Book Reviews

Of Water and the Spirit by Malidoma Patrice Somé: An Honest Review

Last Updated: November 2026. Expanded the initiation chapters and the question of how to read them.

Quick Answer

A boy is taken from his village at four by a Jesuit, raised for fifteen years in a seminary where his language is beaten out of him, walks home at twenty, and is told by the elders that he is a stranger who must be initiated or lost. The month in the bush that follows, with its tree that becomes a woman, its night buried in the earth and its passage through a door of light, is the centre of the book and the reason it has been read by a generation looking for what the West stopped doing. Somé presents it as what happened. Read it as testimony from inside a tradition, weigh it accordingly, and you will find the most direct account of initiation in modern memoir and an argument about elders and ritual that has only grown more pointed.

Key Takeaways

  • The grandfather: the first teacher, and the prophecy that frames the book.
  • The seminary: fifteen years of erasure, and the walk home.
  • The stranger: a man who returns and cannot speak.
  • The initiation: the tree, the cave, the light.
  • The task: to carry the village's medicine to a West without elders.

17 min read

What This Book Is

Of Water and the Spirit: Ritual, Magic, and Initiation in the Life of an African Shaman was published by Tarcher/Putnam in 1994 and by Penguin Arkana in paperback. It is around three hundred and twenty pages in three parts: Slowly Becoming, on childhood and the grandfather; Ancestors of the Stranger, on the mission, the seminary and the return; and Initiation, on the month in the bush and its aftermath. The subtitle's word shaman is the publisher's, not the Dagara term, and Somé addresses the mismatch in the text.

The book is a memoir. It is not ethnography, though it contains a great deal about Dagara life, and it is not a teaching manual, though the later books drew their teaching from it. It is one man's account of losing his people and being given them back, written for Western readers whom his elders had sent him to address, and it should be read with all three facts in mind.

The name. Malidoma, in Dagara, means be friends with the stranger or the enemy. It was given at birth after divination, as a statement of the child's task, and the book is the story of how the task unfolded: the strangers took him, he became one, and he was sent back to them as a friend. Somé never treated the name as coincidence.

Who Malidoma Somé Was

Malidoma Patrice Somé was born in 1956 in Dano, in the Dagara region of what was then the French colony of Upper Volta, and died in 2021 in California. After the events the book describes, he took a degree at the national university in Ouagadougou, then a doctorate in political science at the Sorbonne and another in literature at Brandeis, and from the late 1980s he lived in the United States, teaching ritual, grief work, the role of elders and the Dagara cosmology to Western audiences. With his then wife Sobonfu Somé he led workshops for two decades; he wrote Ritual: Power, Healing and Community in 1993 and The Healing Wisdom of Africa in 1998.

He held, by his own account, two full identities, initiated Dagara elder and Western academic, and the book is the account of how the first was recovered after the second had been imposed.

The Dagara World

The setting, sketched from the book's first part.

The Dagara are farmers of southwestern Burkina Faso and northern Ghana, living in compounds of extended families, growing millet and yams, organised by clans and governed by elders and diviners. Their religion, as Somé describes it, centres on the ancestors, who are consulted and fed and who intervene in the living; on the earth, which has its shrines and its guardians; on the spirits of the bush, the kontomblé, small beings who live in the wild places and who can teach or harm; and on the five elements of the Dagara cosmology, fire, water, earth, mineral and nature, each with its year in a five-year cycle and its character in a person. Divination, healing and ritual are the daily work of maintaining the relationships among all of these.

Somé writes of this world from inside, as the child who lived in it before the mission, and the first part of the book is the fullest account of Dagara village life in English.

Bakhye

The book's first teacher and its moral centre.

Bakhye, Somé's paternal grandfather, is a healer and elder, old and blind, who keeps the boy near him in the years before the mission and speaks to him of the ancestors, the spirits and the world beyond the village. He tells him stories of the family's past, of the coming of the white men and their strange religion, and of the boy's own task, which he has divined: to go among the strangers and return. He teaches by riddles and by presence, and the chapters about him are the book's tenderest.

His death, when the boy is four, opens the narrative, and his instruction that the boy is to be taken care of by the ancestors after he is gone is the promise the rest of the book fulfils.

The Funeral

The first great ritual described, and a model for what follows.

Somé describes his grandfather's funeral in detail: the days of wailing and drumming, the body displayed, the mourners driven into grief by the musicians and pulled back by the ritual keepers, the diviner who speaks with the dead man to learn what he needs, the burial. He reads the funeral as a technology of grief, in which the community is made to feel the loss fully and then released from it, and he contrasts it with what he later saw in the West, where the dead are hurried away and the grief goes nowhere. The chapter is where his later work on grief ritual begins, and it is the book's first argument.

The Abduction

The break.

Father Maillot, a French Jesuit who had befriended Somé's father, a convert, arrives at the compound and takes the boy away in his truck, with the father's consent and against the mother's, to be educated at the mission. Somé remembers it as a kidnapping and describes it as one: the truck, the dust, the mother running behind. He was four. He would not see the village again for fifteen years.

The chapter is brief and its restraint is its force. Somé does not editorialise about colonialism; he describes a child being driven away, and lets the reader supply the rest.

The Seminary

The second part, and the book's darkest.

The mission school and then the seminary at Nansi were run by French priests for the purpose of producing African clergy, and the method was erasure. Dagara was forbidden and beaten; French and Latin were imposed; the ancestors were demons; the village was savagery. Somé describes the beatings, the loneliness, the loss of his language, and the slow success of the project: by his late teens he was a seminarian who thought in French, knew Aquinas and had forgotten his grandfather's face. He also describes what the seminary gave him, a European education that he later used, and he does not pretend the gift was nothing.

The section's climax is an encounter with a priest who made a sexual approach; Somé struck him, and knew that he could not stay.

The Escape and the Walk

At twenty, Somé left the seminary on foot and walked home, more than a hundred miles across the savanna, sleeping in the bush, arriving at a village whose name he knew and whose language he had lost. The chapter is short and it reads like a passage in an epic: the young man returning from the land of the dead to a home that does not recognise him.

The Stranger at Home

The book's hinge.

The village received him with joy and then with unease. He could not speak Dagara beyond a child's words. He did not know the greetings, the customs, the names of the spirits. He had been among the white men for fifteen years and, in the village's eyes, had become one, and the term the elders used for him was the stranger. His father, who had given him away, was ashamed. His mother wept. Somé himself, in the account, was torn between a home he had longed for and a self that no longer fitted it.

The chapters on this period are the book's most honest. Somé does not present his return as a homecoming; he presents it as a second exile, in which he was foreign in the only place he belonged.

The Elders' Decision

The council, and the risk.

The elders met to decide what to do with him. Initiation, the passage that made Dagara boys into men, was normally undergone at thirteen or so; Somé was twenty and had lived among the whites. Some elders held that he was too old and too damaged, that the bush would kill him, that the ancestors would not accept a man who had been baptised. Others held that without initiation he would remain a stranger forever and that the risk was worth it. His grandfather's prophecy was recalled. The decision was made to send him, with the year's group of boys, and with the understanding that he might not return.

The Tree

The first trial, and the book's most famous passage.

The initiates are taken into the bush, and Somé's first task is to sit before a tree and look at it until he sees. For two days he sees a tree, and grows angry, and is told by the elders to keep looking. On the third day the tree begins to change, and he sees a green woman, luminous, of great beauty and tenderness, who embraces him and whom he understands to be the tree's true form or the spirit that the tree is. He weeps for hours. The elders tell him he has seen what the others saw, and that the tree was never only a tree.

The passage has been read as a mystical vision, as an account of the dissolution of a Western perceptual habit, and as a description of what the Dagara mean when they say the world is alive. Somé presents it as what happened, and he says that his Western training made it harder and longer for him than for the boys.

The Cave

The second trial.

Somé is buried alive in a shallow cave, with only his head free, for a night, as a ritual death. He describes the terror, the cold, the sense of the earth pressing, and then a shift: a visit from the ancestors, from his grandfather, and from beings he calls kontomblé, small and luminous, who speak with him and give him something he does not fully describe. In the morning he is dug out and the elders treat him as a man who has died and returned. The chapter connects to the funeral that opened the book, and Somé's reading is that initiation is a funeral for the child undergone by the living.

The Door of Light

The final trial and the book's climax.

The initiates are brought to a place in the bush where, Somé says, the elders opened a portal of light in the earth, and each young man was sent through it into another world. He describes what he saw there in terms he says are inadequate: a place of light and colour and beings, a knowledge that he was given and could not carry back in words, and a return through the portal to the ordinary bush, changed. One of the boys did not return, and Somé records the elders' grief and their acceptance. He was told that what he had seen was his, that some of it could be told and some could not, and that he was now a Dagara man.

The chapter is the one on which the book's reception has turned, and how to read it is the subject of a later section here.

The book's structure is a single ritual, and the funeral at the beginning is the key. The Dagara bury the dead with a grief so complete that the mourners nearly die of it and are pulled back by the community. Initiation, in Somé's account, does the same to the child: the tree undoes what he thinks he sees, the cave buries him, the portal takes him out of the world, and the elders receive back someone who has died. What was buried in the cave was the seminary boy, and what walked out was a Dagara man with a European education, able to be friends with the stranger because he had been one. The book is the account of that funeral, and everything else in it is preparation or consequence.

The Return and the Task

The aftermath.

Somé returned to the village as an initiated man, learned again to speak, took his place, and was then told by the elders that his task was not to stay. He had been made a friend of the stranger so that he could go to the strangers and give them what they lacked: the knowledge of ritual, of elders, of the ancestors and of initiation, which the elders had divined the West was dying without. He was sent to school, to the university, to Paris, to America, and the book ends with him in the West, carrying the medicine, and unsure whether it can be received.

How to Read the Initiation

The question every reader faces, addressed directly.

The book describes events, a tree becoming a woman, a night with the ancestors, a passage through a door of light, that no outside reader can verify and that Somé says happened. There are three ways to hold this. One is to accept the account literally, as Somé's Western students largely did. One is to dismiss it, as some reviewers did, and to lose the book. The third, and the one this review recommends, is to read it as testimony from within a tradition: an initiated man's account of what initiation was, told in the only terms his tradition and his experience gave him, and offered to readers whose own terms are different. On this reading the question is not whether the tree was literally a woman but what it means that a tradition trains its young men to see it so, and what such a training does to a person.

Somé himself invited this reading. He says repeatedly that the elders warned him some things could not be translated, that his Western mind resisted, and that he has done his best. He did not claim the book was ethnography, and readers who treat it as such, in either direction, misread it.

The Argument About the West

The book's second subject, and the reason it was written.

Somé's elders sent him to the West because they had divined that it was in trouble, and the book's later pages and his later work set out the diagnosis. The West has no initiation, so its young men do not become men and remain restless and dangerous into middle age. It has no elders, only old people, so its knowledge is not transmitted and its old are discarded. It has no living relation to the ancestors, so its dead are unquiet and its living are unmoored. It has no grief ritual, so its losses accumulate unmourned. And it has no ritual in the full sense, only ceremony, so its communities do not cohere.

The diagnosis has been enormously influential in men's work, in the grief and ritual movements, and in the broad turn toward indigenous wisdom, and it is stated in this book with the authority of a man who had lived both sides.

The Later Books and the Teaching

Ritual: Power, Healing and Community, 1993, is a short essay on why ritual is necessary and how the West might recover it. The Healing Wisdom of Africa, 1998, sets out the Dagara cosmology, the five elements and their years, the role of the shrine and the elder, in a form Western readers can use, and it is the book to read for the teaching. Sobonfu Somé's The Spirit of Intimacy covers Dagara approaches to relationship. The workshops, which ran for twenty years and reached many thousands, translated the book's initiation into forms of grief ritual and community work that continue after Somé's death. Of Water and the Spirit is the life behind all of it.

The Prose

Direct, concrete and paced like a story told aloud. Somé wrote in English, his fourth language after Dagara, French and Latin, and the prose has the slight formality of a careful non-native speaker together with a storyteller's sense of when to slow down. The initiation chapters are written with an immediacy that has made them, whatever one concludes about their content, among the most gripping accounts of a spiritual vision in recent memoir. There is little analysis and no jargon.

The Objections

Four, and they should be weighed.

The initiation cannot be assessed. The central events are unverifiable and are presented without acknowledgment that a reader might need to hold them differently.

The village is idealised. The Dagara world is presented as whole and the mission as pure destruction, and the truth of both was more mixed.

The teaching role shapes the telling. Somé wrote for Western students, and the book gives them what they came for.

Some Dagara have demurred. Aspects of the account, including the portal, have been questioned by others from the tradition, and Somé's authority to represent the Dagara was not universal.

Who Should Read It

Read it if you are interested in initiation and want a first-person account rather than a theory.

Read it if you are drawn to African traditional religion and want it from someone raised inside it rather than described from outside.

Read it if you have felt the absence of elders, ritual or a place to put your grief, and want the argument for why that absence matters, from a man who was sent to make it.

Read it with the objections in mind, and read The Healing Wisdom of Africa after it for the teaching that the memoir grounds.

The book's lasting idea is that a person can be taken from their people and given back, and that the giving back is a death. Somé lost his language, his grandfather's face and the names of the spirits, and no amount of walking home restored them. What restored them was being buried, being made to look at a tree until it broke his way of looking, and being sent through a door he could not describe, under the care of old men who had done it themselves and knew that he might not survive. The West, he argues, has no such door and no such old men, and its lost children stay lost. Whether or not one accepts the portal, the diagnosis is hard to refuse, and the book's refusal to soften either the loss or the cure is why it has been read by people who have never seen a Dagara village and recognised themselves.

A Dagara boy taken by the mission, a man who walked home, and the initiation that gave him back his people and sent him to ours.

Of Water and the Spirit on Amazon

Affiliate disclosure: Thalira earns a small commission on purchases made through the link above, at no additional cost to you. Our account of how to weigh the initiation chapters and of the objections to the book is given above and was not softened for the link.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Of Water and the Spirit about?

The author's life from his early childhood in a Dagara village in Upper Volta, now Burkina Faso, through his abduction at four by a Jesuit priest and fifteen years in mission schools and seminary, his escape and return to a village where he no longer spoke the language, and the month-long initiation in the bush that restored him to his people.

Who was Malidoma Somé?

A Dagara elder, teacher and writer, 1956 to 2021, initiated in his tradition and holding doctorates from the Sorbonne and Brandeis, who spent three decades in the West teaching ritual, grief work and the role of elders. His name, Malidoma, means be friends with the stranger or enemy, and was given him at birth as a task.

What happened at the mission?

Somé was taken from his family by Father Maillot, a French Jesuit who had befriended his father, and raised in a seminary where Dagara language and religion were forbidden and beaten out of the boys. At twenty, after striking a priest who had sexually approached him, he walked more than a hundred miles home.

What is the initiation described?

A month in the bush with other young men under the elders, involving days of staring at a tree until it showed itself as a green woman, burial alive in a cave overnight, a passage through a light-portal in the earth, and encounters with beings the tradition calls kontomblé. Somé was older than the others and had missed the usual age.

Is the book literally true?

Somé presents it as memoir and says the events happened as described. He also says the elders warned that some of what he saw could not be told in Western terms and that he has translated as best he can. Readers should hold it as testimony from within a tradition, not as ethnography, and Somé did not claim otherwise.

What is the grandfather's role?

Bakhye, Somé's grandfather, is the book's first teacher: a healer and elder who speaks to the boy of the ancestors, the spirits and the coming of the white man, and whose death and funeral open the book. His prophecy that the boy will go among the strangers and return shapes the whole narrative.

What does it say about the West?

That the West suffers from the absence of initiation, elders, ritual and a living relation to the ancestors, and that its restlessness and loneliness come from this. Somé was sent by his elders to teach these things to Westerners, and the book is partly the account of why.

What are the Dagara?

A people of southwestern Burkina Faso and northern Ghana, farmers of millet and yams, organised by clans with elders and diviners, whose religion centres on ancestors, earth shrines and the spirits of the bush. Somé's village, Dano, is in the Dagara heartland.

What are the objections?

That the initiation passages describe events no outside reader can assess, that the book idealises the village against the mission, that Somé's Western teaching role shapes what he chose to tell, and that some Dagara have questioned aspects of his account. All are fair; none removes the book's value as testimony.

How does it compare to Ritual and The Healing Wisdom of Africa?

Ritual, 1993, is a short essay on why the West needs ritual; The Healing Wisdom of Africa, 1998, is a fuller account of Dagara cosmology and practice for Western readers. Of Water and the Spirit is the life those two books draw on, and it should be read first.

Is it well written?

Yes. It is direct, vivid and unornamented, with a storyteller's pacing, and the initiation chapters are among the most compelling accounts of spiritual vision in recent memoir. Somé wrote in English, his fourth language after Dagara, French and Latin.

Who should read it?

Anyone interested in initiation and rites of passage, readers drawn to African traditional religion who want a first-person account, anyone who has felt the absence of elders and ritual in modern life, and anyone who has been taken from a home and had to find the way back.

Find the funeral you never held

Somé's grandfather was buried with a grief so complete the mourners had to be held back from following him. Most of us have buried people, and selves, with nothing of the kind, and the book's practical claim is that the unmourned do not leave. Name one loss, a person, a place, a version of yourself that the seminary of your own life beat out, that was never given its funeral. You do not need the Dagara drums. You need, Somé would say, a community to witness and a form that lets the grief go all the way down, and if you have neither, then knowing what is missing is the beginning of building it. The book was written so that its readers would start.

Sources & References

  • Somé, Malidoma Patrice. Of Water and the Spirit: Ritual, Magic, and Initiation in the Life of an African Shaman, Tarcher/Putnam, 1994; Penguin Arkana, 1995.
  • Somé, Malidoma Patrice. Ritual: Power, Healing and Community, 1993.
  • Somé, Malidoma Patrice. The Healing Wisdom of Africa, 1998.
  • Somé, Sobonfu. The Spirit of Intimacy, 1997.
  • Goody, Jack. Death, Property and the Ancestors, 1962, for the LoDagaa funeral ethnography.
  • van Gennep, Arnold. The Rites of Passage, 1909, for the theory of initiation.
Back to all book reviews

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.