Quick Answer
An anthropologist could not explain how the Ashaninca knew which two of eighty thousand plants to boil together, and would not accept their answer, which was that the plants told them. Ten years later he proposed that they were right in a way nobody had considered: that ayahuasca lets consciousness receive information from DNA, and that the serpents, ladders and twisted ropes of shamanic vision and world myth are the double helix seen from inside. Scientists dismissed the hypothesis and were mostly right to. But the puzzle Narby began from is real, the book is honest about its own reach, and its first hundred pages are the best account in print of what an outsider learns when he stops assuming the shaman is wrong.
Key Takeaways
- The ayahuasca puzzle: two plants, one enzyme, and no trial-and-error account that works.
- Two fluorescent serpents: Narby's own visions, and what they said.
- Serpents, ladders, ropes: the mythological catalogue as evidence.
- DNA as text: molecular biology told as a story.
- The hypothesis fails as science and survives as a question.
17 min read
What This Book Is
The Cosmic Serpent: DNA and the Origins of Knowledge was published in French in 1995 as Le Serpent cosmique and in English by Tarcher in 1998. It is around two hundred and fifty pages, of which nearly a third is notes, and the notes are part of the book: Narby uses them to give the evidence for claims he keeps brief in the text and to be candid about where the evidence is thin.
The structure is an investigation told in order. Narby begins with his fieldwork and the problem of how the Ashaninca know what they know. He describes his own ayahuasca sessions. He then follows the serpents of his visions through the anthropology of shamanism, through world mythology, and into molecular biology, and he arrives at a hypothesis that he states, tests as far as he can, and leaves for others. The last chapters consider what the hypothesis would mean and how it might be investigated.
It is a first-person book by a trained anthropologist who is careful to say what is observation, what is inference and what is speculation, and the care is why it has survived the dismissal of its central idea.
The claim, precisely. Narby does not claim that DNA is conscious, that the shamans are geneticists, or that ayahuasca is a microscope. He claims that there is a puzzle about the origin of indigenous botanical knowledge that science has not solved, that the shamans' own account of it, that the knowledge comes in visions from the plants, should be taken as data, and that a hypothesis linking the visions to DNA is worth testing. Reviewers who attacked a stronger claim attacked one he did not make.
Who Jeremy Narby Is
Jeremy Narby was born in Montreal in 1959, grew up in Canada and Switzerland, studied history at Canterbury and anthropology at Stanford, and in 1984 and 1985 lived among the Ashaninca of the Pichis Valley in the Peruvian Amazon for his doctoral fieldwork on the effects of development projects on indigenous land use. His thesis argued that the Ashaninca used the forest rationally and that the projects were destroying a working system. He has since worked for Nouvelle Planète, a Swiss organisation supporting indigenous land titling and forest conservation in the Amazon, and has written Intelligence in Nature, 2005, and co-edited Shamans Through Time, 2001, with Francis Huxley.
He is not a mystic and not a biologist. He is an activist anthropologist who came to the questions in this book through the practical problem of defending peoples whose knowledge was being dismissed by the institutions that controlled their land.
The Ashaninca and the Problem
The first chapter, and the book's foundation.
The Ashaninca, Narby found, had detailed and accurate knowledge of the medicinal properties of the plants around them, knowledge that Western pharmacology was then confirming and, in some cases, patenting. When he asked how they knew, they said the plants had told them, in visions induced by ayahuasca, and that the shamans, the ayahuasqueros, were those who could hear. Narby, a rationalist, took this as metaphor and looked for the real answer: trial and error over generations. The Ashaninca were patient with him and did not change their account.
He records his own resistance honestly. He could not believe that plants communicated and could not find an account of trial and error that explained the specific knowledge, and the chapter ends with him agreeing to drink the brew. He had not come to believe; he had run out of other ways to investigate.
The Ayahuasca Puzzle
The fact that carries the book.
Ayahuasca is not a plant but a combination. The vine, Banisteriopsis caapi, contains harmine and related beta-carbolines, which on their own produce mild effects. The leaves of Psychotria viridis contain DMT, one of the most powerful psychedelic compounds known, which on its own does nothing by mouth because an enzyme in the gut, monoamine oxidase, destroys it before it reaches the blood. The beta-carbolines in the vine inhibit that enzyme. Boiled together, the two plants produce visions that neither produces alone, and the mechanism was worked out by Western chemistry only in the twentieth century.
The Amazon contains around eighty thousand plant species. The Ashaninca and dozens of other peoples found this pairing, and the same pairing, across a region the size of Europe. Narby's question is how. The trial-and-error account requires that someone boiled a random vine with random leaves, drank the result, and happened on the one combination that works, and then that the discovery spread or was repeated across the basin. He does not say this is impossible. He says it is an explanation that has never been shown to work and that the shamans offer another one.
The Two Serpents
The second chapter, and the experience the rest of the book interprets.
Narby drank ayahuasca with a shaman named Carlos Perez Shuma and saw, among much else, two enormous fluorescent serpents, which told him, without words, that he was a human being and nothing more, and that he had been presumptuous to think otherwise. The visions were geometric, luminous and, he says, more real than the ordinary world; he also vomited copiously and was frightened. He drank a second time and saw the serpents again.
The account is brief, unembellished and free of the ecstatic tone that mars much writing about ayahuasca. Narby does not claim to have been enlightened. He claims to have seen serpents, to have found that ayahuasqueros across the Amazon see serpents, and to have wanted to know why. The chapter is a model of how to report visions as data rather than as testimony.
Defocalising
The method, and the book's proposal to its readers.
The shamans, Narby learned, describe their way of seeing as a defocalising: a relaxation of the ordinary focus so that what is ordinarily unseen can appear. He adopts the word for his method. He would set aside the reflex by which a scientist dismisses the shaman's account as superstition, and the reflex by which a mystic dismisses the scientist's account as reduction, hold the two side by side without forcing either, and look for the place where they might meet. He describes reading molecular biology and shamanic ethnography alternately for months until the serpents of one and the helices of the other began to overlay.
Whatever one makes of where the method led, the chapter is an honest account of how a hypothesis forms, and its refusal to choose a framework in advance is the book's intellectual virtue.
The Serpent in Myth
The middle chapters, and the book's catalogue.
Narby gathers the serpent from the traditions: the twin serpents of Amazonian cosmology, the rainbow serpent of Australia, the cosmic serpent of the Aztecs, the nagas of India, the serpent of Eden, the uraeus of Egypt, the caduceus of Hermes with its two snakes twined on a staff, the ouroboros, the kundalini serpent coiled at the base of the spine, the Chinese dragon. He notes that the serpent is everywhere the creator, the giver of life and knowledge, the guardian of the tree, and that it is very often double, twinned or twisted. He connects this to the shamans' reports that the serpents are the source of their knowledge and that they appear in visions as intertwined and luminous.
The catalogue is wide and the parallels are real. Its weakness, which critics pounced on, is that serpents are common in myth for reasons that need no DNA: snakes are common, dangerous, shed their skin and live in the ground, and the human imagination has had a long time to work with them.
Ladders, Ropes and the Axis
A refinement of the catalogue, and its more interesting half.
Beyond the serpent, Narby collects the twisted ladder, the rope to the sky, the vine as the shaman's path, the axis of the world around which two spiralling forms wind. Eliade's Shamanism, which Narby reads closely, had already gathered the ladder and the rope as universal shamanic images of ascent. Narby adds that the ladder is often twisted, that the rope is often double, and that ayahuasca's own name, in Quechua, means vine of the soul or vine of the dead, and that the vine is a climbing spiral. The images, he argues, converge on a form: two strands, twined around an axis, connecting worlds. That form is the double helix.
DNA as Text
The chapter that even hostile readers praised.
Narby explains molecular biology for the general reader: the double helix, the four bases, the code by which triplets of bases specify amino acids, the transcription of DNA into RNA and the translation of RNA into protein, the fact that the code is the same in every organism on earth, and the fact that the DNA in a single human body, uncoiled, would stretch to the sun and back many times. He dwells on the biologists' own language: DNA is a text, it is read, it is transcribed, it is edited, it contains information. He asks the reader to take the language seriously and to consider what it would mean if the text could, under some conditions, be perceived.
The chapter is lucid, accurate, and enthusiastic in a way that makes the science vivid, and it shows that Narby's interest in biology is real and not decorative.
Biophotons
The most speculative chapter and the mechanism the hypothesis needs.
Living cells emit a very weak light, biophotons, first measured by Alexander Gurwitsch in the 1920s and studied since by Fritz-Albert Popp and others, and DNA appears to be among the sources. Narby proposes that this emission could be the channel: that DNA, as a crystalline structure emitting coherent light, could transmit information, and that consciousness in the ayahuasca state, with the brain's ordinary filtering suppressed, could receive it. He describes the visions' luminosity, their geometric and crystalline character, and the shamans' reports of seeing by an inner light, and suggests they match.
He is explicit that this is speculation. The measured biophoton emission is on the order of a few photons per square centimetre per second, and no mechanism is known by which it could carry information to consciousness. The chapter is the point at which the book most clearly steps beyond what its evidence supports, and Narby says so in the notes.
The Hypothesis Stated
The claim in full, as Narby gives it.
That DNA and its cellular machinery are minded, in the sense that they process information and respond; that DNA emits photons; that in the defocalised state produced by ayahuasca, a shaman's consciousness can pick up biophotonic signals from the DNA of his own cells and of other organisms; that this is experienced as luminous serpents, ladders and geometric forms; that the information received includes knowledge of the properties of plants, since the plant's DNA specifies its chemistry; and that the world's serpent myths are the residue of this perception in cultures that once had shamans. He adds that the hypothesis is testable in principle, by studying biophoton emission and by comparing the visions of shamans with the structure of the molecules, and he calls for the tests.
The right way to read the book is to separate the puzzle from the solution. The puzzle is real: peoples without laboratories arrived at pharmacological knowledge, including a two-plant combination that depends on enzyme inhibition, that laboratories later confirmed, and the only account they offer is that the plants taught them. The solution, that they perceive DNA through biophotons, has no known mechanism and does not survive contact with molecular biology. But the failure of the solution does not dissolve the puzzle, and readers who dismiss the book because the DNA idea is wrong have usually not offered an account of the ayahuasca combination either. Narby's lasting contribution is to have made the puzzle impossible to ignore.
Crick and the Cosmic Origin
A late chapter, and a strange one.
Narby notes that Francis Crick, co-discoverer of the double helix, proposed in 1973 and in his 1981 book Life Itself that DNA is too complex to have arisen by chance on the early earth and may have been sent here by an advanced civilisation, a hypothesis Crick called directed panspermia. Narby does not endorse this, but he uses it to argue that the origin of DNA is an open question even among its discoverers, and that the shamans' claim to receive knowledge from a serpent that made the world is not obviously stranger than a Nobel laureate's claim that the molecule came from space. The chapter is rhetorically effective and scientifically beside the point, and it is where the book's tone shifts from investigation to advocacy.
What Scientists Said
The reception, which was cool.
Molecular biologists and neuroscientists who reviewed the book made four points. DNA cannot be perceived: there is no sensory or neural mechanism by which molecular structure could reach consciousness, and the ayahuasca state does not create one. Biophoton emission is far too weak and too incoherent to carry information, and there is no receiver. Serpents in myth have simpler explanations. And the ayahuasca combination, while remarkable, is not inexplicable: indigenous peoples experiment with plants constantly, the vine was probably used alone first, and additives were tried over centuries. The book was received, in scientific circles, as an interesting failure, and in some as a dangerous one, since it gave a scientific-sounding warrant to claims about ayahuasca that were spreading rapidly.
Narby has responded over the years with some patience, conceding that the mechanism is unknown while maintaining that the puzzle is real and that the dismissal is too quick.
What Survives the Objections
More than critics allowed.
The ethnographic record of what ayahuasqueros report is accurate and valuable. The account of the ayahuasca combination and the difficulty of the trial-and-error explanation is fair, and the trial-and-error account remains unproven. The demonstration that scientists use the language of text and information about DNA without asking what it implies is a philosophical point that has been made since by others. And the method, taking the indigenous account as data rather than as error, has become mainstream in ethnobotany, where researchers now routinely begin from what the shamans say. Narby's later work on intelligence in nature developed this without the DNA mechanism, and it has been better received.
The Ethical Argument
Present throughout and worth drawing out.
Narby began as a land-rights activist and the book is, beneath the hypothesis, an argument about whose knowledge counts. Pharmaceutical companies were patenting compounds that the Ashaninca had used for centuries, on the ground that the Ashaninca had not discovered them scientifically. Narby's point is that they had discovered them, by a method the companies did not understand, and that the dismissal of the method was a dismissal of the people. Whether or not DNA is involved, the book's insistence that indigenous knowledge is knowledge, and that its origin is a scientific question rather than a settled non-issue, has had effects in policy and in ethnobotany that outlast the biology.
Narby's Later Work
Intelligence in Nature, 2005, followed the question into biology proper, reporting on research into problem-solving in slime moulds, bees, plants and single cells, and arguing that intelligence is distributed through living systems rather than confined to brains. It drops the DNA hypothesis and the biophotons and is the better book as science. Shamans Through Time, with Francis Huxley, is a five-hundred-year anthology of Western reports on shamanism, from the conquistadors to the present, and shows how the dismissal Narby resists has a long history. Readers who find The Cosmic Serpent too speculative should try either.
The Prose
Plain, first-person and short-sentenced. Narby writes as an investigator reporting, not as a seer testifying, and the restraint is unusual in the literature of ayahuasca, most of which is neither. The notes are a second voice, more cautious and more scholarly, and the reader who ignores them misses half the book. There are no purple passages and no sermons. The book is short enough to read in two sittings and clear enough to argue with.
The Objections
Three.
The mechanism does not exist. No known process lets consciousness perceive DNA, and biophotons cannot supply one.
The parallels are cheap. Serpents and ladders are everywhere in myth for reasons that need no helix.
The advocacy shows. The later chapters argue for the hypothesis rather than testing it, and the Crick chapter is rhetoric.
Who Should Read It
Read it if you are interested in ayahuasca and want the best short account of what the shamans say they see, told by someone who neither believes nor dismisses.
Read it if you like a bold hypothesis argued honestly, with the speculation labelled as such.
Read it with Eliade's Shamanism, which supplies the comparative material, and with McKenna, whose stoned-ape and mushroom arguments are the wilder cousin.
Read the first four chapters and the DNA chapter if you read nothing else. The puzzle and the biology are the book; the hypothesis is the guess.
The serpents told Narby he was a human being and nothing more, and the book that followed is oddly faithful to that message. It does not claim that he became a shaman, or that ayahuasca made him wise, or that the plants speak to those who deserve it. It claims that a people knew something, that he could not explain how, and that the honest response was to take their explanation as a starting point rather than as an obstacle. The DNA hypothesis is what came of that, and it is probably wrong. The stance is what lasts: that when someone who has lived in a place for a thousand years tells you where their knowledge comes from, the scientific thing to do is to listen, and then to work out what they could possibly mean.
The ayahuasca puzzle, the two serpents, and the hypothesis that connects shamanic vision to the double helix, argued by an anthropologist who labels his guesses.
Affiliate disclosure: Thalira earns a small commission on purchases made through the link above, at no additional cost to you. Our account of the scientific rejection of the book's central hypothesis is given above and was not softened for the link.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is The Cosmic Serpent about?
An anthropologist's attempt to explain how Amazonian shamans know what they know about plants. Narby proposes that in ayahuasca visions they perceive, at the molecular level, the DNA in all living things, and that the twin serpents, ladders and cosmic ropes of world mythology are images of the double helix seen from within.
Who is Jeremy Narby?
A Canadian-born anthropologist, born 1959, who did doctoral fieldwork among the Ashaninca of the Peruvian Amazon in the 1980s, took his PhD at Stanford, and has since worked for a Swiss NGO supporting indigenous land rights. He later wrote Intelligence in Nature and co-edited Shamans Through Time.
What started the inquiry?
The Ashaninca told Narby that their botanical knowledge, including the ayahuasca brew itself, which combines two plants that only work together, came from the plants in visions. He could not accept this and could not explain the knowledge otherwise, and the book is the record of taking the claim seriously.
What is ayahuasca?
A brew of the Banisteriopsis caapi vine with the leaves of Psychotria viridis or similar plants. The leaves contain DMT, which is inactive by mouth; the vine contains harmine and related alkaloids that inhibit the enzyme that would destroy it. The combination, out of eighty thousand Amazonian plant species, is the puzzle Narby starts from.
What is the DNA hypothesis?
That DNA emits photons, that consciousness in the ayahuasca state can receive biophotonic information from the DNA of the shaman's own cells and of other organisms, and that this is experienced as the serpents, twisted ladders and luminous ropes of the visions. Narby offers it as a hypothesis for testing, not a proven fact.
What is the mythological evidence?
That twin serpents, cosmic serpents, ladders to the sky, twisted ropes and the axis of the world appear in shamanic and mythological traditions worldwide, from the Amazon to Australia to Egypt to the caduceus, and that these images match the structure of DNA. Narby catalogues them at length in the middle chapters.
Did scientists accept it?
No. Molecular biologists pointed out that DNA cannot be perceived by any known mechanism, that biophoton emission is far too weak to carry information to consciousness, and that serpents are common in myth because snakes are common in the world. The book is read as provocation rather than as science.
What is defocalisation?
Narby's term for the method he adopted: setting aside the reflex of scientific dismissal, holding two frameworks side by side, and looking for the point where they might touch. He borrows it from the shamans' own description of how they see, and it is the book's methodological proposal.
Did Narby take ayahuasca?
Yes, twice, and the book opens with his account of the visions, including two enormous fluorescent serpents that told him he was a human being and nothing more. The account is brief and unembellished, and it is what set the inquiry in motion.
Is the book anti-science?
No. Narby reads molecular biology closely and admiringly, quotes Crick and Watson, and argues that science has not yet explained where the shamans' knowledge comes from. His complaint is with dismissal, not with method.
What is the best part?
The first chapters, on the Ashaninca, the problem of plant knowledge and the visions, and the chapter on DNA as text, in which Narby makes molecular biology vivid for a general reader. The mythological catalogue is the weakest and the biophoton chapter the most speculative.
Who should read it?
Anyone interested in ayahuasca who wants a thoughtful account of what shamans say they see, readers who enjoy a bold hypothesis argued honestly, and anyone who has wondered how peoples without laboratories arrived at pharmacological knowledge that laboratories confirmed.
Take one explanation as data
Narby's method, before the DNA and the biophotons, was a discipline of listening: when the Ashaninca said the plants taught them, he stopped translating it into something he could accept and asked instead what it would have to mean for it to be true. Try the same with one account you have dismissed, from a tradition, a practitioner, a grandparent. Not to believe it, but to hold it as a report from someone who was there and to ask what they could be describing. Most of the time you will find a puzzle you had papered over. Occasionally you will find, as Narby did, that the puzzle is bigger than the answer you had, and that nobody has a better one.
Sources & References
- Narby, Jeremy. The Cosmic Serpent: DNA and the Origins of Knowledge, Tarcher/Putnam, 1998.
- Narby, Jeremy. Intelligence in Nature: An Inquiry into Knowledge, 2005.
- Narby, Jeremy and Francis Huxley, eds. Shamans Through Time: 500 Years on the Path to Knowledge, 2001.
- Eliade, Mircea. Shamanism: Archaic Techniques of Ecstasy, for the comparative material.
- Luna, Luis Eduardo and Pablo Amaringo. Ayahuasca Visions, 1991, for the visionary iconography.
- Crick, Francis. Life Itself: Its Origin and Nature, 1981.