Steiner's account of willing: every act of will is a dying process held back at its embryonic stage, never carried through, because completion would be death.
The Will as Embryonic Dying in Anthroposophy is Rudolf Steiner's account of what willing actually is, a dying process arrested at its embryonic stage and never carried through to the end. He set it out in the sixth lecture of the Zurich series published in English as Anthroposophy has Something to Add to Modern Sciences (GA 73), given on 10 October 1918. Steiner paired it with its opposite pole: forming ideas is an attenuated being born, pictorial and therefore unreal, while willing is an attenuated dying, embryonic and therefore fully real. What makes will into will, on this reading, is precisely that the process stops short. A will intent grown to full strength would be death itself, so the human being carries the forces of death continuously, in miniature, inside every deed. This is why the will stays dark to a thinking trained only on outer nature, and why anthroposophic soul research approaches it through sleep, through metabolism, and through the moment of death.
The will as embryonic dying is Steiner's answer to why willing feels opaque from the inside. Thinking hands us pictures we can inspect at leisure. Willing hands us a reality we cannot watch, because it is a real process deliberately halted before it finishes. Steiner set willing beside falling asleep and dying in one triad, and forming ideas beside waking and being born in the other.
In Steiner's Own Words
Will intent is a reality; it is not image but reality. But it is an act that is not as yet completed. If it were to be complete, if the act of will were to be fully grown, it would always be a process of dying. What makes the will into will is that whatever evolves in will intent remains embryonic and does not enter into existence in reality. For if it were to develop further from the embryonic state of will intent and gain full strength, it would always be a dying process. In our will intent we are potentially dying all the time. We bear the powers of death in us. And for someone able to penetrate the soul as an investigator, every act of will is an attenuated dying process that has remained embryonic.
What it Means Today
Steiner gave the claim a physiological edge in the question period after that same Zurich evening, saying that grasped physically the will process is a toxic process, so that every deed leaves breakdown products behind in the organism. For most of the twentieth century that sentence read as speculation. Then came the sleep work of Maiken Nedergaard's laboratory at the University of Rochester Medical Center, reported in Science in 2013 by Lulu Xie and colleagues. Their measurements showed that the interstitial space of the mouse brain expands by roughly sixty percent during sleep, and that clearance of metabolic waste, beta-amyloid among it, rises sharply while the animal is unconscious. Waking activity accumulates the residue. Sleep flushes it. The shape is the one Steiner started from, reached from the microscope end rather than the meditative end.
Thalira synthesis: the worth of Steiner's formulation is not that it anticipated a 2013 result, but that it names what the result leaves untouched, namely why an activity that is destructive at the level of tissue is experienced from the inside as freedom.
Practically, this changes what a person watches for. Tiredness after a day of decisions is the residue of a hundred dying processes stopped in time, and its ordinary remedy, sleep, is the same threshold in small that dying is in full.
Where to Read More