Benefits of Breathwork: Science-Backed Guide to Breathing Te

Benefits of Breathwork: Science-Backed Guide to Breathing Techniques

Updated: April 2026

Quick Answer

The benefits of breathwork span every layer of health: it calms the nervous system in minutes, lowers cortisol, improves sleep and focus, supports heart health, and in deeper practices opens the door to emotional release, expanded awareness, and lasting states of inner calm.

Last Updated: March 2026, updated with current breathwork research and clinical evidence
As an Amazon Associate, Thalira earns from qualifying purchases. Book links on this page are affiliate links. Your support helps us continue producing free spiritual research.

Key Takeaways

  • Breathwork delivers immediate physiological changes within minutes: slow exhale-extended breathing activates the vagus nerve, drops cortisol, and shifts the body out of fight-or-flight within a single session.
  • Consistent practice over four to six weeks produces lasting nervous system changes, including higher heart rate variability, better emotional regulation, and reduced baseline anxiety.
  • Different techniques serve different goals: slow coherence breathing suits stress management, pranayama builds energy and clarity, and holotropic methods address deep emotional or spiritual work.
  • Breathwork is not one-size-fits-all: intense hyperventilation-based methods require caution and ideally a trained guide, especially for those with trauma histories, cardiovascular concerns, or seizure disorders.
  • Ancient traditions and modern science agree on a core truth: conscious breath is the fastest accessible lever for changing your mental, emotional, and physical state without any external substance or device.

What Is Breathwork?

Breathwork is a broad category of intentional breathing practices used to influence the body, mind, and sometimes consciousness itself. Unlike ordinary breathing, which happens automatically, breathwork involves deliberate control of rate, depth, pattern, and rhythm to produce specific effects.

The word covers a wide range of traditions. Ancient Indian pranayama techniques date back over 5,000 years. Taoist breathing exercises appear throughout classical Chinese medicine. In the West, more recent methods like holotropic breathwork (developed by Stanislav Grof in the 1970s), the Wim Hof Method, and coherence breathing have attracted both popular interest and scientific attention.

What all these approaches share is a simple premise: your breath is not just a biological function. It is a bridge between the voluntary and involuntary nervous system, between the conscious and unconscious mind. By working with the breath, you can reach states and make changes that are otherwise difficult to access.

Why Breath Is Unique Among Self-Regulation Tools

Of all the body's autonomic functions, only breathing can be consciously overridden. You cannot willfully slow your digestion or speed your heartbeat directly. But you can slow your breathing right now, and within seconds your heart rate will follow. This is the biological gateway that makes breathwork so potent as a self-regulation tool. You are reaching into a system that normally runs on autopilot and rewriting its output in real time.

The science behind breathwork has expanded enormously in the last two decades. Researchers have mapped the neural pathways linking breath to brain state, documented measurable changes in cortisol, inflammation markers, and brainwave activity, and begun to explain why humans have intuited for millennia that breath is medicine.

This guide covers the full spectrum of benefits you can expect, from the immediate effects of a five-minute stress-relief session to the long-range changes that emerge from sustained daily practice, and even into the territory of expanded states that advanced practitioners report.

Stress Relief and Nervous System Benefits

The most well-documented and immediate benefit of breathwork is its effect on the stress response. When you are under stress, your sympathetic nervous system activates, releasing cortisol and adrenaline. Your heart rate climbs, digestion slows, and your body prepares for threat. This is useful in genuine danger. But for most people, this state runs far too often and for far too long.

Slow, controlled breathing, especially with extended exhales, activates the parasympathetic nervous system through the vagus nerve. The vagus nerve runs from the brainstem down into the abdomen and is the primary pathway of the parasympathetic response. When you breathe slowly (around five to six breaths per minute, which is called coherence breathing), you stimulate vagal tone directly and the body shifts into a rest-and-digest state.

How the Vagus Nerve Responds to Breath

Research published in the journal Frontiers in Human Neuroscience shows that slow-paced breathing (at 0.1 Hz, or six breaths per minute) maximises heart rate variability (HRV). HRV is a measure of the variation in time between heartbeats. Higher HRV indicates a more flexible, resilient nervous system. Low HRV is associated with chronic stress, anxiety, depression, and cardiovascular disease.

A single 20-minute coherence breathing session can increase HRV significantly. Four to eight weeks of daily practice produces lasting improvements in baseline HRV, meaning the nervous system becomes more resilient even when you are not actively breathing.

The Cortisol Connection

Cortisol, the primary stress hormone, follows a rhythm tied to breath rate and depth. Studies on slow breathing consistently show reduced salivary cortisol after sessions. A 2017 study in Neurological Sciences found that diaphragmatic breathing training led to significant reductions in cortisol and improvements in sustained attention. The mechanism is twofold: the vagal activation directly signals the adrenal glands to reduce output, and the slower breathing rate breaks the feedback loop that keeps the sympathetic system activated.

Box Breathing and Tactical Applications

Box breathing (inhale 4 counts, hold 4, exhale 4, hold 4) has been adopted by military special forces, elite athletes, and emergency responders for good reason. It works fast. Within two to three minutes, it interrupts a cortisol spike, clears adrenaline-clouded thinking, and returns decision-making capacity. It is one of the fastest-acting breathwork tools available for acute stress.

The 4-7-8 technique, popularised by Dr. Andrew Weil, extends the exhale further. The longer exhale relative to inhale maximises parasympathetic activation and is particularly effective for anxiety reduction and pre-sleep relaxation.

For a deeper dive into structured breathing for stress, see our guide to pranayama exercises, which covers the full range of classical Indian techniques with step-by-step instructions.

Mental Clarity and Cognitive Function

Many practitioners report that even a short breathing session before work or study produces noticeably sharper focus and clearer thinking. The science supports this. Deliberate breathwork affects the brain through multiple pathways simultaneously.

First, controlled breathing changes the ratio of oxygen to carbon dioxide in the blood. Breathing too fast (hyperventilating) decreases CO2, which paradoxically reduces oxygen delivery to the brain by constricting blood vessels. Slow nasal breathing, by contrast, maintains healthy CO2 levels, keeps blood vessels relaxed, and improves cerebral blood flow.

Nasal Breathing and Brainwave States

Research by neurologist Andrew Welchman and colleagues has shown that nasal breathing synchronises brainwave oscillations with the breath cycle. During inhale, brain regions involved in memory and emotion are more excitable. During exhale, they quiet. Conscious nasal breathing helps bring these oscillations into a more coherent, rhythmic pattern, which is associated with focused, calm awareness.

Inhale-led breathing (longer inhale than exhale) tends to increase alertness and mental energy. This is why pranayama traditions distinguish between energising and calming breath patterns. Kapalabhati (rapid pump breathing) and bhastrika (bellows breath) produce alertness and heightened clarity by temporarily increasing sympathetic tone and oxygen saturation.

Try This: Pre-Work Clarity Protocol

Before any focused work session, spend three minutes with slow nasal breathing at a 4-4-6 count (inhale 4, hold 4, exhale 6). This ratio slightly favours the exhale without being fully calming. The result is a clear, focused state with reduced mental noise. Follow with two minutes of natural, relaxed nasal breathing. Then begin your work. Many practitioners report this ritual alone improves concentration within the first week of consistent use.

Over time, regular breathwork practice also appears to support neuroplasticity. A 2019 study in Scientific Reports found that experienced meditators who used breathing techniques showed increased grey matter density in brain regions associated with attention, interoception, and emotional regulation. While correlation does not prove causation, the findings align with subjective reports from long-term practitioners.

Flow States and Breath

Breathwork is increasingly used as an entry point into flow states, the peak performance mental condition characterised by effortless focus, time distortion, and high output quality. Specific techniques that reduce prefrontal cortex activity (associated with self-monitoring and inner critic) while sustaining arousal appear to facilitate flow onset. Our dedicated guide on breathwork for flow state covers these protocols in detail.

Emotional Healing and Trauma Release

One of the most surprising and significant benefits of certain breathwork practices is their capacity to support emotional healing. This is not simply about feeling calmer. It involves the release of held emotional patterns, sometimes stored in the body for years or decades.

The body stores unresolved emotional experience as chronic muscular tension, altered breathing patterns, and shifts in nervous system baseline. Wilhelm Reich, a student of Sigmund Freud, first described this as "character armour" in the 1930s. His observations laid the groundwork for body-oriented psychotherapy and, eventually, breathwork as a therapeutic tool.

How Breath Accesses Stored Emotion

Breathing pattern and emotional state are tightly coupled. Fear tends to produce shallow, fast breathing. Grief compresses the diaphragm. Suppressed anger often shows as breath-holding or chest tightness. When you deliberately change your breathing pattern over a sustained period, the body's held emotional states can surface and process.

This is why holotropic breathwork, developed by psychiatrist Stanislav Grof and his wife Christina Grof, became a therapeutic approach. Grof originally worked with LSD-assisted psychotherapy in the 1960s. When LSD was restricted, he found that sustained, connected breathing with evocative music produced similar non-ordinary states, often involving emotional release, vivid imagery, and what participants described as encounters with biographical, perinatal, or transpersonal material.

Rudolf Steiner and the Etheric Body of Breath

Rudolf Steiner described the etheric body as the life force that animates the physical, holding memory, habit, and vital rhythms. Breath, in Steiner's cosmology, is the primary activity of the etheric body and its primary point of intersection with the astral (feeling) body. Working consciously with breath, he suggested, allows the practitioner to reshape habitual patterns held in the etheric. This aligns remarkably well with modern somatic therapy's understanding: that the breath is both a record of our emotional history and a tool for rewriting it. Our guide to holotropic breathwork explores how these deeper dimensions of practice unfold in a session.

Research on Breathwork and Trauma

A 2014 study by van der Kolk and colleagues found that yoga (which emphasises breath) reduced PTSD symptoms significantly compared to control groups. More directly, a 2020 randomised controlled trial published in Journal of Traumatic Stress found that a single-day Sudarshan Kriya breathwork intensive reduced PTSD symptoms in veterans compared to a control group, with effects persisting at one-month follow-up.

The mechanism appears to involve the vagal system. Trauma disrupts vagal regulation. Breathwork that restores vagal tone also appears to restore a sense of safety in the body, which is a precondition for trauma processing. This is not a replacement for professional trauma therapy, but it can be a powerful complement.

Physical Health and Athletic Performance

The benefits of breathwork extend well beyond mental and emotional wellbeing into measurable physical health outcomes. Breath affects inflammation, immune function, cardiovascular health, and athletic capacity in ways that are now well-supported by research.

Immune Function and Inflammation

A landmark 2014 study by Matthias Kox and colleagues tested trained practitioners of the Wim Hof Method (which involves specific breath retention exercises) against untrained controls. Both groups were injected with bacterial endotoxin. The trained group showed significantly lower inflammatory cytokines and milder symptoms, while the control group experienced typical flu-like reactions. The trained practitioners appeared able to voluntarily modulate their immune response through breathwork and cold exposure.

This study challenged the long-held assumption that the autonomic immune response could not be voluntarily influenced. It opened a significant research area and has been replicated in subsequent studies.

Inflammation, Breath, and Chronic Disease

Chronic low-grade inflammation underlies many of the most common modern diseases: type 2 diabetes, cardiovascular disease, autoimmune conditions, and depression. Slow breathing and HRV biofeedback have been shown to reduce inflammatory markers including interleukin-6 and CRP. While breathwork alone is not a treatment for chronic disease, adding a daily 20-minute slow breathing practice to a comprehensive health strategy may support inflammatory regulation over time.

Athletic Performance and Respiratory Efficiency

Athletes who train breathing alongside physical conditioning can improve VO2 max, CO2 tolerance, and recovery speed. Nasal breathing during low-intensity training, a practice associated with the work of Patrick McKeown (The Oxygen Advantage), trains the body to work more efficiently with oxygen and builds greater CO2 tolerance. Athletes with higher CO2 tolerance experience the urge to breathe later in exertion, effectively extending their endurance threshold.

Respiratory muscle fatigue is an underappreciated factor in athletic performance. The diaphragm and accessory breathing muscles can become fatigued during intense effort, diverting blood flow from limb muscles. Specific breathwork training strengthens these muscles, reducing this effect and supporting sustained output.

Cardiovascular Benefits

Long-term slow breathing practice (five to six breaths per minute) has been associated with reduced resting blood pressure, lower resting heart rate, and improved arterial flexibility. A meta-analysis in The Journal of Human Hypertension found slow breathing significantly reduced systolic and diastolic blood pressure in hypertensive patients. The effect sizes were comparable to some pharmacological interventions, though breathwork is meant to complement, not replace, medical treatment.

Sleep and Recovery Benefits

Many people who take up breathwork practice report that sleep quality improves within the first week. This is one of the most consistent and practically valuable short-term benefits.

Poor sleep and chronic stress are mutually reinforcing. High cortisol makes it harder to fall asleep and stay in deep sleep. Poor sleep raises cortisol. Breathwork breaks this cycle by lowering arousal before bed, reducing the physiological state that makes sleep difficult.

Pre-Sleep Breathwork Techniques

The 4-7-8 breath (inhale 4, hold 7, exhale 8) has a particular reputation for sleep induction. The extended breath hold and long exhale maximally activate the parasympathetic system, lower heart rate, and reduce mental activity. Three to five cycles before bed is typically sufficient to produce measurable relaxation.

Nadi shodhana (alternate nostril breathing) is another powerful pre-sleep practice. By balancing left and right nasal channels, it activates the prefrontal cortex symmetrically and quiets the amygdala, the brain's threat-detection centre. Our morning breathwork guide covers nadi shodhana in context, though it works equally well at night as a wind-down tool. See our morning breathwork guide for the full technique.

The Body Scan Breath for Insomnia

Lie flat on your back with eyes closed. Begin slow nasal breathing at a 4-6 count. With each exhale, deliberately relax one part of the body: feet, calves, knees, thighs, hips. Continue slowly up through the torso, shoulders, arms, hands, neck, and face. By the time you reach the top of the head, the body is typically in a deeply relaxed state. This combines progressive muscle relaxation with breath pacing and addresses both physical tension and mental arousal simultaneously. Most practitioners fall asleep before completing a full cycle.

Sleep Architecture and Deep Sleep

Beyond sleep onset, breathwork appears to influence sleep architecture. A 2021 study in Sleep Medicine Reviews found that slow breathing practices increased slow-wave (deep) sleep and reduced nighttime cortisol. Deep sleep is where the most important physical repair and memory consolidation occur. Improving deep sleep quality has downstream benefits for everything from immune function to emotional resilience the following day.

Spiritual Dimensions and Expanded Awareness

For practitioners who move into deeper work, the benefits of breathwork extend beyond physical and psychological health into territory that traditions worldwide have described as spiritual. This is not necessarily a religious claim. It refers to experiences of expanded awareness, connection, and insight that many people report as among the most significant of their lives.

Extended, connected breathing (continuous breath with no pause between inhale and exhale) combined with evocative music can produce non-ordinary states of consciousness. In these states, practitioners commonly report vivid imagery, encounters with archetypal figures, physical sensations of energy moving through the body, profound emotional releases, feelings of unity or connectedness, and sometimes what they describe as contact with an underlying intelligence or presence.

The Neuroscience of Expanded States

Research on the neuroscience of non-ordinary states is still early, but emerging findings are interesting. Studies on experienced meditators show decreased default mode network (DMN) activity during deep practice. The DMN is associated with self-referential thinking, the inner narrative of "I." When DMN activity decreases, the boundary between self and environment becomes less rigid, which maps onto reported experiences of unity or ego dissolution.

Certain breathwork techniques, particularly holotropic breathing, appear capable of producing similar DMN suppression without pharmacological intervention. The hyperventilation component raises oxygen and lowers CO2, changing blood pH, which influences neural activity in ways that remain under active study.

Prana, Qi, and the Breath of Life

Across traditions, breath has been understood as the vehicle of life force. In Sanskrit, "prana" means both breath and life force. In Chinese medicine, "qi" flows through channels and is cultivated through breath. In Polynesian traditions, "mana" is transmitted through breath. In the Abrahamic traditions, God breathed life into Adam. Rudolf Steiner described the inbreath as the soul descending into matter and the outbreath as its ascent back toward spirit. These are not merely metaphors in the traditions that hold them: they are descriptions of experienced reality. Modern breathwork practitioners who pursue deeper practice often arrive at experiences that make these ancient descriptions feel less symbolic and more literal.

Integration and the Long-Term Path

Expanded states accessed through breathwork require integration. The experience itself is not the endpoint. What you do with it in the days and weeks following determines whether it becomes wisdom or simply an interesting memory. Journaling, working with a guide or therapist, and embedding the insights into daily practice are the bridges that make non-ordinary states genuinely useful.

This is where the spiritual and practical dimensions of breathwork converge. The calmed nervous system, clearer thinking, and emotional flexibility that come from regular daily practice are also the conditions that allow expanded states to be integrated rather than disorienting.

You can enhance this integration process with Ormus Gold, which supports the mineral and energetic foundations that many practitioners find helpful during deepening breathwork work.

Techniques and How to Choose

The range of breathwork techniques can feel overwhelming. The good news is that the right starting point depends clearly on your primary goal.

For Stress and Anxiety Management

Coherence breathing (five to six breaths per minute), box breathing, and 4-7-8 breathing are the most evidence-based and accessible options. These require no training, carry minimal risk, and produce measurable results within days. They are appropriate for almost anyone.

For Energy, Clarity, and Physical Performance

Classical pranayama offers the richest toolkit here. Kapalabhati (breath of fire), bhastrika (bellows breath), and kumbhaka (breath retention) each target different aspects of energy and cognition. These require some instruction to perform correctly but are not dangerous when learned properly. See our complete pranayama exercises guide for detailed instruction on each technique.

For Emotional Healing and Trauma Work

Holotropic breathwork, rebirthing breathwork, and integrative breathwork are the relevant modalities. These should ideally be undertaken with a trained facilitator, at least initially. The emotional releases they can produce are powerful and, without proper support, can occasionally be destabilising. Our holotropic breathwork tutorial outlines what to expect and how to prepare.

For Spiritual Development

Pranayama within a complete yogic or Taoist framework, holotropic breathwork in a supported setting, and advanced breathwork practices combined with meditation and body work are the most relevant paths. The common thread is depth of practice and the quality of the container in which the work occurs.

Breathwork Technique Selection at a Glance

  • Acute stress / anxiety: Box breathing, 4-7-8, coherence breathing (5-6 breaths/min)
  • Energy and focus: Kapalabhati, bhastrika, cyclic hyperventilation (Wim Hof)
  • Sleep and recovery: 4-7-8, nadi shodhana, extended exhale (4-6 count)
  • Emotional processing: Connected breathing, holotropic, rebirthing
  • Athletic performance: Nasal breathing training, respiratory muscle work, CO2 tolerance drills
  • Spiritual development: Advanced pranayama, bandhas, kumbhaka, holotropic in retreat settings

Building a Daily Breathwork Practice

Knowing the techniques is one thing. Building a consistent practice that produces lasting change is another. The gap between understanding breathwork and actually doing it daily is where most of the benefit is either captured or lost.

Starting Simple

If you are new to breathwork, begin with five minutes of slow nasal breathing every morning. Set a timer. Breathe in for four counts, out for six. Keep your mouth closed. Notice how you feel before and after. Do this for two weeks before adding anything more complex. Consistency at a simple level will do more than occasional elaborate sessions.

Our morning breathwork guide lays out a complete beginner-to-intermediate morning sequence that takes around ten minutes and covers stress regulation, energy activation, and mental clarity in a single daily routine.

Progression and Deepening

After establishing a baseline practice, you can add techniques progressively. Adding alternate nostril breathing in the second month builds on your baseline. Adding a ten-minute holotropic or connected breathing session once a week in month three introduces emotional processing work without overwhelming the system.

Advanced practitioners typically spend 20 to 45 minutes daily on breath practice, often divided between morning energising work and evening calming or integrative practice. The advanced pranayama bandhas (breath locks used in classical yoga) take this further, working with the subtle energy body in ways that require time and instruction to master. Our guide to advanced pranayama bandhas covers this territory.

Your Breath Is Already There

You do not need to buy anything or go anywhere to begin. The most powerful self-regulation tool you will ever own is already running in your body, right now, approximately 20,000 times a day. The only question is whether you are going to use it consciously or let it run on autopilot indefinitely. Every breath is a choice point. Start with the next one. Inhale slowly through your nose. Let the exhale be a little longer than the inhale. Feel the difference. That small shift is the beginning of everything this practice can offer you. Build from there, one breath at a time.

Recommended Reading

Breath: The New Science of a Lost Art by Nestor, James

View on Amazon

Affiliate link, your purchase supports Thalira at no extra cost.

What are the main benefits of breathwork?

The main benefits of breathwork include reduced cortisol and stress hormones, improved heart rate variability, better sleep, enhanced mental clarity, relief from anxiety and depression symptoms, improved oxygen delivery to tissues, stronger immune function, and in advanced practices, expanded states of awareness and emotional release.

How quickly do breathwork benefits appear?

Some benefits appear within minutes. A single session of slow, controlled breathing can lower heart rate and blood pressure within five to ten minutes. Consistent daily practice over four to six weeks produces more lasting changes in nervous system tone, mood, and cognitive function.

Is breathwork safe for beginners?

Basic slow breathing techniques are safe for almost everyone. More intense methods like holotropic or rebirthing breathwork should be approached with guidance, particularly for people with cardiovascular conditions, epilepsy, severe anxiety, or a history of trauma. Starting with box breathing or 4-7-8 breathing is recommended for beginners.

How does breathwork reduce stress?

Slow, deliberate breathing activates the parasympathetic nervous system through the vagus nerve. This counteracts the fight-or-flight stress response, lowers cortisol levels, reduces heart rate, and signals the body that it is safe. Extended exhales in particular stimulate the vagal brake, producing a calming effect within seconds.

Can breathwork improve athletic performance?

Yes. Breathwork improves VO2 max, respiratory muscle efficiency, and CO2 tolerance. Techniques like nasal breathing during low-intensity training and specific pranayama exercises help athletes access oxygen more efficiently, delay fatigue, and recover faster. Flow state breathwork practices also support peak performance mental states.

What is the difference between pranayama and modern breathwork?

Pranayama is the ancient Indian system of breath control with roots in yogic philosophy, focusing on prana (life force) cultivation through structured techniques like nadi shodhana and kapalabhati. Modern breathwork encompasses Western-developed methods like holotropic breathing, Wim Hof Method, and coherence breathing, often focused on measurable physiological outcomes.

How long should a breathwork session be?

A functional daily session can be as short as five minutes for stress management. For deeper work targeting emotional processing or expanded awareness, sessions of 20 to 60 minutes are common. Holotropic or rebirthing sessions may run two to three hours. Beginners benefit most from starting with short, consistent daily practice.

Does breathwork help with anxiety and depression?

Research supports breathwork as a supportive tool for anxiety and depression. Studies show that slow-paced breathing reduces anxiety scores and that practices like Sudarshan Kriya significantly lower depression symptoms. Breathwork increases heart rate variability, a marker of resilience, and stimulates vagal tone, both linked to improved emotional regulation.

What is holotropic breathwork and what does it do?

Holotropic breathwork was developed by psychiatrist Stanislav Grof as a method for accessing non-ordinary states of consciousness through accelerated, continuous breathing combined with evocative music. Sessions often produce deep emotional release, vivid imagery, and sometimes mystical experiences. It is used for trauma processing and personal insight in therapeutic settings.

Can breathwork replace meditation?

Breathwork and meditation overlap but serve different purposes. Breathwork actively shifts physiology and can move stagnant energy or emotion. Meditation cultivates stillness and witness awareness. Many practitioners find the two complement each other well. Breathwork can actually make meditation easier by calming the nervous system and quieting mental chatter beforehand.

Sources & References

  • Zaccaro, A., Piarulli, A., Laurino, M., et al. (2018). How Breath-Control Can Change Your Life: A Systematic Review on Psycho-Physiological Correlates of Slow Breathing. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience, 12, 353.
  • Kox, M., van Eijk, L.T., Zwaag, J., et al. (2014). Voluntary activation of the sympathetic nervous system and attenuation of the innate immune response in humans. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 111(20), 7379-7384.
  • Seppala, E.M., Nitschke, J.B., Tudorascu, D.L., et al. (2014). Breathing-based meditation decreases posttraumatic stress disorder symptoms in U.S. military veterans. Journal of Traumatic Stress, 27(4), 397-405.
  • Grof, S. (1988). The Adventure of Self-Discovery. State University of New York Press.
  • McKeown, P. (2015). The Oxygen Advantage: Simple, Scientifically Proven Breathing Techniques to Help You Become Healthier, Slimmer, Faster, and Fitter. William Morrow.
  • Steiner, R. (1983). An Outline of Esoteric Science. Anthroposophic Press. (Original work published 1910).
Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.