Quick Answer
The book that turned Goddess religion from an idea into something people could do on a Tuesday night. A twenty-eight-year-old Faery-trained witch in San Francisco wrote a theology of immanence, a feminist and ecological politics, and a complete practice, with breathing exercises, trance work, circle casting and full rituals for the year, and it sold hundreds of thousands and made a movement. The history she gave it was wrong, and she said so herself in the notes she added ten and twenty years later, which are the most honest thing in the book. The practice was not wrong. It is still the practice.
Key Takeaways
- Immanence: the Goddess is the world, not above it.
- Magic as consciousness: the art of changing it at will.
- The exercises: grounding, trance, energy, the cone of power.
- The history was wrong, and the author's own notes say so.
- Politics in the circle: feminism and ecology as religious acts.
17 min read
What This Book Is
The Spiral Dance: A Rebirth of the Ancient Religion of the Great Goddess was published by Harper and Row in 1979, in a tenth-anniversary edition in 1989, and in a twentieth-anniversary edition in 1999, which is the current text. It is around three hundred pages in thirteen chapters, with the 1999 edition adding two introductions and a set of notes on each chapter that together run to another sixty.
The book has three layers. A theology, of the Goddess as immanent in the world and of witchcraft as her religion. A practice, laid out as exercises at the end of most chapters and as full rituals in the later ones. And a politics, feminist and ecological, which Starhawk understands as inseparable from the religion. The 1979 text also had a history, of witchcraft as the survival of an ancient Goddess religion, which the later editions revise.
It sold in numbers that no book on witchcraft had before, and it is, with Adler's survey published the same year, the founding text of American Paganism as a public movement.
Which edition. The 1999 twentieth-anniversary edition keeps the original text unchanged and adds, after each chapter, Starhawk's notes from 1989 and 1999 on what she would now say differently. The notes correct the history, revise the gender essentialism, report how the rituals evolved and describe Reclaiming's growth. Reading the original without them gives the 1979 book; reading them gives the author's own review of it, which is better than any outsider's.
Who Starhawk Is
Miriam Simos was born in 1951 in St Paul, Minnesota, to a Jewish family, and grew up in Los Angeles. She studied art and film at UCLA, encountered witchcraft as a student in the late 1960s, was initiated by Victor and Cora Anderson into the Faery tradition, and by the mid-1970s was teaching classes in the Craft in San Francisco. She took the name Starhawk from a dream. The Spiral Dance grew from her class notes and from a thesis on the Goddess movement written for a master's degree in psychology.
In 1980 she and Diane Baker founded the Reclaiming collective, which became a tradition; through the 1980s she was arrested repeatedly in anti-nuclear and environmental actions and wrote Dreaming the Dark and Truth or Dare on magic and political power; in the 1990s she wrote the novel The Fifth Sacred Thing; and since the 2000s she has taught permaculture and Earth Activist Training. She remains the most widely read author in Goddess religion and the movement's best-known public figure.
The Faery Tradition
The lineage behind the practice, which the book acknowledges and adapts.
Victor Anderson, a blind poet in the San Francisco Bay Area, taught a witchcraft he said he had received from a Hawaiian kahuna and from Appalachian and other sources. It stressed ecstatic trance, direct sensory contact with the divine, a doctrine of three souls, and a poetic rather than ceremonial style. Starhawk was one of his students, and much of the book's method, the grounding, the energy work, the trance induction, the sense of magic as felt rather than performed, comes from Faery. She altered it, dropping much of its secrecy and its harder edges, and Anderson and others in the tradition were not all pleased with what she published. The book is best read as Faery made public and feminist, and the notes discuss the relationship.
The Spiral Dance
The ritual that gives the book its name, and its image of the whole.
Participants join hands in a line and follow a leader who spirals inward toward the centre, then turns and spirals out again, so that the line doubles back on itself and each person passes face to face with every other. Starhawk describes it as the ritual of the Samhain gathering and as the shape of the religion: not an ascent toward a distant god but a winding into the centre and back, in which the sacred is met in the faces of the others. The dance has been performed at Reclaiming's Samhain ritual in San Francisco every year since, with hundreds of participants, and it is the book's most literal legacy.
The History as Told in 1979
The part of the book that has dated, given fairly.
The first chapter tells the story that the Goddess movement believed in 1979: that religion began in the Paleolithic with the worship of the Goddess, that Neolithic Europe was a peaceful matriarchal or matrifocal culture, that the Indo-European invasions brought patriarchy and the sky gods, that the Old Religion survived among the peasants of Europe, that the Christian Church persecuted it as witchcraft, burning nine million in the Burning Times, and that Wicca is its survival and revival. The account draws on Margaret Murray, Robert Graves, Marija Gimbutas and the feminist historians of the 1970s.
Almost none of it has held. The matriarchy is unproven and mostly abandoned by archaeologists; the witch trials killed perhaps forty to sixty thousand, not nine million, and the victims were Christians, not Pagans; the survival of an organised Old Religion through the Middle Ages has no evidence; and Wicca was assembled in the twentieth century. Starhawk's 1989 and 1999 notes concede all of this, and readers should take the first chapter as the myth the movement told itself, which is a fact about the movement rather than about the past.
Immanence
The theological centre, and the part that has not dated.
The Goddess, Starhawk writes, is not a being outside the world who made it. She is the world: the earth, the body, the cycle of birth and death and return, alive and sacred in every part. To worship her is to recognise the sacredness of what is already here, and the sin of patriarchal religion, in Starhawk's account, is to have placed the divine outside and above, so that the world became dead matter and the body became shame. The religion of the Goddess reverses this. Nothing is profane. The divine is met in the flesh, in the seasons, in the circle of the coven, and there is nowhere to go to find it because it is everywhere.
The theology is stated with force and simplicity, and it has become the common ground of modern Paganism whatever the tradition. It also connects the book to the divine feminine more broadly, and readers from outside witchcraft have taken the immanence and left the rest.
The Goddess
The chapter on the deity, and the book's most poetic.
The Goddess is triple, Maiden, Mother and Crone, the phases of the moon and of a woman's life; she is the earth and the sea and the sky; she is many-named, and Starhawk gives the names of the Goddesses of the world as her aspects. The chapter is written in a mixture of exposition and invocation, and it includes the Charge of the Goddess, the Wiccan liturgical text that Doreen Valiente had written for Gardner in the 1950s, in Starhawk's adaptation. The chapter's purpose is to give the reader an image of the divine as female, whole and immanent, and it did that for a great many readers who had never been offered one.
The God
The chapter often forgotten.
Starhawk's witchcraft is not Goddess-only. The God is the Horned One, the lord of animals and the wild, the child of the Goddess and her consort, the dying and returning one who is born at Yule, grows through the year, is cut down at the harvest and descends to the underworld to be reborn. He is the male divine as the Goddess's complement, and the chapter presents him as an image of masculinity that is not domination: wild, tender, mortal, bound to the cycle. The 1999 notes record that Starhawk would now present him differently and that Reclaiming's understanding of gender has moved beyond the polarity, but the God was there in 1979 and the book was never for women alone.
Magic and the Changing of Consciousness
The definition that has been quoted for forty years.
Magic, Starhawk writes, borrowing from Dion Fortune, is the art of changing consciousness at will. It is not supernatural; it works through the mind and the body, through image, breath, rhythm and intention, and its first effect is on the practitioner. The chapter sets out the psychology: the Younger Self, which thinks in images and feels; the Talking Self, which reasons and speaks; and the Deep Self or God Self, which is the divine within, reached through the Younger Self. Magic is the training of the Younger Self and the opening to the Deep, and ritual is the technology for doing it. The scheme comes from Faery's three souls and has entered Pagan practice generally.
The Exercises
The reason the book was used and not only read.
Most chapters end with exercises, numbered and progressive. Breathing and relaxation. Grounding and centring, the tree of life visualisation in which roots go into the earth and branches into the sky. Sensing energy in the hands and between people. Visualisation of images and colours. Trance induction and the rainbow staircase. Raising and directing energy. Working with the elements. Creating a personal sacred space. The exercises are simple, clear, and cumulative, and a reader who does them in order over some months will have the basic skills of the practice. Many thousands did, and the exercises have been reprinted and adapted in most subsequent Pagan manuals.
Casting the Circle
The core ritual form, given fully.
The circle is cast by walking its boundary with intention, the four quarters are called, East for air, South for fire, West for water, North for earth, the Goddess and God are invoked, the work is done, the deities are thanked, the quarters are dismissed and the circle is opened. Starhawk gives the words, the gestures and the reasons, and she explains the circle as a container for energy and a boundary between the ordinary and the sacred. The form is Wiccan and older, but her version, with its emphasis on felt energy over ceremonial correctness, became the standard for the eclectic traditions.
The Cone of Power
The central act of the working.
The coven raises energy, by chant, dance, breath or drumming, until it peaks, and then directs it, through visualisation, toward the purpose of the working, whether healing, protection or change. Starhawk describes the raising and the release, the sense of the energy as a cone rising from the circle, and the grounding afterward in which the excess is returned to the earth. She treats the cone as the practical heart of witchcraft and describes its use in group and solitary work, and the chapter is where the book's method and its theology come together: the energy raised is the immanent divine made active.
The book's lasting move is to have written down what had been secret. Wicca had been initiatory, oath-bound and transmitted in person; Faery had been more so. Starhawk published the grounding, the circle, the cone, the sabbats and the invocations, with instructions, for anyone with the price of a paperback. Her elders were not all pleased and the notes record the argument. But the effect was to make the practice available to people who would never find a coven, and the eclectic, self-taught, book-learned witchcraft that is now the majority of the movement is in large part the consequence of this one book's decision that the Goddess did not need gatekeepers.
The Coven
The community, and the book's model of it.
Starhawk's coven is small, ideally thirteen or fewer, non-hierarchical in principle though with a priestess who guides, and consensus-based in its decisions. The chapter describes how to form one, how to run its meetings, how to handle conflict, and how the coven is at once a support group, a working group and a family. The model is drawn from the feminist consciousness-raising groups of the 1970s as much as from Wicca, and the 1999 notes describe how Reclaiming developed it into a formal process of shared leadership. Readers from other traditions have found the chapter useful for small spiritual groups of any kind.
The Rituals of the Year
The later chapters, with full rituals for the eight sabbats of the wheel of the year, from Samhain through Yule, Brigid, Eostar, Beltane, Litha, Lughnasadh and Mabon, and for the full moons, for initiation, for handfasting, and for rites of passage. Each ritual is given with its invocations, its actions and its meaning, and each can be used as written or adapted. The rituals are lyrical and participatory, with call and response and movement, and they are the practical model for most of the public Pagan ritual performed since. The Samhain and Beltane rituals are the most used.
The Politics
The book's second argument, inseparable from the first.
If the Goddess is immanent, Starhawk argues, then the destruction of the earth is sacrilege and the domination of women is a violation of the divine image, and the religion of the Goddess is necessarily ecological and feminist. The witch is a political figure: the woman the patriarchy burned, reclaimed as the woman who will not be ruled. The last chapter, on the future, connects the practice to the anti-nuclear and ecology movements and to a vision of a society organised on the coven's principles of consensus and immanent value. Starhawk's own arrests in the 1980s, and her later books on power, are the working out of this chapter, and it is why the book was read beyond the Pagan community.
The Anniversary Notes
The second book inside the first, and the reason to buy the 1999 edition.
Starhawk, at forty and again at fifty, went through her own book chapter by chapter and wrote what she now thought. On the history: that she had repeated claims she could not support, that the nine million figure was wrong, that the matriarchy was contested, and that the religion's value did not rest on them. On gender: that the 1979 text had assumed a polarity of feminine and masculine energies that she no longer held, that Reclaiming had come to include people of every gender and orientation without the polarity, and that the language of the rituals had been revised accordingly. On practice: how the exercises had been refined, which rituals had changed and why, what she had learned from twenty years of teaching. On politics: how the activism had developed and where it had failed.
The notes are candid, unsentimental and often funny, and they are a model of how an author can revise a foundational text without disowning it. No other Pagan founder has done anything like it.
Reclaiming and After
What the book built.
The Reclaiming collective, founded in 1980, grew from classes based on the book into a tradition with communities across North America and Europe, a Witchcamp programme of week-long intensives, a set of principles of unity, and a distinctive style combining ecstatic ritual, feminist process and direct action. Its later development, including the dissolution of the original collective into a wider structure, is described in the 1999 notes. The book's exercises are still Reclaiming's core curriculum, and the tradition is the fullest realisation of what the book proposed.
The Prose
Warm, direct, lyrical in the invocations and plain in the instructions. Starhawk writes as a teacher speaking to a class, and the tone is encouraging without being saccharine. The theological chapters have a rhythm that comes from spoken ritual; the practical ones are clear enough to follow without a teacher. The 1979 text has the confidence of a young writer who has found her subject, and the notes have the humour of the same writer twenty years on.
The Objections
Three, and the author has made the first herself.
The history is false. The Paleolithic Goddess, the matriarchy, the Burning Times and the survival are unsupported, and the 1979 text presents them as fact.
The gender polarity is essentialist. The original text assumes feminine and masculine energies with fixed characters, which later readers and Starhawk herself have rejected.
The secrets were not hers to publish. The Faery tradition's material was oath-bound, and some of its keepers regard the book as a breach.
Who Should Read It
Read it if you are drawn to Goddess religion or Wicca and want the book that most practitioners learned from.
Read it for the exercises if you practise in any tradition and want a grounding in energy work that is clear and safe.
Read the 1999 edition, and read the notes after each chapter, so that you get the book and its author's correction together.
Read it with Adler for the context and with Hutton for the history, and take the first chapter as myth.
The book's deepest claim is that the sacred does not need to be somewhere else. Starhawk's Goddess is the body you are sitting in, the ground under the chair, the season outside the window, and the circle of people you would form if you called them. Everything in the practice follows from taking that literally: you ground because the earth is holy, you raise energy because it is already moving through you, you cast a circle not to keep the profane out but to notice that nothing was ever profane. The history she wrapped this in was wrong and she said so. The claim itself has no history to be wrong about. It is either true when you try it or it is not, and the book's exercises are the invitation to find out.
Goddess religion as theology, practice and politics, from the priestess who wrote it down, with her own twenty years of corrections.
Affiliate disclosure: Thalira earns a small commission on purchases made through the link above, at no additional cost to you. Our account of the book's false history and the author's own corrections is given above and was not softened for the link.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is The Spiral Dance about?
Witchcraft as a religion of the Goddess: its theology of a divine immanent in nature and the body, its history as Starhawk understood it in 1979, and its practice, with exercises, rituals, spells and a coven structure laid out for readers to use. It is both an argument and a manual.
Who is Starhawk?
Miriam Simos, born 1951 in St Paul, Minnesota, raised Jewish, who found witchcraft in California in the late 1960s, trained in the Faery tradition under Victor and Cora Anderson, co-founded the Reclaiming collective in San Francisco in 1980, and became the most influential writer and activist in Goddess religion and Pagan ecofeminism.
What does the title mean?
The spiral dance is a group ritual in which participants hold hands in a line that winds inward and then turns to wind out again, so that each person passes face to face with every other. Starhawk uses it as the image of a religion of connection and return rather than of ascent.
What is the theology?
Immanence: the Goddess is not a being outside the world but the world itself, alive and sacred, present in every body, tree and stone. The God is her consort and child, the dying and returning one of the seasons. Magic is the art of changing consciousness at will, and the coven is the community in which the divine is met.
Is it a practical book?
Yes. Most of the chapters end with exercises, in breathing, grounding, visualisation, energy sensing and trance, and there are full rituals for the sabbats, the moon, initiation and the cone of power, with instructions for casting the circle and invoking the quarters. Generations of practitioners learned from it.
What are the later editions?
The tenth-anniversary edition of 1989 and the twentieth of 1999 add long introductions and chapter-by-chapter notes in which Starhawk revisits her claims, corrects the history, reconsiders the gender essentialism, and reports how her practice and politics changed. The notes are a second book and the 1999 edition is the one to read.
What did she get wrong?
The history: the 1979 text presents witchcraft as the survival of a Paleolithic Goddess religion suppressed by patriarchy and the Burning Times, with a figure of nine million dead. Starhawk's later notes concede that the survival story is unsupported, the numbers inflated, and the ancient matriarchy contested.
What is the Faery tradition?
An American witchcraft lineage founded by Victor Anderson, drawing on Hawaiian, Appalachian and other sources, which stresses ecstatic trance, the three souls and a poetic rather than ceremonial style. Starhawk was initiated into it and much of the book's practice comes from it, adapted.
What is Reclaiming?
The tradition and collective Starhawk co-founded in San Francisco in 1980, combining Goddess religion with feminist process, non-hierarchical structure and political activism. The book was written just before its founding and became its foundational text; Reclaiming's later development is described in the 1999 notes.
How does it compare to Drawing Down the Moon?
Both appeared in 1979. Adler surveyed the whole Pagan movement as a reporter; Starhawk taught one path from inside as a priestess. Adler tells you what Paganism is; Starhawk tells you how to do it. They are read together as the founding pair.
Is it only for women?
No. The book was written for mixed covens and includes the God; Starhawk's own tradition has always included men. The feminist framing led some readers to assume otherwise, and the later notes address the question of gender directly and revise some of the original essentialism.
Who should read it?
Anyone drawn to Goddess religion who wants its founding text, practitioners who want the exercises that shaped modern Pagan practice, students of religion who want to see a tradition being written into existence, and readers of ecofeminism who want its spiritual source.
Ground once, and mean it
The first exercise in the book is the tree of life: sit, breathe, and imagine roots going down from the base of your spine into the earth, drawing its energy up, and branches going out from your crown into the sky, drawing that down, until the two meet in you. Starhawk's claim is that this is not a metaphor. The earth is the Goddess and you are standing on her. Do it once, for five minutes, before deciding whether the theology is true, because the theology was written by someone who had done it a thousand times and found that the question answered itself somewhere around the roots.
Sources & References
- Starhawk. The Spiral Dance: A Rebirth of the Ancient Religion of the Great Goddess, 20th anniversary ed., HarperSanFrancisco, 1999.
- Starhawk. Dreaming the Dark: Magic, Sex and Politics, 1982.
- Adler, Margot. Drawing Down the Moon, rev. ed., 2006, for the movement context.
- Hutton, Ronald. The Triumph of the Moon, 1999, for the history.
- Salomonsen, Jone. Enchanted Feminism: The Reclaiming Witches of San Francisco, 2002, for the ethnography of the tradition.
- Anderson, Victor. Thorns of the Blood Rose, for the Faery source.