Book Reviews

Mama Lola: A Vodou Priestess in Brooklyn by Karen McCarthy Brown: An Honest Review

Last Updated: November 2026. Expanded the treatment of the spirit chapters and the initiation debate.

Quick Answer

The book that replaced the zombie and the doll with a woman in a Brooklyn kitchen feeding her spirits. An anthropologist spent twelve years with a Haitian manbo named Alourdes, and wrote a book that alternates the story of her ancestors, told as fiction because the documents do not exist, with chapters on the spirits she serves, Azaka the farmer, Ogou the soldier, the two Ezilis, Gede who jokes about death, each shown at work in the family's history and in the crowded flat where they are called down. The author was initiated before she finished, and says so. The result is the most read book on Vodou in English, and thirty-five years on, still the most humane.

Key Takeaways

  • Four generations of women and the spirits they served, from rural Haiti to Fort Greene.
  • Alternating chapters: ancestor stories as fiction, spirits as ethnography.
  • Vodou as relationship: feed the spirits, and they hold you.
  • Possession as the centre, described without explanation.
  • An initiated author, and the argument about whether she should have been.

17 min read

What This Book Is

Mama Lola: A Vodou Priestess in Brooklyn was published by the University of California Press in 1991 in its Comparative Studies in Religion and Society series, and in an updated and expanded edition in 2001, with a third edition in 2010. It is around four hundred pages in twelve chapters, with a prologue, an afterword and a glossary of Haitian Creole terms. It won the Victor Turner Prize of the Society for Humanistic Anthropology and the American Academy of Religion's award for excellence.

The book is an ethnography of one person and her household: Marie Thérèse Alourdes Macena Margaux Kowalski, known to her community as Alourdes and to her clients as Mama Lola, a Haitian immigrant who served the Vodou spirits from a row house in Fort Greene, Brooklyn. Brown met her in 1978 while surveying Vodou in New York and stayed for twelve years before publishing, and for the rest of both their lives after.

It is also an experiment in how ethnography can be written, and its form has been as influential as its content.

The spelling. Brown writes Vodou, following the Haitian Creole orthography, rather than voodoo, the American spelling that carries a century of Hollywood. The choice is deliberate and the book is in part an argument for it: that the religion has a name of its own and a life that the borrowed word obscures.

Who Karen McCarthy Brown Was

Karen McCarthy Brown was born in 1942, took her doctorate at Temple University in religion, and taught the anthropology of religion at Drew University in New Jersey from 1976 until her retirement. She first went to Haiti in 1973 to study the Vodou sacred drawings called vèvè, and in 1978, surveying Vodou among Haitian immigrants in Brooklyn for a museum project, she was sent to Alourdes as someone who knew the tradition. The relationship that followed was the work of her life. She published on Vodou, on women in religion and on ethnographic method, and she died in 2015 after a long illness.

She was, by her own account, a white Protestant-raised academic with no prior connection to Haiti, and the book is candid throughout about what that meant for what she could and could not see.

Who Alourdes Was

Alourdes was born in Port-au-Prince in the early 1930s to Philomise Macena, herself a manbo, and grew up in the city's poverty, with the spirits present in the household as a matter of course. She was married young, had children, worked as a singer with a government troupe, and in 1962 emigrated to New York, where she cleaned houses and then worked in a hospital while raising her family. The spirits, she told Brown, came for her in New York, through illness and dreams, and demanded that she take up her mother's work. She was initiated as a manbo on a return to Haiti and from the 1970s served the spirits from her home, holding ceremonies in her basement, reading cards and treating clients in her bedroom altar room, for a community that included Haitians, other Caribbean immigrants and, increasingly, curious Americans.

She was a large personality: warm, funny, quick-tempered, shrewd about money and about people, and entirely serious about the spirits. The book's success is that she is on every page.

The Alternating Structure

The form, which readers either love or find disorienting.

The twelve chapters alternate between two modes. The odd-numbered chapters are stories of Alourdes's ancestors, written in the third person as fiction: her great-grandfather Joseph Binbin Mauvant, who walked into the sea and became a spirit; her grandmother Sina, a market woman; her mother Philomise, who became a manbo after the spirits made her sick. Brown reconstructed these from what Alourdes and her family told her, and she labels them as fiction because no documents exist and because, she argues, the family's own way of telling the past is through story rather than record. The even-numbered chapters are ethnography in the first person: each takes one of the spirits Alourdes serves and describes how that spirit appears in ceremony, what it demands, whom it protects, and how it has figured in the family's life.

The alternation is the book's argument in form. The spirits and the ancestors are the same story told twice, and a reader who follows both strands sees how a family's history becomes a pantheon.

Vodou as Brown Presents It

The religion, as the book understands it.

Vodou, in Brown's account, is a religion of relationship with the lwa, the spirits, who are served through offerings of food, drink and song, who come down in possession to speak with the community, and who in return advise, heal, warn and protect. The spirits are not gods to be worshipped from a distance but family members to be fed and argued with, and the relationship is reciprocal and often difficult. Brown reads the religion as a practical theology of survival, shaped by the experience of slavery, revolution, poverty and migration, in which the spirits embody the moral dilemmas of the people who serve them: how to be a soldier and not a tyrant, how to be a mother in a world that takes children, how to laugh at death.

She treats the Catholic surface, the saints' images on the altar and the Masses that precede ceremonies, as part of the religion rather than as disguise, and the West African roots, the Fon and Kongo spirits behind the lwa, as history that lives in the present without needing to be recovered.

The Ancestor Chapters

The fictional strand, and its best moments.

Joseph Binbin Mauvant, in the first story, is an old man in the countryside near Port-au-Prince who one day walks into the sea and does not return, and whose family understands that he has gone to Africa, to Ginen, the ancestral home beneath the water. The story establishes the book's spiritual geography and its refusal of a line between the living and the spirits. Later stories follow the women: Sina's market trade, Philomise's illness and calling, Alourdes's own early life. They are written plainly, in a style that owes something to Haitian oral narrative, and they carry the reader across a century of Haitian history without a single date.

Critics have argued that fictionalising the ancestors compromises the ethnography. Brown's reply, in the prologue, is that the alternative was to present guesses as facts, and that the family's own history was already story.

Azaka

The first spirit chapter, and the gentlest.

Azaka, or Kouzen Zaka, is the peasant farmer, dressed in blue denim and a straw hat, carrying a straw bag, shy and suspicious of city people, fond of simple food. Brown shows him coming down at a ceremony in Alourdes's basement and haggling over the price of his offerings, and reads him as the family's memory of the countryside they left and of the rural poverty that Haitian city dwellers both flee and long for. The chapter introduces the way the spirits carry class, region and history in their manners, and it sets the pattern for those that follow.

Ogou

The soldier, and the book's most complex portrait.

Ogou is the spirit of iron, war and politics, descended from the Yoruba Ogun, and he comes in many forms: the general, the guerrilla, the wounded veteran, the drunk. He is the spirit of Haiti's revolution and of its dictators, and Brown reads him as the embodiment of a moral problem the Haitian people have lived inside for two centuries: that the power needed to be free is the power that becomes tyranny. In Alourdes's household he is her protector and her difficult father, and the chapter follows him through the family's dealings with men, with violence, and with the Duvalier regime that many of them fled.

The chapter is where the book's method shows most clearly what it can do. A spirit's character becomes a history and a psychology at once, and neither reduces the other.

Kouzinn

Azaka's wife, the market woman, and a short chapter on trade.

Kouzinn is the spirit of the Haitian market women who carry the country's economy on their heads, and Brown uses her to describe the world of commerce that Alourdes's grandmother lived in and that Alourdes herself, with her fees and her shrewdness, has never left. The chapter is about money in Vodou, which the religion does not pretend to be above, and about the women's economy that sustains both the market and the temple.

Ezili Dantò and Ezili Freda

The two women, and the chapters most read.

Ezili Dantò is the dark-skinned mother, fierce, hardworking, scarred on the cheek, who protects her children absolutely and does not speak, only grunts, because in one story her tongue was cut out during the revolution so that she could not betray the rebels. Ezili Freda is the light-skinned mistress, perfumed, jewelled, weeping, who demands luxury and is never satisfied. Brown reads the two as the split image of the feminine that Haitian women, and Haitian men, carry: the mother who endures and the woman who is desired, neither of whom is allowed to be whole. She shows both at work in Alourdes's life, in her marriages and losses and in her care of her own daughter Maggie, and she is honest about which one she herself, as a white American woman, was first drawn to and how that changed.

The chapters have been used in women's studies for thirty years and they are the book's emotional centre.

Gede

The trickster of death and sex, and the funniest chapter.

Gede, or Papa Gede, wears a top hat and dark glasses with one lens missing, smokes cigars, drinks rum steeped in hot peppers, talks obscenely and dances the banda with his pelvis, and he is the spirit of the dead, the graveyard and the joke that death is. He comes at the end of ceremonies and mocks everyone present, including the anthropologist, and Brown records the mockery. She reads him as the religion's refusal to be solemn about mortality, and as the guardian of children, since the dead and the unborn are neighbours. The chapter is a corrective to every account of Vodou as morbid: the spirit of death, it turns out, is the one who makes the room laugh.

Danbala

The serpent, and the oldest spirit.

Danbala Wedo, the white serpent, and his wife Ayida Wedo, the rainbow, are the ancient spirits of Dahomey, of water, of continuity and of the ancestors, and when Danbala comes he does not speak but hisses and moves on the ground like a snake, and is fed eggs and white things. Brown treats him as the spirit of the connection to Africa and to the deep past, and the chapter is quieter than the others, since Danbala's presence is a matter of stillness rather than drama. It closes the circle that Joseph Binbin Mauvant's walk into the sea opened.

Possession

The centre of the religion, and Brown's handling of it.

The spirits come down by riding a devotee, most often Alourdes herself, whose personality departs and is replaced by the spirit's: Ogou's stance, Gede's voice, Ezili Dantò's grunts. The community then speaks with the spirit directly, asks for advice, receives rebukes, is told things. Brown describes many possessions in detail, from the first signs to the spirit's departure and Alourdes's exhaustion afterward, and she is explicit about her method: she does not explain possession as dissociation or performance, since neither does justice to what she observed, and she does not claim that a spirit is literally present, since she cannot know. She records what happens and what it does for the people in the room, and she lets the reader decide. The restraint has been much praised and it is why believers and sceptics both use the book.

The book's central discovery is that a family's pantheon is its history. Azaka is the countryside they left; Ogou is the men and the politics that both saved and broke them; the two Ezilis are the women they were made into; Gede is how they survived the deaths; Danbala is the Africa under the water. Alourdes did not choose these spirits. They came for her because they were already hers, carried down four generations of women who had served them and been served, and the alternating chapters show the carrying. Vodou, on this reading, is not a system of belief but a way of keeping the family together across a century and an ocean, with the dead included.

Healing and the Work

What Alourdes actually does.

Much of the book is about the work: the clients who come to Alourdes's altar room with illnesses, love problems, immigration troubles and enemies; the card readings, the baths, the lamps and the charms she prescribes; the ceremonies she holds for the spirits on their feast days; the trips to Haiti to fulfil obligations. Brown describes the treatments concretely and shows them as a practical craft with a theory behind it: illness and misfortune arise from broken relationships, with people or with spirits, and healing is the repair of the relationship. She also describes her own treatment, since she became Alourdes's client before she became her student, and the account of what a Vodou healing feels like from the inside is one of the book's contributions.

Brooklyn and Haiti

The two places, and the book's argument about diaspora.

Vodou in Brooklyn is not Vodou in Haiti, and Brown is careful about the differences: the ceremonies in a basement rather than a temple courtyard, the drums muffled for the neighbours, the offerings bought at the botanica rather than raised, the community scattered across boroughs and held together by telephone. She argues that the religion has adapted, as it adapted to slavery and to Catholicism, and that Alourdes's practice is not a diminished version of the Haitian one but a new form of it, in which the spirits themselves have taken on the concerns of immigrants: papers, jobs, the children who are becoming American. The chapters on Alourdes's trips home, and on the difference between her Haitian and Brooklyn selves, are among the most affecting.

The Author's Initiation

The last chapter, and the decision that divided the book's readers.

In 1981 Brown underwent the kouche, the initiation into the Vodou priesthood, under Alourdes's direction, in Haiti. The final chapter describes it: the days of seclusion, the ritual death and rebirth, the emergence as a manbo. Brown explains the decision in two ways. As method: she had reached a point where the spirits' logic could not be understood further from outside, and Alourdes had said so. And as personal: the spirits had, over years, become part of how she understood her own life, and she chose to formalise the relationship. She does not claim that the initiation gave her authority over the religion, and she continued to describe herself as a scholar who was also an initiate.

Anthropologists argued about it for years. Some held that she had crossed a line that made her account partisan. Others held that the line was always a fiction and that her candour about crossing it was more honest than the pretence of distance. The debate has moved on, and the book's practice, of an author who is present in the ethnography and says where she stands, has become common.

The Method and Its Critics

Beyond the initiation, the book's approach has drawn comment.

The single-household focus gives depth and loses breadth: a reader learns Alourdes's Vodou and not the religion's regional and doctrinal variety. The fictional chapters, however honestly labelled, blur the line between what Brown knows and what she imagines. The author's presence in the text, her feelings, her doubts, her own treatments and dreams, is either the book's honesty or its self-indulgence depending on the reader. And the warmth of the portrait raises the question of whether Alourdes, who read the manuscript and approved it, shaped it more than an ethnographer's subject usually does. Brown addresses all of this in the prologue and the afterword, and her answers are considered rather than defensive.

The Prose

Clear, warm and unhurried. The ethnographic chapters read like good reportage, with the scenes rendered in detail and the analysis kept to what the scenes support. The ancestor chapters have a different register, simpler and more oral, and the shift between them is deliberate. Brown does not lecture and rarely uses the vocabulary of her discipline; the glossary is of Creole terms, not academic ones. The book is long and the reader does not notice.

The Objections

Three.

One household is not the religion. Alourdes's practice is particular, and the book is not a guide to Vodou in general.

The fiction blurs the record. Labelled or not, the ancestor chapters put words in the mouths of people who cannot be checked.

The author is too present. Brown's initiation and her feelings occupy space that a reader might want given to the subject.

Who Should Read It

Read it if you want to understand Vodou as something people do rather than as something done to them in films.

Read it if you are drawn to the spirits of the African diaspora, the orishas and the lwa, and want to see how they are actually served in a kitchen and a basement.

Read it if you are interested in how ethnography can be written, since the book's form has been copied for thirty years.

Read it with a general study for the history and variety the book does not attempt, and with Maya Deren's Divine Horsemen for an earlier outsider's account of possession.

The book's quiet teaching is that the spirits are how a family remembers. Alourdes did not learn her religion from a book or a temple. She learned it from her mother, who learned it from hers, and each woman's life, its men and losses and migrations, became part of what the spirits are. Ogou is the soldier because the family lived through soldiers. Ezili Dantò cannot speak because someone's tongue was cut. Gede laughs because the alternative was not surviving. To serve the spirits is to carry the history forward, feed it, argue with it and let it speak through you to the next generation, and the ancestors are not behind the spirits but in them. A reader with no connection to Haiti can still ask what their own family carries that has never been named, and the book gives a way of thinking about what it would mean to name it.

Vodou from inside one Brooklyn household: the spirits, the ancestors, the healing work, and the anthropologist who stayed.

Mama Lola on Amazon

Affiliate disclosure: Thalira earns a small commission on purchases made through the link above, at no additional cost to you. Our account of the objections to the book's method and the author's initiation is given above and was not softened for the link.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Mama Lola about?

The life, family and religious practice of Marie Thérèse Alourdes Macena Margaux Kowalski, known as Alourdes or Mama Lola, a Haitian Vodou priestess living in Brooklyn, told through the spirits she serves and the four generations of women who served them before her, by an anthropologist who became her friend, her client and finally her initiate.

Who was Karen McCarthy Brown?

An American scholar of religion, 1942 to 2015, professor of the anthropology of religion at Drew University, who first went to Haiti in 1973 and met Alourdes in 1978. She worked with her for over a decade before publishing, and the book won the Victor Turner Prize for ethnographic writing.

Who was Mama Lola?

A manbo, a Vodou priestess, born in Port-au-Prince in the 1930s, who emigrated to New York in 1962, worked as a domestic and in a hospital, and served the spirits from her home in Fort Greene, Brooklyn, for a community of Haitian immigrants and others. She died in 2019.

How is the book structured?

Twelve chapters, alternating. The odd chapters are fictionalised narratives of Alourdes's ancestors, from her great-grandfather Joseph Binbin Mauvant in the Haitian countryside to her own mother Philomise, reconstructed from family stories. The even chapters are ethnographic accounts of the spirits Alourdes serves and of life in her Brooklyn home.

Which spirits does it cover?

Azaka, the peasant farmer; Ogou, the soldier; Kouzinn, the market woman; Ezili Dantò and Ezili Freda, the two faces of the feminine; Gede, the trickster of death and sex; and Danbala, the serpent. Each even chapter takes one spirit and shows how it lives in Alourdes's practice and in her family's history.

What is Vodou in the book?

A religion of relationship: the spirits, the lwa, are served through offerings, song and possession, and in return they advise, heal and protect. Brown presents it as a practical theology of survival, shaped by slavery, poverty and migration, in which the spirits embody the moral dilemmas of the people who serve them.

Did the author get initiated?

Yes. In 1981 Brown underwent the kouche, the initiation into Vodou priesthood, under Alourdes's guidance, and the book's last chapter describes it. She defended the decision as necessary to understand the religion from within and as a personal choice, and it was controversial among anthropologists.

Why the fictional chapters?

Brown argues that the family stories could not be told as documented history, since the documents do not exist, and that fictionalising them in the voice of the ancestors was more honest than presenting reconstructions as fact. The chapters are labelled as fiction and drawn from what Alourdes told her.

What is the book's view of possession?

That it is real as an experience and central to the religion: when Ogou or Gede rides Alourdes, the community speaks with the spirit directly, receives counsel and is confronted. Brown describes it without reducing it to psychology and without claiming to explain it.

Is it a reliable introduction to Vodou?

It is the best introduction to Vodou as lived by one family, and its accounts of the spirits are accurate and widely used in teaching. It is not a survey of the religion's history or its variety, and readers who want that should pair it with a general study.

What does the 2001 edition add?

A new preface and an afterword updating Alourdes's life, the death of her daughter Maggie's father and other family events, and reflecting on the book's reception and on what Brown's initiation had meant over the intervening decade.

Who should read it?

Anyone who wants to understand Vodou from inside one household rather than from outside the religion, readers of ethnography interested in its experimental forms, and anyone drawn to the spirits of the African diaspora who wants to see how they are actually served.

Name what your family serves

Alourdes's spirits were her family's history given faces and fed. The book's invitation, for a reader with no altar, is to ask what your own family has carried across its generations without naming: the soldier, the mother who could not speak, the one who laughed at the funeral, the one who walked into the sea. These are not spirits in the Vodou sense, and the book does not ask you to make them so. It asks you to notice that every family has a pantheon, that it is inherited whether or not it is acknowledged, and that the difference between Alourdes and most of us is that she knew the names and set a plate.

Sources & References

  • Brown, Karen McCarthy. Mama Lola: A Vodou Priestess in Brooklyn, University of California Press, 1991; updated ed. 2001; 3rd ed. 2010.
  • Deren, Maya. Divine Horsemen: The Living Gods of Haiti, 1953.
  • Métraux, Alfred. Voodoo in Haiti, 1959, for the classic survey.
  • Desmangles, Leslie. The Faces of the Gods: Vodou and Roman Catholicism in Haiti, 1992.
  • Michel, Claudine and Patrick Bellegarde-Smith, eds. Vodou in Haitian Life and Culture, 2006.
  • Brown, Karen McCarthy. "Writing about the Other," Chronicle of Higher Education, 1992, for the method debate.
Back to all book reviews

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.