Steiner's three-stage portrait of the educator: the Greek gymnast formed the whole body, the Roman rhetorician formed speech, the modern professor only transmits knowledge.
The Gymnast, the Rhetorician, and the Professor in Anthroposophy is Rudolf Steiner's typology of the educator across three epochs of Western civilisation, given in the ninth lecture of Human Values in Education (GA 310), Arnhem, 24 July 1924. The Greek teacher was a gymnast: he schooled the whole human being through movement, and let thinking, feeling, and willing grow out of a rightly moved body. The Roman and medieval teacher was a rhetorician: he worked on one part of the human being, beautiful speech, which still engages the body down to the diaphragm. Since the sixteenth century the teacher has become the professor, whom Steiner calls a Zivilisationsskelett, a skeleton of civilisation, because he imparts knowledge instead of forming human beings. Steiner states the pedagogical demand plainly: the professor must be superseded, and education must turn again to the whole human being. Waldorf movement teaching is the practical answer.
The Gymnast, the Rhetorician, and the Professor is not a list of professions but a measurement of shrinkage. Steiner traces what each epoch believed a teacher was for, and finds the target narrowing: from the moving human being, to the speaking human being, to the knowing head. Each step buys precision, and each step pays for that precision in wholeness.
In Steiner's Own Words
Just as the Roman educator was the rhetorician, so is our educator the doctor, the professor. If the gymnast was still a complete human being, if the rhetorician, when he appeared in public, wished at least to be a representative human being, so our professor has ceased to be a human being at all. He denies the human being and lives more and more in sheer abstractions; all he is now is a skeleton of civilisation. Therefore, in more modern times at any rate, the professor adopts the fashion of dressing like a man of the world; he no longer cares to wear cap and gown in the lecture room, but dresses in such a way that it is not apparent immediately that he is merely a skeleton of civilisation. Ever since the 16th century our entire education has been focused on the professor.
What it Means Today
The clearest modern answer to Steiner's complaint sits in a gymnasium, not a lecture hall. In 1922 Count Fritz von Bothmer joined the first Waldorf School in Stuttgart as its movement teacher and worked out, on Steiner's indications, the graded sequence of exercises now taught as Bothmer Gymnastics. They are not fitness drills. Each exercise asks the pupil to feel a direction in space and then to answer it: rising, widening, closing, falling. Bothmer graded them to the ages Steiner described, so that a nine-year-old and a fifteen-year-old meet different spatial questions on the same floor. Bothmer Movement International still trains teachers in the sequence, and it remains part of the movement curriculum in the Waldorf schools that carry it.
Thalira synthesis: the gymnast, the rhetorician, and the professor Steiner describes are not three job titles but three depths of contact with the child, and Bothmer's contribution was to show that the deepest of the three can be rebuilt deliberately rather than merely mourned. A teacher who has brought a class to throw, to balance, and to recover has already taught something about consequence that no diagram of consequence will teach. That is what Steiner meant by turning attention back to the whole human being: not adding gym periods to an intellectual timetable, but letting the intellect grow out of a body that has been asked real questions.
Where to Read More