Steiner's name for the medieval shift in which town life, severed from the soil, replaced picture consciousness with the first abstract thinking.
The Town and the Birth of Abstraction in Anthroposophy is Rudolf Steiner's account of how urban settlement between the tenth and thirteenth centuries ended Europe's land-bound picture consciousness and produced the first genuinely abstract thinking. Steiner set it out in the lecture of 16 May 1921 at Dornach, printed in English as European Spiritual Life in the 19th Century (GA 325). Village populations, he argued, lived in a half-waking dream tied to particular places, and their sagas, premonitions and riddles carried the spiritual life of the local cults. When people moved into the growing towns of the eleventh, twelfth and thirteenth centuries they kept the inner personal life but lost its soil, so the same content reappeared in a thinner, more conceptual form. That thinning is the seedbed of the intelligence which surfaces across Europe in the fifteenth century, and of the modern habit of thinking in concepts rather than in pictures.
The Town and the Birth of Abstraction names the hinge Steiner placed between two ways of knowing. Country life gave pictures that arrived like dreams and belonged to a place. Town life gave concepts that belonged to nobody in particular. Steiner treats the medieval town not as an economic fact but as an organ of consciousness, the place where European thinking first had to be produced rather than received.
In Steiner's Own Words
When we come to the tenth and eleventh centuries we see a change in the external life. Even earlier, but at this time more markedly so, we see life centering itself in the towns. That life of picture-like waking dreams which I have described to you is altogether bound up with the soil. As, therefore, in the ninth, tenth, eleventh and twelfth centuries the whole country became covered with larger towns, in these towns another kind of thinking began to develop. Men living in towns had a different kind of thought. They were cut off from the places in which their local cults had developed, their attention was more directed towards what was human.
What it Means Today
Secular medieval history arrives at the same turning point from the outside. Alfred W. Crosby's The Measure of Reality: Quantification and Western Society, 1250-1600, published by Cambridge University Press in 1997, argues that Western Europe exchanged one model of reality for another between roughly 1275 and 1325, and that the new model was quantitative where the old one had been qualitative. Crosby's evidence is a cluster of town instruments from the same two generations: the mechanical clock striking equal hours from municipal towers around 1300, the portolan chart that replaced the symbolic mappa mundi with measured coastlines, the mensural notation that fixed musical duration on a grid, and the double-entry ledgers kept by Italian merchants and later codified by Luca Pacioli at Venice in 1494. Perspective construction in painting follows the same logic a century on. Each device takes something that had been lived qualitatively, time, space, sound, value, and makes it countable. Crosby locates the change in the towns Steiner names, and dates it to the century Steiner points at.
Thalira synthesis: Crosby describes the instruments and Steiner describes the organ, and the two accounts only lock together if abstraction is read as a faculty that had to be grown rather than a technique that happened to be invented. The practical use of the term is diagnostic. When a thought feels weightless, the question is what soil it was cut from, because Steiner's claim is that abstraction is not an error, it is what remains of a picture once the place has been taken away.
Where to Read More