Quick Answer
Complete guide to the ancient wisdom that completes what dbt started: your threefold nature. Research-backed analysis with practical applications.
The Ancient Wisdom That Completes What DBT Started
For therapists and clients: Discover the threefold structure that explains why dialectics work and how to deepen the transformation.
In This Article
- For Therapists and Clients: The Framework That Completes DBT
- What DBT Discovered (A Clinical Breakthrough)
- The Ancient Framework That Deepens Understanding
- What Rudolf Steiner Saw: The Threefold Structure
- What Steiner Adds Beyond DBT
- How Fragmentation Actually Shows Up
- The Complete Solution: Developing All Three
- Why This Changes Everything
For Therapists and Clients: The Framework That Completes DBT
You've done the work. Learned the skills. Practiced mindfulness, distress tolerance, emotion regulation. Maybe DBT has genuinely helped you build a life worth living.
The research is solid. DBT works.
But what if there's something deeper? What if DBT discovered part of the solution, and there's an ancient framework that completes it?
DBT develops witnessing consciousness through mindfulness and cultivates Wise Mind as integration of emotion, reason, and intuition. Steiner's threefold framework (thinking, feeling, willing) explains WHY this works and offers exercises for going further.
This isn't a criticism of DBT -it genuinely works. It's an invitation to understand the deeper structure and go further.
For therapists: Discover the framework that explains WHY your dialectical interventions work.
For clients: Understand the complete structure that transforms symptoms into development.
What DBT Discovered (A Clinical Breakthrough)
Callista Forchuk's excellent article on DBT explains how Dr. Marsha Linehan made a breakthrough discovery when traditional cognitive-behavioral therapy was failing people with complex emotion dysregulation.
The innovation? Humans need to hold two seemingly opposite truths at once:
- Accept yourself exactly as you are right now
- AND work toward significant change
Not either/or. Both/and.
This is dialectical thinking. It works. People who were drowning in emotional chaos learned to build lives worth living.
And DBT goes further than just balancing poles -its Wise Mind integrates emotion, reason, AND intuition into "a place of knowing that has always been there." Linehan studied Zen Buddhism at a monastery and almost called it "Zen Therapy."
So what does Steiner's framework add?
Get Weekly Consciousness Insights
Join thousands receiving sacred wisdom, practical exercises, and exclusive content.
Subscribe FreeNo spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
The Ancient Framework That Deepens Understanding
Here's something that will blow your mind:
Every ancient wisdom tradition knew humans aren't twofold.
They're threefold.
Plato Knew It (380 BCE)
| Part | What It Does |
|---|---|
| Nous (Spirit/Mind) | Connects to eternal truth, can actually KNOW reality |
| Thymos (Soul/Courage) | Emotional passion, moral fire, heart connection |
| Epithymia (Body/Appetite) | Physical needs, material impulses, survival drives |
Three parts. Not two.
Early Christians Knew It
"May God himself sanctify you wholly, and may your whole spirit and soul and body be preserved blameless."
Paul, 1 Thessalonians 5:23
Spirit AND soul AND body. Three distinct aspects.
Then Something Catastrophic Happened
Between the 1st and 6th centuries, institutional Christianity systematically eliminated one third of human nature from consciousness.
The trichotomy (spirit, soul, body) collapsed into dichotomy (soul, body).
What was lost? The spirit. Your capacity for independent spiritual perception. Your ability to connect with divine truth directly without institutional mediation.
Why? Rudolf Steiner saw the pattern clearly:
Spiritually sovereign humans don't need permanent external authority.
They develop their own discernment. They can't be permanently controlled. They recognize manipulation when they see it.
The solution? Convince humans they don't have a spirit aspect capable of development.
The method? Collapse the trichotomy into dichotomy.
The result? Humans who don't even know they're threefold can't develop the missing third. They remain fragmented and dependent.
This wasn't theological evolution. This was systematic elimination of your spiritual sovereignty.
And it's still affecting you today, even in secular therapy.
What Rudolf Steiner Saw: The Threefold Structure
In 1894, Rudolf Steiner published The Philosophy of Freedom and restored what had been lost.
He wasn't a mystic channeling cosmic downloads. He was trained in mathematics, physics, and natural sciences. At 21, he was chosen to edit Goethe's scientific works. He brought the same rigorous observation to consciousness that scientists bring to physical phenomena.
And here's what he observed:
1. Thinking (Your Head/Nervous System)
What it does:
- Connects you to truth beyond conditioning
- Provides witnessing consciousness that can observe without being swept away
- Lets you think your OWN thoughts, not just society's programming
"To be free is to be capable of thinking one's own thoughts, not the thoughts merely of the body or of society, but thoughts generated by one's deepest, most original, most essential and spiritual self."
Rudolf Steiner
2. Feeling (Your Heart/Rhythmic System)
What it does:
- Provides emotional knowing and heart wisdom
- Connects you to beauty, love, authentic values
- Mediates between thinking and willing
This is what you feel when you KNOW something is right or wrong before you can explain why.
3. Willing (Your Limbs/Metabolic System)
What it does:
- Provides moral force to ACT on what you know
- Transforms spirit into matter through deed
- Gives you power to follow through regardless of how you feel
This is what lets you do the right thing even when every cell in your body is screaming to do something else.
The Critical Recognition
These aren't concepts ABOUT you. They're the actual structure OF you.
When thinking disconnects from feeling, when willing operates divorced from values, when feeling surges without wisdom, this is what therapy calls dysregulation.
It's not a disorder. It's fragmentation.
What Steiner Adds Beyond DBT
Look at what DBT actually engages:
Change strategies (skills training, opposite action, problem solving)
→ Primarily develop your WILLING
→ "DO something different"
Acceptance strategies (validation, mindfulness, radical acceptance)
→ Work with your FEELING
→ "Allow what is"
Mindfulness "What" Skills (Observe, Describe, Participate)
→ Develop WITNESSING CONSCIOUSNESS
→ "Step back and notice thoughts like clouds in the sky"
Wise Mind
→ Integrates emotion, reason, AND intuition
→ "A place of knowing that has always been there"
DBT genuinely develops witnessing consciousness. The Observe skill teaches exactly what Callie described: standing outside your experience and thoughts, looking at them as objective observations.
Where Steiner goes further:
- Thinking about thinking -not just observing the stream of thoughts, but actively directing and participating in the thinking process itself
- Ontological framework -a description of what the human being actually IS, not just techniques for managing experience
- Karmic depth -patterns rooted in past experiences (or lives) shaping present consciousness
- Moral imagination -the creative capacity to generate right action from within, beyond learned skills
This isn't what DBT is "missing" -it's what Steiner adds for those ready to go deeper.
DBT teaches you to observe thoughts and cultivate Wise Mind. Steiner teaches you to develop thinking itself as a faculty you can consciously direct -thinking about thinking -and to understand the spiritual structure of the being doing the thinking.
How Fragmentation Actually Shows Up
Pattern 1: When Feeling Dominates
What you experience:
- Emotions completely overwhelm you
- You can't think clearly when feelings surge
- You know what you should do but can't access that knowing when you're triggered
- Intense states that make no logical sense but feel absolutely real
What's actually happening: Your feeling faculty operates without integration with thinking (which would give you observational distance) or willing (which would give you capacity to act from values regardless of emotional state).
What DBT provides: Emotion regulation skills, distress tolerance, mindfulness (Observe skill for witnessing), Wise Mind for integration
What Steiner adds: Framework for understanding WHY this fragmentation occurs and systematic exercises for developing thinking as an active, directable faculty -not just observing thoughts but consciously participating in thinking itself
Pattern 2: When Thinking Dominates
What you experience:
- You understand everything intellectually but nothing changes
- Analysis paralysis, endless rumination
- Emotional disconnection or numbness
- Insight without transformation
What's actually happening: Your thinking operates without heart connection (feeling) or moral force (willing).
What DBT provides: Behavioral activation, opposite action, validation, Wise Mind practices connecting to intuition
What Steiner adds: Understanding thinking as SPIRITUAL faculty capable of connecting to universal ideational content -transforming intellectual knowing into living wisdom through exercises that develop thinking itself
Pattern 3: When Willing Dominates
What you experience:
- Impulsive action you regret immediately
- Compulsive behaviors disconnected from your stated values
- Doing things that betray what you consciously want
- Your body acts before your mind or heart can weigh in
What's actually happening: Your willing serves unconscious drives rather than being guided by thinking (discernment) or feeling (authentic values).
What DBT provides: Chain analysis, urge surfing, pause techniques, Wise Mind to access inner knowing before acting
What Steiner adds: Exercises for developing volitional sovereignty -the "arbitrary action" practice that trains will to serve conscious intention rather than unconscious drives, connected to moral imagination
The Complete Solution: Developing All Three
Phase 1: See Your Pattern (Month 1)
Stop trying to fix anything for 30 days. Just observe.
Daily practice: 10 minutes of honest self observation
Ask yourself:
- When I'm dysregulated, which dominates? Feeling? Thinking? Willing?
- Which are underdeveloped?
- What's my specific pattern?
No judgment. Just data collection.
After 30 days, you'll know exactly what needs development.
Phase 2: Develop Each Faculty (Months 2 to 7)
Now you work with specific practices Steiner gave in How to Know Higher Worlds.
For Thinking: One Pointed Contemplation
- Pick one simple object (a pencil, a seed, anything)
- Contemplate it for 5 minutes
- Allow ZERO stray thoughts
- Every time your mind wanders, gently return
- Do this daily for 3 to 6 months
What this builds: Your ability to actively direct thinking rather than just observing thoughts pass by.
How this complements DBT: DBT's Observe skill teaches you to watch thoughts like clouds. Steiner's contemplation practice goes further -you're not just observing, you're learning to consciously participate in and direct the thinking process. Thinking about thinking.
For Willing: The Arbitrary Action
- Pick one tiny action with NO practical purpose (touch your earlobe at 3pm, water a plant at noon)
- Do it at the EXACT same time every day
- Continue for 3 to 6 months
What this builds: Will that serves YOUR intention, not unconscious drives.
How this complements DBT: DBT's distress tolerance and urge surfing help you pause before acting. Steiner's arbitrary action practice goes further -you're developing the willing faculty itself to serve conscious intention, building volitional sovereignty.
For Feeling: Equanimity Practice
- Throughout your day, observe emotions as they arise
- Don't indulge pleasure, don't resist pain
- Feel fully without being possessed by feeling
- Maintain inner calm through all outer circumstances
What this builds: Capacity to feel without being tyrannized by feeling.
How this complements DBT: DBT's emotion regulation teaches you to modulate emotional intensity and respond skillfully. Steiner's equanimity practice goes further -you're developing the feeling faculty's own intrinsic capacity for balance, so regulation becomes natural rather than effortful.
Phase 3: Integrate All Three (Months 8 to 12)
Now you practice holding all three in conscious awareness simultaneously.
When challenges arise:
- Thinking observes: "What's actually happening here?"
- Feeling knows: "What does my heart sense?"
- Willing acts: "What serves the highest good?"
- All three together from the integrated "I AM" center
DBT's Wise Mind cultivates integration of emotion and reason with intuition. This practice extends that integration to include actively developed thinking, feeling, and willing faculties operating from conscious wholeness.
Why This Changes Everything
You're not broken.
You're not fundamentally defective.
You don't have an incurable disorder.
You have a threefold structure that's been operating in fragmentation instead of integration.
The Path Forward
This isn't quick. Steiner was explicit: consciousness development takes sustained practice.
But it's complete. It addresses the root, not just symptoms.
DBT gave you skills to observe, accept, and skillfully respond -rooted in genuine Zen wisdom.
Steiner's framework explains the deeper structure and offers the path to develop consciousness further.
Use both. DBT for evidence-based skill development. Threefold practices for deepening into the structure of your being.
Because once you've stabilized through skills, you may be called to go further.
From managing experience to understanding the experiencer.
An Invitation to Therapists: Deepen Your Practice
The loneliness epidemic. The mental health crisis. The social fragmentation. They all point to the same thing: humanity has fragmented from its threefold nature.
We've developed extraordinary thinking capacity but at the cost of fragmenting from feeling and willing. We can analyze everything but struggle to feel authentically or act from genuine values.
DBT addresses this well -engaging witnessing consciousness through mindfulness, cultivating Wise Mind, developing skillful action. What if there's more for those who want it?
For therapists already using DBT:
This framework doesn't replace your training. It provides ontological context and deeper territory for clients who've stabilized and want to go further.
For clients in therapy:
Use your DBT skills. They work. And when you're ready, explore how the threefold framework can transform symptom management into structural healing.
This is collaboration, not competition. Therapy + ancient wisdom = complete approach.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I do this alongside DBT therapy?
Absolutely. Keep using your DBT skills for immediate support. Add the threefold practices for structural transformation. They complement each other perfectly.
How long until I see results?
Recognition phase (Month 1): You'll see your pattern clearly. Development phase (Months 2 to 7): Gradual strengthening of each faculty. Integration phase (Months 8 to 12): Noticeable shifts in how you respond to challenges. This is consciousness development, not a quick fix.
Why was this eliminated from Western consciousness?
Humans who know they're threefold can develop independent spiritual capacity. They don't need permanent external authority. The trichotomy was collapsed into dichotomy to ensure dependence on institutional mediation rather than sovereign spiritual development.
Is this religious?
No. This is phenomenological observation of consciousness structure. Steiner was trained in natural sciences and brought the same rigorous methodology to observing consciousness that science brings to physical phenomena. The trichotomy appears across cultures and wisdom traditions because it describes actual human structure.
Continue the Journey
This article honors Callista Forchuk's foundational work explaining DBT while revealing what modern therapy is missing: the complete threefold structure that ancient wisdom knew and Rudolf Steiner restored.
Want to go deeper?
- Steiner's The Philosophy of Freedom (1894) for the philosophical foundation
- Steiner's How to Know Higher Worlds (1904) for the complete practice system
- Our consciousness development series exploring practical integration
References
Forchuk, C. (2025). What is "dialectical" about Dialectical Behaviour Therapy (DBT)? CMBH Mental Health Services. https://www.cmbh.ca/18-11-2025/
Linehan, M. M. (1993). Cognitive behavioral treatment of borderline personality disorder. Guilford Press.
Linehan, M. M., & Wilks, C. R. (2015). The course and evolution of dialectical behavior therapy. American Journal of Psychotherapy, 69(2), 97-110.
Steiner, R. (1894/1964). The philosophy of freedom (M. Wilson, Trans.). Rudolf Steiner Press.
Steiner, R. (1904/2004). How to know higher worlds (C. Bamford, Trans.). Anthroposophic Press.
Steiner, R. (1906). The three fundamental forces: Thinking, feeling, and willing [Lecture]. Rudolf Steiner Archive.