Transformational imagery representing ego death and rebirth

Ego Death: What It Is, Why It Happens, and How to Navigate It

Updated: April 2026

Quick Answer

Ego death is the dissolution of the ordinary sense of being a separate, bounded self. It can be triggered by deep meditation, psychedelic experiences, near-death events, or sustained spiritual practice. Every major contemplative tradition describes it as a necessary stage toward genuine awakening, though it requires preparation and integration to be truly beneficial.

Last Updated: February 2026
As an Amazon Associate, Thalira earns from qualifying purchases. Book links on this page are affiliate links. Your support helps us continue producing free spiritual research.

Key Takeaways

  • Ego death is the dissolution of the constructed self-identity: the separate, bounded self disappears temporarily or permanently, leaving behind a more expansive, less defended mode of awareness.
  • Multiple pathways can trigger it: deep meditation, psychedelics (psilocybin, LSD, DMT), near-death experiences, extreme grief, sustained spiritual practice, and certain physical crises have all been documented as triggers.
  • Every major contemplative tradition describes ego dissolution as essential: from Zen's satori to Sufi fana to Christian dark night of the soul to Vedantic self-inquiry, the death of the constructed ego is universally understood as a necessary stage on the path to genuine spiritual maturity.
  • Context and integration determine whether the experience is beneficial or harmful: set, setting, preparation, and skilled support dramatically affect outcomes, which is why contemplative traditions always embedded ego dissolution practices within a comprehensive framework of preparation and guidance.
  • Ego death is not the end of a self but the death of a false identification: what emerges after genuine ego dissolution is not absence of self but a more authentic, spacious, and less defended mode of being that most describe as more fully alive than the ego-centred state they left.

What Is Ego Death?

Ego death is the dissolution of the ordinary, bounded, separate sense of self. The "ego" in this context is not the Freudian ego of psychoanalytic theory but the more colloquial sense: the constructed identity, the collection of beliefs about who I am, what roles I play, what I like and dislike, what I fear and hope for, and the continuous narrative thread that weaves these elements into the experience of being a distinct, separate individual. In ego death, this construction dissolves.

What remains when the ego dissolves varies according to the account and the tradition. In Buddhist accounts, what remains is pure awareness without a fixed location or identity, what is called no-self (anatta). In Hindu Vedantic accounts, what remains is Atman, the true self that was never the constructed ego and is identical with Brahman, universal consciousness. In Jungian psychological terms, what might remain is a more expanded identity that includes dimensions previously relegated to the unconscious. In phenomenological accounts from psychedelic research, recipients describe a dissolution of the sense of separation between self and world, leaving unified awareness without a centre.

The term "death" is significant. It is not called "ego revision" or "ego expansion" but ego death because the ordinary self genuinely does not survive the experience in its previous form. Something is lost. What is lost is real, even if it was constructed. The grief, terror, and disorientation that can accompany ego dissolution are genuine responses to a genuine loss, even when the experience is ultimately liberating.

Approaching Ego Work Carefully

If you feel drawn to explore ego dissolution through meditation, breathwork, or plant medicine, the most important first step is building a strong and stable foundation. This means: an established daily meditation practice of at least three to six months, a clear understanding of your psychological history and any areas of instability, a supportive community or at least one trusted person who understands this territory, and clear intentions about why you are seeking this experience. Ego dissolution without adequate preparation or support can be destabilising. With adequate preparation, it is one of the most potentially beneficial experiences available. The difference is almost entirely a matter of readiness and context.

Grounding crystals including Red Jasper and Smoky Quartz provide an important physical anchor during periods of intensive inner work.

What Causes Ego Death?

Ego dissolution can be triggered through multiple pathways. Understanding the different triggers helps distinguish between the contexts in which it most commonly occurs and the support most appropriate to each.

Psychedelic Compounds

Psilocybin, LSD, DMT, ayahuasca, and mescaline are among the most reliable modern triggers of ego dissolution experiences. Psychedelic research at Johns Hopkins, NYU, and Imperial College London has documented dose-dependent ego dissolution effects, with high doses of psilocybin producing complete ego dissolution (ego death) in a significant proportion of participants. The acute experience lasts hours, but the psychological and neurological changes can persist for months or years. Research consistently documents that the intensity of ego dissolution during a session correlates with the magnitude of lasting positive changes in wellbeing, meaning, and personality.

Deep Meditation and Retreat

Intensive meditation practice, particularly in the context of silent retreats of ten days or longer, can trigger ego dissolution in experienced practitioners. In Zen, the kensho experience of seeing through the illusion of the separate self is described as a natural fruit of sufficient practice with the right kind of attention and instruction. In Theravada vipassana, the insight of anatta (not-self) at the level of direct experience rather than intellectual understanding can produce profound dissolution of the sense of a fixed, separate self. These meditation-induced experiences tend to unfold more gradually and with more contextual support than psychedelic experiences, making integration somewhat more accessible.

Near-Death Experiences

Near-death experiences (NDEs), studied extensively by researchers including Kenneth Ring, Raymond Moody, and Pim van Lommel, frequently include ego dissolution as a central feature. The classic NDE trajectory involves the dissolution of the bodily identity, followed by a period of expanded, often blissful awareness, and then re-entry into ordinary consciousness with a profoundly altered sense of self. Research consistently documents that NDEs produce permanent changes in values, reduced fear of death, increased compassion, and decreased attachment to material achievement, changes consistent with the lasting effects of other forms of ego dissolution.

Extreme Emotional Events

The death of a child, spouse, or partner; the diagnosis of terminal illness; and other extreme confrontations with the fragility of the constructed self and everything it is built upon can trigger involuntary ego dissolution. These events strip away the stories, roles, and assumptions around which identity is constructed, leaving an enforced confrontation with the more fundamental question of what, if anything, remains. These involuntary forms of ego death are typically the most challenging to integrate without support, precisely because they arrive without preparation and within the context of profound grief.

What Ego Death Feels Like

The phenomenology of ego death varies significantly by trigger, context, and individual, but certain features recur across accounts from different traditions, time periods, and circumstances.

The Dissolution Phase

As the ego begins to dissolve, the ordinary referents of identity become unstable. The sense of having a specific location in space blurs. The narrative thread of personal history loses its grip. The boundary between self and world becomes permeable and then disappears. This can produce either relief or terror depending on the individual's orientation and preparation. Those who have been taught to expect and understand this experience tend toward relief; those who encounter it unprepared tend toward fear.

The Dissolution Itself

At the depth of ego death, accounts consistently describe a paradoxical quality: there is no one present, and yet awareness continues. The self has dissolved and yet the experience of dissolution is occurring. This is often described as "pure awareness without a centre," "consciousness without an object," or "the witness without a witness." Many traditions have names for this state: turiya in Sanskrit, rigpa in Tibetan Buddhism, mushin in Zen. It is characterised by vast spaciousness, complete absence of ordinary thought and narrative, and often by what Maslow called peak experience qualities: profound peace, timelessness, and a sense of having arrived at something absolutely real beneath all the constructed layers.

The Re-Entry

The return of ordinary identity after ego dissolution is rarely a simple restoration. The ego reassembles, but the experience of its dissolution has changed the person's relationship to it. What was previously taken as absolutely real, the bedrock of identity, is now known to be a construction. This can produce integration challenges as the person navigates daily life with a fundamentally different understanding of who and what they are.

Ego Death Across Traditions

The dissolution of the constructed self is among the most universally described features of the world's mystical and contemplative traditions. While the terminology, the theological interpretation, and the specific practices differ, the core phenomenon is recognisable across traditions.

Zen Buddhism: Kensho and Satori

In Zen, the practices of zazen (sitting meditation), koan work (wrestling with paradoxical questions), and shikantaza (just sitting) are all directed toward the breakthrough experience of kensho, the seeing into one's true nature that involves the direct realisation of no-self. Satori, a deeper and more stable version of kensho, represents the more thorough dissolution of the constructed self-illusion. Zen teaching is explicit that intellectual understanding of no-self is not the same as its direct realisation, and that the practice is precisely designed to create the conditions in which this direct realisation becomes possible.

Sufism: Fana

In Sufi Islam, fana (Arabic: annihilation) describes the dissolution of the nafs (the egotistic, separate self) in the divine reality. Sufi poet-mystics including Rumi, Hafiz, and Ibn Arabi wrote extensively about this dissolution as the central mystical event, using the metaphor of the wave dissolving back into the ocean, or of the lover dissolving into the beloved. Fana is distinguished from the complete end of individual existence: what follows is baqa, subsistence in God, where the individual continues as an instrument or expression of divine reality without the veil of the separate ego.

Vedanta: Atman-Brahman Recognition

In Advaita Vedanta, the path to liberation (moksha) involves the recognition that the individual self (Atman) is identical with the universal consciousness (Brahman), and that the sense of being a separate self is a fundamental misidentification (avidya, ignorance). The ego does not truly die in Vedantic terms because it was never real: what occurs is the recognition of what was always true. Practices including self-inquiry (vichara), as systematised by Ramana Maharshi in the 20th century, direct continuous attention to the question "Who am I?" until the false identification dissolves and what was always present is directly recognised.

Steiner and Anthroposophy

Rudolf Steiner's anthroposophy situates ego development and eventual ego transcendence within a comprehensive evolutionary framework. In Steiner's view, the development of the "I" (the ego) to its fullest individual expression is a necessary stage in human evolution, not something to be bypassed or prematurely dissolved. However, the developed "I" must then voluntarily offer itself up to a higher spiritual development, transforming the sentient soul, intellectual soul, and consciousness soul into the spirit-self, life-spirit, and spirit-man respectively. This is ego transcendence rather than ego destruction: the individual identity is preserved and elevated rather than eliminated. Steiner's path explicitly warns against practices that dissolve the ego before it is sufficiently developed, as these can lead to loss of the developed faculties rather than their elevation.

Regular Shadow and Self-Inquiry Practice

Rather than seeking dramatic ego dissolution, a sustainable and integrative approach involves regular, systematic self-inquiry: daily or weekly questioning of the assumptions, beliefs, and stories through which you construct your identity. Byron Katie's "The Work" (four questions applied to stressful thoughts), Ramana Maharshi's self-inquiry practice, and Steiner's prescribed exercises in "Knowledge of the Higher Worlds" all offer structured approaches to gradual ego examination. The consistent, gentle dissolution of individual ego structures over time is ultimately more stable and more deeply impactful than dramatic single events, which require equally dramatic integration effort.

The Dark Night of the Soul

The dark night of the soul is the term used by the 16th-century Spanish mystic John of the Cross to describe a specific form of spiritual crisis in which all previously satisfying spiritual experiences, consolations, and self-images are stripped away. It is a particular form of ego death that specifically targets the spiritual identity, the self-image as a good, spiritually progressing person, as a loved child of God, as someone whose practice is working.

In the dark night, prayer feels empty, spiritual practice produces nothing, God or the divine seems absent, and the previously sustaining beliefs and experiences no longer nourish. John of the Cross understood this as a necessary purification: the soul is being prepared for a deeper union than the ego-centred spiritual identity could sustain. The dark night strips away the ego's appropriation of spiritual experience, clearing the ground for genuine union.

Contemporary spiritual directors and psychologists of religion have extended this concept beyond the Christian context. The dark night describes a universal stage in the spiritual path at which the previous framework of meaning dissolves and what was sustaining the spiritual life is revealed to be insufficient for the next stage of development. This dissolution is experienced as darkness, absence, and loss. What it is preparing is a more direct, less ego-mediated encounter with whatever is most real.

Psychedelics Research and Ego Dissolution

Contemporary research at major academic institutions has investigated ego dissolution and its therapeutic potential with considerable scientific rigour. The Hopkins psilocybin studies, beginning with Griffiths and colleagues in 2006, documented that high-dose psilocybin produced mystical-type experiences (characterised by ego dissolution, unity, and sacredness) in a majority of healthy volunteers and that 14 months later, participants still rated the experience among the most meaningful of their lives. Effects on personality, particularly on the dimension of "openness to experience," were lasting and statistically significant.

Research on MDMA-assisted therapy for PTSD (Phase 3 trials by MAPS) and psilocybin for depression and addiction has consistently documented that the therapeutic benefits correlate with the degree of ego dissolution and insight experienced during the session. The proposed mechanism is consistent with what contemplative traditions have described: when the constructed identity temporarily dissolves and a more expansive perspective becomes available, longstanding patterns held in place by the ego's defences become accessible for transformation.

Ego Death vs Psychosis

The surface similarities between ego dissolution and psychotic states (dissolution of ordinary reality perception, fluid sense of self and world, altered cognition) have led to both confusion in clinical settings and unnecessary pathologisation of genuine spiritual experiences. The distinctions are significant.

Key Distinctions

  • Quality of awareness: ego dissolution typically involves expanded, spacious awareness even when disorienting; psychosis typically involves contracted, fearful, and closed awareness
  • Insight: those undergoing ego dissolution typically retain or develop insight that something unusual is happening; psychosis is characterised by loss of insight and the absolute conviction that distorted perceptions are literally real
  • Integration capacity: ego dissolution, even when challenging, typically yields lasting positive changes; psychotic episodes do not produce the same quality of integrated growth
  • Response to context: ego dissolution responds to supportive grounding intervention; acute psychosis requires psychiatric support and often medication

The psychiatrist and researcher Stanislav Grof, who developed holotropic breathwork as a non-pharmacological method for accessing non-ordinary states, developed a diagnostic framework called spiritual emergency specifically to distinguish genuine spiritual crises, including ego dissolution, from psychiatric emergencies requiring different forms of intervention.

Integrating Ego Death

Integration is the process of bringing the insights, expanded awareness, and changed self-understanding of an ego dissolution experience into stable, functional expression in ordinary life. This is where the real work of ego death occurs: not in the dramatic moment of dissolution but in the weeks and months of restructuring that follow.

Grounding After Dissolution

The first priority after significant ego dissolution is re-establishing embodied, grounded presence. The dissolution of the ordinary ego can leave a sense of floating, of being too permeable, of having insufficient boundary between self and world. Physical grounding practices are the primary tool: time barefoot in natural settings, eating substantial, grounding foods, gentle physical exercise, and working with grounding crystals. The goal is not to reconstruct the old ego but to establish a more spacious and stable foundation from which to live.

Integration Practices

Journalling about the experience as it settles over time, rather than immediately, allows the meaning to clarify without being forced. Conversation with others who have navigated similar territory provides normalisation and perspective. Formal integration therapy with a therapist experienced in spiritual emergence provides the most structured support. The process takes weeks to months for significant experiences, and attempting to rush it typically results in premature closure that leaves valuable material unintegrated.

Crystals for Grounding Through Ego Dissolution

During and after significant ego dissolution experiences, grounding crystals provide physical anchors that help maintain embodied presence and support the rebuilding of stable identity from a more expansive foundation.

  • Red Jasper: the most direct grounding crystal; hold during periods of disorientation to re-establish the felt sense of being in a body
  • Smoky Quartz: transmutes the anxiety and residual fear that can persist after ego dissolution; grounds without contracting
  • Black Obsidian: provides strong energetic boundaries during the period when the ego's usual defences are reduced; particularly useful during integration
  • Clear Quartz: amplifies clarity of awareness and supports the emergence of a clearer, expanded sense of self from the dissolution

The Grounding Crystals Set provides a complete selection for the grounding work essential to healthy ego dissolution integration.

Integration Practice After Ego Dissolution

The most effective integration practice is consistent, patient journalling over the weeks following an ego dissolution experience. Write daily, not to analyse the experience but to describe what is present today: How does the world look? How does your sense of self feel? What has changed in your relationships, your values, your sense of what matters? What is more spacious, what is more tender, what is still disorienting? This longitudinal documentation allows patterns to emerge and the lasting gifts of the experience to clarify. Most people discover, looking back over these journals months later, that the changes were more profound and more lasting than they could recognise in the immediate aftermath.

Steiner on Ego Death and Genuine Development

Rudolf Steiner offered an important caution about ego dissolution that distinguishes his path from traditions that seek the dissolution of the ego as a primary goal. In Steiner's view, the modern human being's task is not to dissolve the ego but to develop it fully as an individual spiritual being and then, from that fullness, to consciously offer it in service to a higher reality. Premature ego dissolution, achieved before the ego is sufficiently developed, produces not liberation but confusion, the loss of the very capacities that make genuine spiritual development possible. This perspective is not anti-mystical: Steiner describes the same unification with cosmic consciousness as the goal. But he insists that the path leads through the fullest development of individual consciousness, not around it. The healthy ego must die, but it must first be fully born.

The Death That Is Not an End

Ego death is the most misleadingly named event in the spiritual lexicon. What dies is not the person, not awareness, not the capacity to love, to think, to feel, or to engage with life. What dies is the conviction that you are only this: only this name, only this history, only this collection of fears and preferences and roles. The dissolution of that conviction, however it happens and however challenging the process, opens into something that most who have experienced it describe as more real, more alive, and more fully themselves than anything they knew before. The ego does not disappear. It returns, smaller and more honest, a useful servant rather than an unconscious master. That is not death. That is a profound and necessary birth.

Recommended Reading

Beyond the Brain: Birth, Death, and Transendence in Psychotherapy (Suny Series in Transpersonal & Humanistic Psychology) by Grof, Stanislav

View on Amazon

Affiliate link, your purchase supports Thalira at no extra cost.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is ego death?

Ego death is the temporary or permanent dissolution of the ordinary sense of being a separate, bounded self. The 'ego' in this context refers to the constructed identity, the collection of beliefs, roles, narratives, and self-images through which a person normally experiences themselves as a distinct individual. In ego death, this construct dissolves, producing a range of experiences from profound relief and expanded awareness (in beneficial experiences) to terror and disorientation (in challenging ones). In spiritual traditions from Zen Buddhism to Sufism to Christian mysticism to Vedanta, some form of ego death is described as a necessary stage in the path toward genuine awakening or union with the divine.

What causes ego death?

Ego death can be triggered by multiple pathways. Psychedelic compounds (particularly psilocybin, LSD, DMT, and ayahuasca) are among the most reliable modern triggers. Deep meditation, particularly in intensive retreat contexts, can produce ego dissolution in advanced practitioners. Extreme physical experiences such as near-death experiences, high fever, severe trauma, childbirth, or the onset of serious illness have been reported as triggering ego dissolution. Sustained spiritual practice over years, including specific practices in Zen, Sufi, Vedantic, and other traditions designed to expose the illusory nature of the separate self, can produce gradual or sudden ego death. Acute grief, particularly the death of a spouse or child, sometimes produces ego dissolution through the intensity of loss.

Is ego death dangerous?

Ego death in itself is not dangerous: it is a natural feature of deep spiritual experience that has been safely navigated by practitioners in many traditions for thousands of years. However, the context and support available significantly affect how the experience unfolds and integrates. Ego death without adequate preparation, supportive context, or skilled guidance can be profoundly disorienting and may trigger acute anxiety, depersonalisation, or in rare cases, contribute to psychological destabilisation in individuals with pre-existing vulnerability. The psychedelic medicine research has documented this carefully: set (mental state), setting (physical and social environment), and integration support are the key variables that determine whether an ego dissolution experience is beneficial or harmful.

What does ego death feel like?

Accounts of ego death vary considerably by context, but common features include: dissolution of the sense of having a separate self or location in space; a feeling of merging with or becoming everything; loss of the boundary between self and world; an experience of timelessness or the collapse of linear time; overwhelming love, unity, and interconnection (in beneficial experiences); terror, helplessness, and the sensation of dying (in challenging experiences); and a paradoxical quality where the one who is experiencing the dissolution is simultaneously absent (the ego has dissolved) and present (there is still awareness). Many who have experienced ego death describe it as the most significant experience of their lives, whether initially welcome or not.

How is ego death different from psychosis?

Ego dissolution and psychosis can share surface similarities (disruption of ordinary reality perception, dissolution of self-boundaries), but they differ importantly in several ways. In ego dissolution, the experience typically involves an expansion of awareness rather than a contraction; even challenging experiences are characterised by some quality of openness rather than the closed, hostile, and fragmenting quality of psychotic states. Insight is characteristic of genuine ego dissolution (the recognition of what has dissolved) while psychosis typically involves loss of insight and the inability to recognise that one's perceptions are unusual. Post-experience integration is another key difference: ego dissolution typically leaves lasting positive changes in psychological functioning and life meaning, while psychotic episodes do not produce the same quality of lasting insight and growth.

What is the spiritual significance of ego death?

In the world's contemplative traditions, ego death is not an accident or a pathology but a stage on the path toward genuine self-knowledge and spiritual maturity. In Zen Buddhism, the kensho or satori experience of no-self is described as essential for progressing beyond intellectual understanding of non-self teachings to direct realisation. In Sufi tradition, the dissolution of nafs (the egotistic self) in fana (annihilation) is described as the threshold to baqa (subsistence in the divine). In Christian mysticism, the dark night of the soul described by John of the Cross involves the dissolution of the self-image and the surrender of all personal will to God. In Vedanta, the recognition of the ego as a false identification and the abiding in Atman-Brahman awareness is the central liberating insight. All these traditions understand the ego's dissolution not as loss but as the removal of an obstacle to a more authentic and expansive mode of being.

How do you integrate ego death?

Integration after ego death involves bringing the insights and expanded awareness of the experience into stable, functional expression in ordinary life. This typically takes weeks to months and benefits from: dedicated reflection time through journalling, contemplation, and conversation with trusted others; grounding practices that re-establish embodied presence (walking in nature, gentle yoga, somatic work); gradual rather than forced return to ordinary responsibilities; avoiding rush to interpret or systematise the experience before it has settled; seeking community with others who have navigated similar territory; and in psychedelic contexts, formal integration sessions with a trained therapist or guide. The most important integration principle is patience: the meaning and lasting changes of an ego dissolution experience often clarify slowly over months, not immediately.

What is the relationship between ego death and the dark night of the soul?

The dark night of the soul, described most fully by the Spanish mystic John of the Cross in the 16th century, is a spiritual crisis characterised by the stripping away of all previously satisfying spiritual consolations, the sense of divine abandonment, and the dissolution of one's existing spiritual identity and self-image. It overlaps significantly with what is called ego death in contemporary spiritual language, particularly in its emphasis on the dissolution of the constructed spiritual self (which can be as deeply identified with as any other self-image). The dark night differs from simple depression in that it tends to occur after a period of genuine spiritual progress and is characterised by a quality of depth and meaningfulness even in the suffering, as if something important is happening rather than everything simply collapsing.

Can ego death happen gradually?

Yes. Sudden, dramatic ego dissolution events are perhaps more commonly described because of their impact, but gradual ego death through sustained spiritual practice is at least as common and is specifically cultivated in most contemplative traditions. Zen's gradual school, Sufi practices of dhikr and muraqaba, Vipassana insight meditation, and Steiner's prescribed path of inner development through Knowledge of the Higher Worlds all describe progressive stages through which the grip of the ego loosens incrementally over years of practice. Each layer of identification that is seen through and released represents a partial ego death, with the total dissolution of the separate-self illusion as the culmination of the path rather than a single dramatic event at the beginning.

What crystals support grounding after ego dissolution?

After significant ego dissolution, grounding crystals help re-establish stable embodied presence and support the integration of expanded awareness into ordinary life. Red Jasper is the most direct grounding crystal, anchoring awareness in the physical body and providing the felt sense of earth-based stability. Smoky Quartz transmutes residual anxiety and fear while maintaining openness. Black Obsidian provides strong energetic boundaries during the period when the ego's usual defences are reduced. Clear Quartz amplifies clarity and supports the emergence of a more spacious sense of self. The Grounding Crystals Set provides a complete selection for this integration work.

Sources & References

  • Griffiths, R. R., Richards, W. A., McCann, U., & Jesse, R. (2006). Psilocybin can occasion mystical-type experiences having substantial and sustained personal meaning and spiritual significance. Psychopharmacology, 187(3), 268-283.
  • Carhart-Harris, R. L., Leech, R., Hellyer, P. J., Shanahan, M., Feilding, A., Tagliazucchi, E., & Nutt, D. (2014). The entropic brain: a theory of conscious states informed by neuroimaging research with psychedelic drugs. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience, 8, 20.
  • Grof, S., & Grof, C. (1989). Spiritual Emergency: When Personal Transformation Becomes a Crisis. Tarcher. (Defines and distinguishes spiritual crises from psychiatric emergencies.)
  • John of the Cross. (c. 1578/1959). Dark Night of the Soul. Doubleday. (The primary text on the spiritual crisis of ego dissolution in Christian mysticism.)
  • Steiner, R. (1904). Knowledge of the Higher Worlds and Its Attainment. Anthroposophic Press. (Describes the staged development and eventual transcendence of the ego in anthroposophical context.)
  • Stace, W. T. (1960). Mysticism and Philosophy. Macmillan. (Classic philosophical analysis of mystical experiences including ego dissolution across traditions.)
Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.