day and covers a single subject for a block of several weeks before moving to the next. The justification is the account of memory: material needs time to settle rather than being revisited in forty-minute fragments across a year.

Formal reading is deferred until around age seven, on the grounds that early abstraction draws on forces the young child needs for physical development.

And the arts are timetabled as core rather than optional, following directly from the threefold scheme, since feeling and willing require their own subjects if they are to be educated at all.

Each of these has an obvious cost. Eight years with one teacher is excellent with a good one and difficult with a poor one, and the movement has no reliable mechanism for handling the second case. Block teaching means long gaps between encounters with a subject. Deferred literacy worries parents and produces measurable early lag.

What is striking is how much of the structure is defensible on ordinary grounds that Steiner never used. Long-term relationships between teacher and pupil, sustained attention to one subject, and time for practical and artistic work would each find support in current educational research, arrived at by entirely different routes.

What He Asks of the Teacher

The demand running under the whole course, and it is severe.

Steiner is not offering techniques. His position is that the teacher's own inner condition is the primary instrument, and that a method applied by someone who has not worked on themselves will not do what it is supposed to.

He asks for daily inner practice, for a meditative relation to each child, and for the teacher to review the class inwardly each evening.

He also asks for enthusiasm as a professional requirement, on the grounds that a bored teacher transmits boredom regardless of the material.

This is why Waldorf training is long and unusual, and why the movement has recruitment difficulties. The job as described here is not one that can be done by qualification alone.

Does It Work

The question a reader will want answered, and the honest answer is that it is hard to establish.

Waldorf schools now number well over a thousand worldwide, which is a substantial run for a method invented in a fortnight.

The research is genuinely difficult to interpret. Most Waldorf schools are private and fee-paying, so families self-select for income, education and commitment, and separating the method from the intake is close to impossible.

What studies report, taken cautiously: later early literacy that generally closes by around age eleven, comparable or better outcomes in some measures of creativity and engagement, and mixed results in mathematics and sciences.

A recurring finding is high pupil satisfaction and strong school attachment, which may say as much about small classes and a single long-term teacher as about the anthroposophy.

There are also documented problems. Anti-vaccination attitudes have clustered in some Waldorf communities and produced measles outbreaks, which is a real public health matter and is connected to anthroposophical views on illness.

The Objections

Three, in order of seriousness.

The foundation does not hold. The physiology is wrong, and the pedagogy is presented as following from it. If the derivation fails, the practices need justifying some other way, which the movement has largely not attempted.

Unfalsifiable authority. Claims from spiritual investigation cannot be checked, which makes the framework immune to correction and leaves practitioners with no way to revise it.

The wider corpus. Steiner's lectures elsewhere contain material on race and national character that is indefensible. This volume is largely clear of it, and a reader should know what is in the surrounding shelf.

How to Read It

Practical guidance for a difficult text.

Read one lecture at a time and leave a gap. This is how the training courses do it, and the material does not reward speed.

Read the companion volumes alongside. The practical seminar discussions are far more concrete and make this one intelligible.

Separate the observations from the derivations as you go. When Steiner describes children, he is frequently acute. When he explains why, hold it loosely.

Expect the middle lectures to defeat you at least once.

Who Should Read It

Read it if you teach in or send children to a Waldorf school and want the source rather than the interpretations.

Read it if you are interested in anthroposophy in application, since this is where it meets an actual institution and real children.

Read it if theories of child development interest you and you want to see one built on completely different premises.

Do not read it as your first Steiner, and do not read it expecting practical classroom advice.

One instruction here is worth taking whatever you make of the rest. Steiner tells the teachers that the children absorb what they are rather than what they say, and that no technique compensates for the inner state they bring into the room. This is stated as spiritual fact and it is observably true in an ordinary way. Anyone who has been around a person doing work they find dull has felt it transmitted, and no amount of professional manner conceals it. Whether or not the metaphysics holds, the requirement it generates is real: the state you arrive in is part of what you deliver.

The fourteen lectures a global school movement was built from.

The Study of Man on Amazon

Affiliate disclosure: Thalira earns a small commission on purchases made through the link above, at no additional cost to you. Our assessment of the physiology, the evidence on outcomes and the wider corpus is set out above and is independent of the link.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is The Study of Man about?

Fourteen lectures Rudolf Steiner gave in Stuttgart in August 1919 to the teachers of the first Waldorf school, setting out the picture of the human being the whole method is built on.

Why are there two titles?

The older English translation is called The Study of Man. The newer one is Foundations of Human Experience, which renders the German more accurately. They are the same fourteen lectures.

Who was it written for?

Not a general readership. It was spoken to about twelve people who were about to open a school in two weeks, most of whom already knew Steiner's work well.

What is the threefold human being?

Steiner's division of human activity into thinking, feeling and willing, associated respectively with the nervous system, the rhythmic system of heart and lungs, and the metabolic and limb system.

What are the seven-year periods?

His developmental scheme dividing childhood into stages of roughly seven years, each with a different mode of learning, which determines what Waldorf schools teach at which age.

Do you need to accept anthroposophy to use it?

The book assumes it throughout, including reincarnation and the spiritual bodies. Many practising Waldorf teachers work with the pedagogical observations while holding the metaphysics loosely.

Is it difficult?

Considerably. It is transcribed speech, it assumes familiarity with Steiner's earlier work, the terminology is unexplained, and the argument moves without signposting.

What does he say about memory?

That forcing early memorisation has costs later, that material should be met before it is defined, and that what is learned through feeling and activity is retained differently from what is drilled.

Is the physiology accurate?

No. The claims about nerves, blood and the location of psychological functions do not correspond to what is known, and Steiner presents them as results of spiritual investigation rather than of research.

Does Waldorf education work?

The evidence is mixed and hard to read, since the schools are self-selecting and largely private. Studies report advantages in some areas and delays in early literacy that later close.

What about the racial passages?

Steiner's wider corpus contains statements about racial and national characteristics that are indefensible. This volume is largely free of them, and the question is live within the movement.

Who should read it?

Waldorf teachers and parents who want the source rather than the summaries, and readers interested in what a completely non-standard theory of child development looks like.

Keep the observation, question the derivation

This book is a useful exercise in a skill that matters well beyond Steiner. Almost every page contains an observation about children and an explanation of it, welded together and presented as one thing. The observations are often good, drawn from someone who watched carefully. The explanations rest on a physiology that is not correct. Learning to hold those apart, to say that this is well seen and that is not why, is harder than either accepting the whole or rejecting the whole, and it is the only way to get anything from a tradition you do not share.

Sources & References

  • Steiner, Rudolf (1919). The Study of Man / Foundations of Human Experience, GA 293.
  • Steiner, R. Practical Advice to Teachers and the seminar discussions, the companion courses.
  • Molt, Emil. Accounts of the founding of the first Waldorf school.
  • Published research comparing Waldorf and mainstream pupil outcomes.
  • Public health reporting on vaccination rates in Waldorf communities.
  • Scholarly discussion of race in Steiner's collected lectures.
Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.